13 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“Made a random stop on our drive from North Carolina to Ohio. The food was excellent, but we were inpressed with the customer service. Every single employee was friendly and helpful. We would have stopped to enjoy a drink, but were anxious to get back on the road. All around a positive experience!“

“I was hungry and weary after a two week stretch from hell and a long, hot day. The focaccia transported my mind and palate to a garlicky Italian paradise.The gramigna cacio e pepe (add the guanciale, it's worth it!) was probably the best pasta I've ever tasted, and it has inspired me to come back to try everything on the menu in the future.The tiramisu is the best I've had since a friend from Rome made some right in front of me many years ago. Pretty much a perfect restaurant all around. I think after years of obsessive exploration of Mexican food I will begin a new era of exploring more of Italian cuisine. Osteria Maria will be remembered as the catalyst.Clearly there's a lot of love put into everything at Osteria Maria and I hope the family and restaurant remains successful for many years to come.“

“Had an amazing chicken alfredo pizza that I will definitely be coming back for my husband greatly enjoyed the lasagna my two sons enjoyed both their dishes of calzone and manicotti they at the end was the final wonderful piece of an amazing dinner dessert. Do yourself a favor and give it a “

“We had not ordered from Claudio's in quite some time but I was in the mood for a calzone so we chose Claudio's. I was happy with my choice and the kids enjoyed the large pepperoni pizza they got. Overall pretty good meal. I'd be curious to try some other options like their meals and sandwiches. Maybe next time.“

“We loved the food and service here! Portion size is very generous for a great price! My only suggestion is to do something about the bathroom situation. There is only one bathroom for the entire restaurant to share (patrons and employees) and the line can become very long.“

“Picture this: Carmela greets you with her effervescent smile from across the restaurant. Her brother, arms in perpetual motion behind her, working the dough. Lovely, quiet music playing. This is what I encounter every week when I go for an awesome casual dinner. The food is prepared to your specifications, don't be afraid to tell them what you want, and great every time. Highly recommend the subs, salads, pizzas...“

“Had Easter dinner at Carrabba's/ 0226. Food was delicious and server (Janette C) did an outstanding job. She hustles and is focused on service, glad we were seated in her section.“

“The Steak & Cheese was awesome - my son described it as probably the best Steak & Cheese he had eaten in his life. We also had the Super Italian Sub and it was also at least the best I had in a long while. The french fries were also awesome - crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, just as fries were meant to be! Will definitely be ordering from them again soon!!“

“???Great place! Seriously, their pizza is amazing, and you get so much bang for your buck. The staff are super cool and always make you feel welcome. Plus, if you're after a tasty meal that won't make you feel like you've swallowed a brick, this is the spot.“

“I have eaten pizza from all around the world always paying attention to some of the best pizzas I have had. This pizza comes in as the second best pizza I have had around the world and that is a very high placement. Absolutely amazing and perfectly done.“

“This was our first time here, and let me just say it was one of the best Italian Boli's (pepperoni and sausage - which tasted amazing) stromboli's we've had.The dough, made from scratch, was so delicious. We also ordered Jalapeño Poppers that were just as great.The one thing I didn't care for was the cheese bread. I didn't like the sliced cheese on it. Otherwise, everything else was worthwhile.The server was one of the friendliest we have had.The only "complaint" would be the water. It tasted like tap water, which in some cases is not bad, but in this instance, it was not very tasty.We definitely will return when and if we are in the area again.“

“I have been a regular customer for many years. I have seen this location change ownership several times. I MUST say that the newest owner is THE BEST ! He greets me with a friendly smile and welcome. The food quality and service has improved noticeably. Also, he has selected a good crew. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Paisano's Pizza in Winchester !!!“

“We ordered from here a couple times so far. My husband says the pizza is great, I got the chicken piccata and that was really good too. They accidentally gave us regular pasta as opposed to gluten free and were so nice about it when we called! They sent someone right over with gluten free pasta at no extra charge. Highly recommend :)“