Pizza Pit - Madison West

6628 Odana Rd, Madison
(608) 833-3030

Recent Reviews

Justin B

The place needs new management for closing 30 mins early. Didn't have time to even pick up my order.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Eric Zolot

Good pizza ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sauce

Lisa

Wings are amazing and chocolate chip cookies are perfection. Flavor, quantity and quality of toppings on the garden veggie pizza with added gyro meat were great...but the pizza was undercooked by a lot. Onions and peppers were still completely crunchy and cool, cheese was just barely melted and the crust was honestly closer to dough. there is an option to order the pizza" well done" that I'll definitely check in the future. However, even though this is my first Pizza Pit pizza, I think this was unintentionally to raw and probably not the way they usually do them. I guess the good news is that we had a lot of leftover pizza, and the rawness made reheating it taste like fresh pizza instead of reheated. I think this was probably a random occurrence, and I will definitely order from this place again.

Steve

The pizza is fantastic, but the wings especially are the best in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Lovers Pizza, Wings

Joe Paterick

Great tasting pizza.... you can taste the vegetables, meats, sauce, dough all together.... Garlic butter is real butter and garlic ... delicious. Great Customer service!

Tempess Jarvis

Called for delivery was told they won’t deliver to my location “TONIGHT” as I proceed to ask if this decisionwas just for tonight or permanently I was rudely hung up on. I called back to speak to management I was left on hold for quite some time. Corporate has been contacted that’s totally unacceptable I work in the food industry as well. I would never treat my customers that way.

Brian Ansdersen

Ordered the big chicken strips and curly fries. Was ready in about 5 minutes. Counter dude recommended Dijon BBQ for my order, and he was right about that. Even had to go back up and get an extra sauce. Didn't try the pizza. Place had the limited seating you'd find at a chinese take out spot. Looking like they do mostly deliveries and take away. Place is too quiet, put some music on. I'd stop in again next time in the area for work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bert Cross

Pizza pit rules! I've eaten my fair share of pizzas and these guys make a tasty pizza. We ordered two pizzas, plain cheese and the deluxe combo. The guy on the phone said 45 minutes to an hour, we were handed them in 25. The sauce and cheese ratio makes this pizza great, the perfect amount of both. For me the sauce is what stood out and separates them from other pizzas I've had. it had excellent flavor and nice consistency - not too thin but not too thick. Thanks for making our movie night a great one!

Red Books

Popped in for lunch with my kid after visiting the soccer store next to them. We ordered the deal on pizza slices and took them to go. 2 slices and a sodah for 7 bucks, had the deluxe slices and kiddo had cheese. No frills, quick and easy. Thanks guy.

Lydia Connors

They accidentally mixed up our pizza with another on a busy Friday night, but rectified the situation with precision and speed. Kudos! Great food btw.

Robby Bisbee

Ordered on Sunday the large pizza twins deal and it was a lot of food for the price. The pizza was spot on as always and my son wanted breadsticks and they were cooked to perfection. Thank youKid-friendliness: Son loved the pizza and the breadsticks

Jennifer Kleine

We had a large order (20 pizzas) this last weekend and Hunter and his crew were amazing. Great customer service, timely, and most importantly our pizzas were hot and delicious! Thank you!

Tim Williams

Still my favorite handtossed pizza in the area aside from *maybe* Sugar River. The deals and prices have gotten worse but I think that's just to be expected. COVID wrecked things pretty bad.

Ami Violet

I haven't had Pizza Pit since I was a little kid (for reference I'm 37 now), so when I learned there was one in town I HAD to try it after decades without. How was this so good?! And I don't think it was nostalgia because I didn't have any expectations this many years later lol. We ordered a 2 topping medium husky pizza with bread stix and cheesy bread, the toppings were the perfect amount and tasted great quality as did the bread and pizza as a whole (bread stix had a bakery quality flavor to them, at least in my opinion). I don't know what I was expecting, maybe something more like Little Caesars? Lol thankfully this was much better! Even the box it came in brought back the nostalgia. My positive childhood memories of Pizza Pit remain untouched by time thanks to whoever made this great food for us tonight!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jay kroeber

Excellent Gyros at a fair price with great customer service...

Load More