Settle Down Tavern

Burgers, Sandwich Shops

117 S Pinckney St, Madison
(608) 442-6335


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Settle Down Tavern

Just went there at 2pm today (Sunday), and they close at 2:30pm. We were seated outside, in the shade, immediately, and had our food within 10 minutes.I had the Good Idea Burger and Ghost Fries, and my friend had the Hey Sunshine with Fries. The food was amazing! The burger was juicy and brimming with flavor, and my fried thoroughly enjoyed his breakfast sandwich. The fries were also done just right.Our server was attentive and quick, and we were back at our apartment by 2:30! full review

Very sparse menu. Friday fish fry was more expensive than most at $19. Fries that came with the fish were a skimpy portion for the price. Everywhere else is much more generous with the portion. Would not go back on our next trip to Madison. Also when asked for a dessert menu the waitress told us about only ONE dessert and played it up as her favorite.

Visited Settle Down Tavern on a Sunday afternoon (around 1:30). There was a short wait for an outside table. As a non drinker, I was happy to see multiple options on the menu for N/A drinks and mocktails. I got the Sauk County celery lemonade which was delicious. I ordered the croque madaaaamne and my fiancé got the burger. Both were great. There are other menu items I would like to try but I have a feeling if I go back I’ll be getting the croque madaaaamne again. So good! full review

More Reviews(103)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 11:30AM - 2PM
4 - 10PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 2PM
4 - 10PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 2PM
4 - 11PM
Friday 11:30AM - 2:30PM
4 - 11:30PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 2:30PM
4 - 11:30PM
Sunday 10AM - 2:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.