10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Deerfield

“We will return!!! We had a group order placed and we ran later for pick up than expected they called to make sure we were still coming and kept our food warm. They also offered a warmer bag for us to carry our food back! The food was so good! I had the roast beef sandwich it was the bomb!“

“We left a horrible experience at Nora's 2 and ended up here. SO GLAD we did!! The service was prompt and we got exactly what we ordered, cooked to perfection. Had the Pickle Burger with added bacon and it's probably the best burger I've ever had.Try it out--you'll love the food!!“

“I ordered on line and didn’t get the confirmation email. I called the store and they had the order as pick up the person answering my was quick to be able to change my order. I was not able to get a confirmation for delivery time… but short after what would have been pick up, my delivery driver was here! I was not expecting so soon but he was so friendly and wanted to be sure I had my food! Every single order from Sal’s… all the staff are so wonderful! Amazing kindness!“

“Best sandwiches in this state.wow. real solid tastes and textures. A genius sandwich maker.Thistle bought for wife's family, they all raved. Thebbqbriskwt was meltingly lush, pork, Italian beef, all were fantastic. Service both excellent and interesting. Ambiance hippie gourmet. The best!“

“Best pizza in the entire Madison area. The online ordering for pickup is a breeze. We've not done delivery bc we live too far away but it's worth the drive. When ordering online it tells how long for pickup, and that time estimate is always spot-on. The food is always consistent too, so there's never a bad experience.“

“We order from Papa Jimmy's at least once every couple of weeks. They always have our order ready on time- delivered or pick up. They have really good pizza and we love the extra sprinkled breadsticks! Continues to be a family favorite in this home.“

“the only reason it isn't overall 5 stars is because they switched from Pepsi products to Coke products, their selection for cans, bottles and 2 liters are very limited now. my family always complains about no mtn dew. if this has to do with corporate, please fix it i bet their sales decreased bc of the sudden swtich. the service is amazing though! all staff seem to work very hard and as quickly as they can. best pizza place in sun prairie by far“

“What a great business with a great group of Employees! I was on my way to get food for my employees/coworkers today when my truck was totalled by an inattentive driver. I called to let them know i wouldn’t be able to make it to get the food that I had ordered ahead. They were so caring, firstly asking if i was ok, then offering to deliver the food for me so my guys could eat lunch. They have earned my business and my respect! Can’t thank Everyone Enough! I wish i could give more than 5 stars!“

“Ordered quite a few times and some nights the pizza tastes different than the other nights. Last night we got the big dinner box and asked for a dipping sauce for our wings, got home and had no dipping sauce for the wings or the breadsticks. Driving from Deerfield it wasnt worth it to drive all the way back and ask for our sauces. The chicken and breadsticks definatley were not as tasty without the sauces :(“

“Great food. Go there often and some family get togethers. Only one item I don't care for.. SPICY pizza!!!!! Been eating pizza for 78years. Never was spicy but I notice it's spicy a lot more. lately. Tommy Pipita is turning over in his grave. pineapple????“