35 Best Pizza Restaurants in Green Bay

“It was our first time here and it was 10/10! WOW! I LOVE pizza and honestly, this rates in my top 3 favorite pizza places. From the variety of crust options to the mound of toppings they pile on the pizza, I was so impressed! Our server, Renata, what a gem. As someone who's worked in the service industry since 17, it's rare to see someone who really enjoys their job and is kind and compassionate. Renata is the true definition of what one should strive to be when working in the service industry. Kudos to her! Protect this woman at all costs. She was such a joy. I would have invited her to join our table and share some pizza. She made me feel like family. Keep smiling, Renata. You are a GEM! We can't wait to come back. ❤️🍕“

“I work for Innovative Care Services and today we took a group of about 20 out to eat at the buffet for lunch. Not only was the food amazing but our service was top notch! Our clients had a blast and it made for some great memories! I will definitely be back in the future!! Thank you for making our outing so wonderful!“

“Best pizza in town, especially love the sausage. Cat was a great waitress tonight“

“Great food just wish the dining room was warmer thermostat was set at 59 degrees 🥶“

“Jenny S. was my waitress and she was fantastic and so accommodating. Definitely coming back and requesting her!! Thank you Jenny!“

“I ordered online and was not given the correct pizzas. When i talked to the gentleman behind the counter he assured me it was what i ordered but it was not. I think i can tell the difference between a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza but he kept telli g me i had the right order.“

“Have loved their pizza since the 1960's. My personal favorite.“

“I looooovvveee Jake's pizza! Its my favorite! Its worth the wait. The taste is fantastic. The service is wonderful! Thanks everyone!“

“Took my grandson here for the day, and we had a blast. This place has been here since I was a little kid, back when it was show biz pizza. Always a good stop if u kids or grandkids, prices are another discussion but it's 2026 so it is what is, all games are 1 swipe/token which is nice. Food is a little pricey but so is everything else I guess so I roll with punches, anyway it's fun for all ages I believe. Pizza got better staff is nice, and the vibe is chaotic sometimes, but worth it... definitely worth a shot.“

“We had a lovely evening for the Installation of Officers for our Altrusa Club. From the first phone call to the last good by everything was handled efficiently and professionally. Our waitress Tara was friendly and very efficient. Plus the food was delicious!! Thank you again, you never disappoint.“

“5920-Matt G was very polite & helpful with my order. What a great worker.“

“love the pizza great menu polite staff“

“Awesome buffet and amazing staff. Kudos to the waitresses and cook.“

“My must stop every Friday. Delicious subs with fresh ingredients on the best bread in town. Always served quickly and with a friendly smile.

Ps…if they ran out of bread one day, so they had to stop taking orders over the phone for the two-for-one special, it’s not “false advertising.” It’s responsible order-taking so they could fill the orders they had already taken. Pretty sad when someone writes a review calling a business “greedy” because they were so busy they ran out of product.

Keep up the great work Scott’s Subs!!“

“Best pizza in the Green Bay Area!“

“Food was fresh and appetizing. The drinks were cold and nothing was flat. The sweet tea wasn't overly sweet. The building was clean. Which is what I always look for first. The buffet was plentiful. Lots of choices. The chicken is absolutely ridiculous and delicious! Cannot wait to go back. The staff was very nice and helpful. They accommodated us very well.“

“Jessica D at the West one is Amazing!! Excellent server!“

“Our family LOVES Luigi’s. Luigi’s always caters for all of our parties and does such an amazing job!!“

“If you have food intolerances or allergies be careful!!! Just because you asked to omit an item doesn't mean your food with show up without it. I spent last night throwing because I ate onions in a wrap I requested no onions for. A few days before, my burger showed up with onions as well. I was able to see them and remove them (though that still pushed my luck).“

“Old school style place. The pizza is amazing! This is the closest pizza I have had to the famous Wells Brothers in Racine WI. The thin, crispy, cracker crust, with lots of flavor! Very reasonable pricing, family friendly. Highly recommend!!!!“

“My son & I were in town Polishing this week! We will definitely be back for the great food, cold drinks, & great bartenders!“

“Omg huge shout out 2 Schlotzsky’s deli. As soon as I walk in I get greeted. Everything is always so fresh my staff are awesome I’ve been going here for years ever since they had the one on Oneida Street in greenbay. But after that one closed I started going to the one in Appleton but now I will drive 20 minutes just to come to the one in Green Bay on Mason Street . Very clean and you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door whoever the owner is he’s got a great staff that work for him in a very clean restaurant. Keep up the great work love your food!😎 Thank you Aaron“

“Met a random human named Keith last night playing Marvel Rivals. He shamelessly plugged little ceasars in the chat, and in that moment I knew I needed pizza. A moment later, a heavily glowing appeared behind my closet door and there he was, Keith, the little ceasars man, with pizza, crazy bread, and a dream. Now I have everything I need. Thank you Keith the pizza man. You have changed my life forever.“

“I stopped at Earth Senses in GB to get some pellets for my wood stove & they recommended Glass Nickel Pizza Company. So I got to try it 10/3/23. Needless to say it did not disappoint... Very satisfied & thanks for the AWESOME PIZZA 🍕“

“I really liked this place the staff were great was here for the experience olde main street wvent first time ever the free slice of pizza was huge and first time having a martini which was great would definitely recommend you check this place out if you haven't already“

“Josephine’s has consistently amazing food and is one of our family’s favorite establishments. Tonight our server Ethan went above and beyond for us. I would also like to mentioned that we forgot my sons medicine on the table and Frank promptly found us on Facebook to let us know that he would be staying late to make sure we were able to pick it up. We had a rough day and the kindness of these strangers really helped us cope. I will always recommend Josephine’s.“

“Topper’s GB West, Military Ave location is GREAT. I’ve ordered take out more than a dozen times in the last few months and NEVER have I had a bad experience. Staff are always friendly and order is always on time.“

“Great bar and restaurant, under new ownership and they’re doing amazing. The food and atmosphere is great, can’t wait to come back!“

“Townline is one of my favorite places to visit! Whether a Packer game, a friend's meeting place or just good food, I enjoy visiting.
My brother, Todd Stephan has worked there for over 20 years and loves his responsibility of bartending and making sure everyone is having fun! For my past birthday, Todd coordinated with Nelson, the chef and made me a delicious birthday dinner! Kudos to Townline and my bro!“

“So thankful for my delivery driver tonight! 1: apparently I gave the wrong phone number and it went right to voicemail when he came to the front desk of the hotel. But he hunted us down and was totally nice about it. 2: I had not thought about plates and napkins, but he had it all already to go for us! Thank you so much my ginger delivery man!! 😌“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Wonderful friendly people� Great products and good prices.“

“Great place to shop. Never know what you will find. Always great deals. Love the cheese cooler.“