NY Pie (Hendersonville)
$ • Pizza, Vegetarian
Hours:
305 Indian Lake Blvd, Hendersonville
(615) 431-5618
About NY Pie (Hendersonville)
Customers' Favorites
NY Pie (Hendersonville) Reviews
Share your opinion about NY Pie (Hendersonville)
Love the staff at this location! They are always busy, but make you feel welcome. Best NY style pizza in town! I love to pick up a par baked pie to take home for dinner when traveling through that area.
had the absolute worst service there again. that's why we stopped going years ago. My wife commented on how many tickets they had and i counted just 9. we waited 40 minutes for a pepperoni pizza. We thought the table behind us (whi ordered and sat after us) was getting up to check on their order so I got up too. he was getting a to go box. when I complained the snot nosed brat that they said was the 'manager' got a crappy attitude and just made excuses. They didn't even try to...read full review
We love NY Pie! We’ve been coming for years since the kids were small. And now they’re big and still play with the pizza dough. Ha! Seriously the best NY style pizza you’ll find anywhere around here🍕
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8:30PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8:30PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8:30PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8:30PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8:30PM |
People in Hendersonville Also Viewed
NY Pie in Hendersonville offers a pizza experience that is reminiscent of New York-style pizza, according to some customers. The crust is described as chewy and the pizza as a whole is considered very good, although it is noted that the seasoning could be improved. Customers often praise the large 18-inch pizzas, which are well priced and perfect for sharing. The restaurant features plenty of booths and comfortable seats, making it a good place to enjoy a meal. The gluten-free options are excellent, with some customers saying they did not feel like they missed out on anything, and the pizza reminded them of Italian pizza from their childhood. The margarita pizza is often praised as one of the best in a while, especially for garlic lovers.
Recent reviews highlight that the staff is great—young, attentive, and willing to do what needs to be done. Orders placed for to-go are well executed, with pizzas being hot and fresh to the table, and customers recommend adding extra cheese for the best flavor. One customer shared a positive experience with a large order of 9 pizzas for a family birthday, appreciating the staff's help and punctuality. Customers also mention that the service is friendly and approachable, with the staff being available and caring.
Although there have been some slower days, customers have noted that when the staff is on point, the experience is excellent. For example, a customer praised the antipasto salad made fresh and well balanced, and the beer service was noted as cold, crisp, and ready to refill. Overall, NY Pie provides a friendly atmosphere with good pizza, attentive service, and a positive experience that makes many look forward to their next visit.