11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cedarburg

“I had the special this month, which was a chicken. Avocado, bacon bread, red onion sub. Starting with the bread, it was just absolutely perfect. The bread was crunchy on the outside. Soft on the inside all the ingredients were extremely fresh. Also had a side of chili which was really tasty. I look forward to my next visit.“

“Solid food, good outdoor seating in the summer, cozy block corner with lots of mature trees. Highly suggest stopping in, even if it's just the once.This place isn't for everyone. But for those that it is, it's very well loved. It's almost always at least a little busy. Locals mostly. There's great parks near by so highly suggest, if the parking lot is too crowded for you, to stop at one of those. Custard is solid, fries are solid, the rest is on preference. Food ranges from good cookout to excellent diner. Hard to go wrong. Never going to have something you hate.“

“I wish I could break the scale for this review!Whenever I had the cream pig last, it was THE BEST cheese filled brat. The staff were RIDICULOUSLY friendly, the food was exquisite! I was bummed to learn I didn't make it in time (on Sunday) for another brat! You just can't ask for a better place!“

“The patty melt and fried onions was out standing. True diner food. like a step back in time. You know the way it was supposed to be. Sooo yummy! It's late in the season we sat outside. So I can't really speak to the atmosphere but inside the diner was was as I knew it back in the day.“

“First time visitor checking in! Listen this is some great sweet trouble to get into!!I’ll have to digest the goodies over the next few days, I’m slowly preparing for the 5k for the spring! Moderation as my dietician would say, but of course my ears don’t work! So I indulged. What did I buy?Macaroons- Vanilla- Salted Carmel- Toasted Coconut- LemonChocolate, listen I’m a chocolate girl but I like vanilla. However, I’m hooked on their chocolate! O M G, it’s so freaking delicious! It’s basically a new love affair. So of course I got chocolate too!! Soooooo gooood!!!!Gelato, so did you know ice cream is more cream and gelato is whole milk? I think that’s what I learned today. So basically in my eyes, gelato is healthy.Gelato is fancy and it is soooo good!I did the espresso gelato today, just a scoop, you know for moderation purposesI wanted to buy it in bulk!“

“Well. What can I say. I think the place has the best chocolates in Wisconsin. Only place you can get hand crafted, 74% dark chocolate bars. We are out of town for the winter, and Monday, I'm going to have them ship me some Dark Bars because you can't get them anywhere else. (there are 72% dark bars out there, and higher, but not any good 74% bars) (I like that concentration of dark). (Ok, ok, i haven't been to every chocolate shop in Wisconsin, so technically I don't know if it's the best, but from what I've had, it is). (that's not to diminish what I think of the Chisel, because I drive all the way to Port to get it.) (The ice cream is fantastic too.) (that's all)“

“Cookies are pricey but they're huge. Very tasty. Some of the items were too sweet but it's okay. It's amazing that a 2017 startup has become the largest cookie store in the United States :). Totally worth stopping by for yummy treats.“

“Excellent food, service and atmosphere! Has the vintage restaurant feel and is a great location close to Lime Kiln Park as well as the main Village Park. However, because of this the low amount of seating hurts them in the summer time so I don’t recommend staying during dinner rush.“

“Hit the spot after a warm walk by the lake. I love that they serve out of a little Airstream trailer. You can choose an ice cream treat or mini donuts here.I was so excited to see they had my fave flavor (Blue Moon) here. I enjoyed my Waffle cone. I was intrigued by the floats and donuts, but just stuck with the cone.Items came out pretty quickly for how busy it was. If you have an ice cream craving near the lake, this spot did not disappoint!“

“The BEST frozen yogurt in the world. I have always loved Fro-yo and as stores began to disappear my heart was a little bit shattered. Though, when I finally discovered Smart Cow and their little Gem of a location I could not be happier. They always have such great flavors, with every type of profile you could imagine. Though, they do change things out frequently which is nice! I love that their toppings have a large range of options, and they even have real cake batter, or cookie dough to top off your bowl with! Friendly staff, and enjoyable kid friendly atmosphere.Vegetarian options: Super great for people with allergies, nothing meat related happening here.“

“Yumm!! Big fan of all the amazing flavors here, especially the rotating dairy free ones!! They always have a least one dairy free option and I love that for the lactose intolerant and dairy averse. They of course have dairy ice cream and house made hot fudge and caramel, which I also partake in. Delicious cones, split scoops, unicorn bowls, sprinkles, and more! They also have a upright cooler of pints off to the right so you can grab your favorite to go, including flavors not currently "on scoop"? lol.“