I went to pick up some cheesecake. It was after their listed open hours, but no one was there and the doors were locked. Is this place still open?
Joe N.
Found this on Yelp and been a few times in the past (probably pre Covid was the last time we got some, since it's not close to home) but we have our favorites! Bananas cream and triple chocolate. This time we decided to try Coconut Lime which wasn't too tart , more coconut flavor so we enjoyed this as well. Not bad for 3 slices -- around $16. Super small location. Definitely a pick up and go spot only. Parking can be limited depending on when you go since there are a few lil restaurants at this tiny "strip mall". It's so small that I'm not sure it's considered a strip mall. Note: check in on Yelp when you get there, they have a special discount for 1st time purchases.
Ky W.
Great spot for cheesecake. Perfect location to grab and go. I went all out and got the party platter. Everything was great! My fam killed the cheese cake; ate the whole thing. Everything was gone by the next morning.
Elis Hassin
Cute place with cheesecake that is to die for. Would definitely recommend.
We loved it here! Or server, I think her name was Camille, was super friendly and helped us know what to choose.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
Jessica Dimas-Walsh
I really think we would have loved it, but both of the cheesecakes we received were frozen in the middle.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Zak Gowans
I recently visited this charming cheesecake shop and had a decently good experience. The cheesecake, while tasty, had a slight issue with being a bit frozen in the middle, which was a minor disappointment. However, the atmosphere of the shop was delightful, with its cozy and cute ambiance. I'd recommend giving it a try, but perhaps ask for a slice that's not too cold next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake, Dasani Bottled Water
Kelsey K.
This place has amazing keto cheesecake! Don't hesitate to try it, you won't be disappointed. The guy at the counter was really helpful and friendly and I wish I had an option like this where I live in Southern California. I'd be a regular.
Zane Maguet
This is one of my favorite places in Provo to get cheesecake! They have several good options that are all reasonably priced.
Kevin Wirfs
We have been wanting to try Simply Cheesecake for awhile but we’re never in Provo when they are open.We saw them on door dash so we put an order in! They did not disappoint! It is delicious!They were out of one of the flavors that we ordered but, unlike most places we have door dashed before when they are out of something they just replace it with something else without letting you know, if they do anything at all. They called us to let us know they were out of one of the items and let us pick a different flavor. When the order arrived it had an extra treat for us to try for the inconvenience. They went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. Thank you!!!
My Boyfriend loves cheesecake and I wanted to surprise him with some and he was is awe I He loved every bite and is telling me how we need to go back!! We got the cookies and cream and turtle pecan one. We both liked the cookies and cream better
Mary Derby
We came and ordered just a slice of cheesecake with the intent for it to be enjoyed right when we got home. Unfortunately, it was frozen which was not ideal and then when parts were finally defrosted the texture was still not amazing. Not the experience we were hoping for.
Tory Janssen
The cookie dough cheesecake is the best! Went here for my birthday and got 3 different flavors. The second best is the cookies and cream one. The other flavor I got was red velvet and it was alright. Their cheesecake is more of a “whipped” texture but the flavor was great.Cute little shop inside. The gentleman working was very nice and helpful.
Hailey S.
Cheesecake was fluffy instead of creamy and overly sweet. I can't put my finger on what it was but the texture was just off. Especially the texture of the red velvet, it was not enjoyable in my opinion. The lemon raspberry was okay.
Peak Pagez
They were not open during their posted hours when we tried to come in and eat. We drove a good 30 minutes just to find it closed up early.
I went to pick up some cheesecake. It was after their listed open hours, but no one was there and the doors were locked. Is this place still open?
Found this on Yelp and been a few times in the past (probably pre Covid was the last time we got some, since it's not close to home) but we have our favorites! Bananas cream and triple chocolate. This time we decided to try Coconut Lime which wasn't too tart , more coconut flavor so we enjoyed this as well. Not bad for 3 slices -- around $16. Super small location. Definitely a pick up and go spot only. Parking can be limited depending on when you go since there are a few lil restaurants at this tiny "strip mall". It's so small that I'm not sure it's considered a strip mall. Note: check in on Yelp when you get there, they have a special discount for 1st time purchases.
Great spot for cheesecake. Perfect location to grab and go. I went all out and got the party platter. Everything was great! My fam killed the cheese cake; ate the whole thing. Everything was gone by the next morning.
Cute place with cheesecake that is to die for. Would definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake, Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
We loved it here! Or server, I think her name was Camille, was super friendly and helped us know what to choose.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
I really think we would have loved it, but both of the cheesecakes we received were frozen in the middle.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I recently visited this charming cheesecake shop and had a decently good experience. The cheesecake, while tasty, had a slight issue with being a bit frozen in the middle, which was a minor disappointment. However, the atmosphere of the shop was delightful, with its cozy and cute ambiance. I'd recommend giving it a try, but perhaps ask for a slice that's not too cold next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake, Dasani Bottled Water
This place has amazing keto cheesecake! Don't hesitate to try it, you won't be disappointed. The guy at the counter was really helpful and friendly and I wish I had an option like this where I live in Southern California. I'd be a regular.
This is one of my favorite places in Provo to get cheesecake! They have several good options that are all reasonably priced.
We have been wanting to try Simply Cheesecake for awhile but we’re never in Provo when they are open.We saw them on door dash so we put an order in! They did not disappoint! It is delicious!They were out of one of the flavors that we ordered but, unlike most places we have door dashed before when they are out of something they just replace it with something else without letting you know, if they do anything at all. They called us to let us know they were out of one of the items and let us pick a different flavor. When the order arrived it had an extra treat for us to try for the inconvenience. They went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. Thank you!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
My Boyfriend loves cheesecake and I wanted to surprise him with some and he was is awe I He loved every bite and is telling me how we need to go back!! We got the cookies and cream and turtle pecan one. We both liked the cookies and cream better
We came and ordered just a slice of cheesecake with the intent for it to be enjoyed right when we got home. Unfortunately, it was frozen which was not ideal and then when parts were finally defrosted the texture was still not amazing. Not the experience we were hoping for.
The cookie dough cheesecake is the best! Went here for my birthday and got 3 different flavors. The second best is the cookies and cream one. The other flavor I got was red velvet and it was alright. Their cheesecake is more of a “whipped” texture but the flavor was great.Cute little shop inside. The gentleman working was very nice and helpful.
Cheesecake was fluffy instead of creamy and overly sweet. I can't put my finger on what it was but the texture was just off. Especially the texture of the red velvet, it was not enjoyable in my opinion. The lemon raspberry was okay.
They were not open during their posted hours when we tried to come in and eat. We drove a good 30 minutes just to find it closed up early.