11 Best Italian Restaurants near Fishersville

“Tony’s is the best! We love the pizza, Stromboli’s , salads and more!! Service is great and atmosphere is cozy, restaurant is super clean . Make a visit, you will be wanting to go back! 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This has become one of our favorite places to eat. Excellent food at excellent prices. My sister-in-law lived in Italy several years and said the food reminders her of there.“

“Best Italian in the Valley!! Hands down!“

“Nothing staff is unprofessional. Orders were wrong. Waitress cussed and carried on during our dining experience with another staff member. Food was good when waitress finally got the order correct.“

“Family owned and always offering amazing food. You can’t go wrong here!“

“This gem may be a little out of your way but is well worth the trip. We were welcomed with a warm smile as we walked in and we were seated right away. We had a very kind lady take our order and she was patient and helpful with me as I was deciding what I would eat. I chose the Stromboli and it was DELICIOUS but I couldn't eat it all! It had pepperoni, peppers, sausage, and mozzarella. And the sauce was so yummy and bursting with flavor. Definitely going back!“

“Pizza was really good. We were somehow forgotten, and it took us over an hour to get our pizza, but they very nicely removed those from our ticket and tried to rectify the error. I just wish they had noticed we were waiting before it had been that long. But I'm really glad we waited until after the show to go, or we would have been very upset and really hungry at the play across the street.“

“Waitress was kind, attentive, offered refills. Bread was warm and crispy. Alfredo was creamy, but it needed a lot of salt, there wasn't much cheese flavor or hints of garlic (minus one star). Fettuccine was perfectly aldente. The sausage had a good fennel flavor but was in a casing like a brat. The tiramisu was perfect, absolutely perfect. There are several dessert options. There was no one else in the restaurant at 530pm. ?‍♀️ By the time I left, there were 3 tables seated and there had been several to-go pickup orders.“

“My family visited Maria's Pizza while traveling through Staunton. We were very satisfied. Their pizza was delicious! That says alot coming from a New Yorker! Kudos Maria and staff. Thanks again, it was nice meeting you all!“

“Great food. Great service.“

“Food-The sub was the bomb! No gristle, gristly (did I spell that right?) pieces!! I asked for the cheese steak hoagie without the cheese, add lettuce, tomato and light mayo. That was delicious!!Service- the lady that answered the phone was awesome! Kind & courtesy!Atmosphere- needs a major overhaul! Meaning it was decorated by the original owner in 199something....“