Restaurants near Colgate

“First time here yesterday 4/27/24! There was a small wait, but the wait was so worth the food! Had the bang bang shrimp and cheese curds for an appetizer and the crab rangoon flatbread for the main course! Leftovers were brought home! Great staff, awesome environment and great food! I’ll definitely be coming back!”

“Purchased these for my granddaughters 3rd birthday party…everyone thought they were absolutely adorable, and good tasting too!! I’d recommend Cookies From Scratch!! Laura is a joy to work with!!”

“If your looking for that old school feel to a bar this is it. Very relaxing atmosphere the food is actually really good. If you stop in the Pizza is definitely worth trying. Lowell lake state park is just down the road if your looking for a great hike in nature before a stop in. While there you may learn alot about the history of the bar and the area.”

“The food is amazing and fresh!! Tisha and Shaofei's service was amazing and even gave us free shakes. They are so kind, welcoming and patient. PLEASE COME HERE!”

“Tasty chicken with kick to them, very good customer service, and the place looks nice as well. Only thing is, they don’t have stuff you can add in your food like Lemon Peppers or something.”

“The restaurant is very clean, it wasn't too loud, the service was great, and the food was fantastic! Simple seasoning of food is often overlooked and instead chefs focus on the latest trends. Cafe Manna offers delicious food without being pretentious. I had lunch here and I will certainly return!”

“Took clients there and didn't disappoint. Also used them for catering and from the event start to finish everything was taken care of. You can taste the freshness in the food. It is amazing.”

“The burgers are hands down the best we have had... fresh buns, actual meat and not frozen... delicious! Bloody Mary's made with housemade vegetable infused vodka, and the homemade chips!!! don't forget to order the poutine... fantastic! great atmosphere, comfortable, very friendly staff!”

“3 cellars host's the best wine tasting events around. ("Code Red" is the best)- staff is knowledgeable and is always bringing in new products- food options are great(pizzas are delicious)- great atmosphere- tasting bar always has new fresh options. They've got something for everybody.”

“Northstar Bistro isn't just about the food (though it's amazing!). The staff truly elevates the dining experience – they're friendly and attentive. Combine that with their creative cocktails and reimagined American classics, and you've got a recipe for a perfect night out.”

“The hand-piped detail on her themed macarons is truly unbelievable. My favorites are the Harry Potter characters. They are almost too beautiful to eat, but taste too delicious not to!”

“Go here now if you're reading this. Go here, EVERY DAY! Except when they're closed. Don't think about eating anything else. What are you gonna do? Go to McDonald's and fill yourself with their dirty food? Too lazy or busy to drive? GET DELIVERY! If you think about leaving a bad review, I wouldn't. Just saying.”

“Food was great! Sit at the bar- the people are so nice and great to chat with. I haven't sat at the outside patio but looks comfortable and temperature controlled.”

“Great Place to experience Bourbon. If you are struggling with deciding which to try the knowledgeable staff will assist. BONUS: Food is amazing and they always have seasonal specials. Whiskey Club is well worth the price!!”

“We needed a place to have family gather after a Baptism and Town 9 Tap met our every need. JT customized a breakfast and lunch menu for us to choose what we wanted to eat. Tabitha, JT and staff bent over backwards for us. The food was excellent! The room was perfect! I highly recommend Town 9 Tap for your gathering needs. Thank you so much! God Bless you all!”

“We had wanted to try the fish fry for a long time and finally made plans to go. I appreciate the fact they take reservations on a Friday, for even 2 people! We both ordered the fish fry, had mozzarella sticks as an appetizer. The food was very good. The value for the portion, fantastic. The small dining room did get kind of loud, it was fine for the 2 of us, but if we were going out with another couple to, "catch up," conversation at times would have been a little difficult without having to talk really loud, that said, we will definitely return.”

“Food and service is fast and friendly. Like coming here on my lunch break. They get the order right each time and never have had anything that wasn't delicious.”

“Fun atmosphere, quirky location, worth the trip. Empanadas were delicious and maybe the best Caprese sandwich I've ever eaten. Be sure to enjoy the Chilean donuts while they're still warm, perfect for sharing!”

“We always enjoy the food and service at Maxims. Everything was good. One minor issue is the asparagus scrambler only had the tough bitter ends of asparagus. A disappointment.”

“My husband and I love attending the lunch buffet at this restaurant. The staff is always welcoming and attentive. The food is incredibly delicious and there is a wonderful variety of foods offered. The prices are also reasonable.”

“The food is AMAZING. Extremely cool atmosphear especially after their remodel/addition they just did. The real fireplace is a nice touch. I recommend the pizza and garlic bread but have had their steaks and sandwichs too and have been very happy with them.”

“I get food here at least once a week. It's absolutely delicious and you can order ahead. The food is ready fairly quickly. If I could, I would order food here every day of the week. I'm not even exaggerating. It's that good.”

“Always a great experience with Pewaukee location! This is our "go to" fot delivery.Vegetarian options: Order what you want and they will not disappoint.”

“We had a party of 6 along with two children. The food was absolutely amazing as always. But our server Matt was even better! Very attentive, super nice and patient. We will be back!”

“I have been here a couple of times now and I can say the food and service are outstanding! I would encourage anyone wanting to try this spot to do it, I don't think you'll be sorry you did.”

“We stopped here after visiting Holy Hill. the food and service was great. we have some picky eaters and they loved the food. The fish fry and brisket were excellent. We will definitely stop here again.”

“I came here for the Gluten-free bakery. It is Molly's gf bakery. SO GOOD!!! I then realized they have Anodyne coffee. Another so good product. I will be back!!”

“Great food, healthy, nice place to meet friends and family! The banana cake is the "bomb" and all the salads are great! Care for a drink , try the Bloody Mary w the works, no regrets!”

“Undoubtedly this is my go to place for breakfast when my work brings me to the area. Great breakfast. Wonderful people. I support local businesses for sure and their food tends to be better than national franchises or chains. I most strongly endorse this wonderful place with kind and caring people.”