“We had their Fish Fry on Friday...AH-MAZING! We've gone to a lot of fish frys in the area, and Belly Up's was probably one of the best we've EVER had! Fish was very tender and crispy, fries were great, and the coleslaw was a perfect combination! We ordered everything to go (it was still hot when we got home even) because we had a little one with us that was getting antsy, otherwise we would of most definitely stayed for the exceptional atmosphere! Looking forward to our next visit!“
“First time in after driving past many times. Really good food for the most part. Didn't dig the brisket as much. And one thing woulda been really nice on the menu. A brisket and steak option haha. Just my opinion but other then that everything was really good! And the cocktails were really good!!“
“Friendly staff great food. Had wings the garlic parm and the Thai chili, both were delicious but we were craving spicy. We decided to order the irie heat....YUM! You won't be disappointed if you like spicy it's smoky and peppery. It doesn't last forever so you can enjoy more. We told the gentleman who brought the food out we loved it and he said he had something hotter called the scary Larry sauce. We were thrilled, we dipped a bit of the garlic parm since it's so mild and I took a baby bite and was fine. My husband was sweating and tearing. Go check it out“
“Just moved to Menomonee Falls from Buffalo New York five days ago. I have been coming here to Menomonee F back-and-forth for the year and a half and have not found a place with buffalo chicken Wings like back home, I stopped in tonight and a very nice young lady, named Marie or Maria. I apologize I cannot remember, Excellent service ! I got a dozen of chicken wings hot to-go and they were spot on just like the wings back home. I will only go here now to get my fix of Buffalo NY wings. Thank You Alumni Club!“
“3/21/24 We made the mistake of the first time going there during March madness don’t do that unless you really want to get into the games they didn’t have the fish fry. because of that. So we had pizza was not impressed at all with the pizza seem like a frozen pizza just cooked with a little extra cheese on it, not real good flavor. But I’m sure there’s other things there that are better. We had the cheese curds. They were good. Everybody was really nice and very attentive. Katie the bartender was very good. But the place is just Phenomenal For sports memorabilia. It’s a site to see and it’s a very large building and bar. We will go back and try something else.“
“I had the Smash Burger, and homemade chips, my wife got the Chicken Wrap and it was excellent. We stopped on Saturday around 6:00PM, so it was busy but we got a table in the bar.I highly recommend stopping in, getting a drink and trying the food.“
“I LOVE walking into a bar in the afternoon when it's light out and the conversations have already started in the welcoming atmosphere. Spinning the wheel, ice cold beer, attentive bartender and clean surfaces make the DBR an awesome stop for happy hour. I've also attended live music in the backyard when the weather's a bit more cooperative. Overall a great roadside stop!“
“I have been coming to Kelly’s for quite a bit now and I just want to truly thank them for always giving me a pleasant experience. I was there for Opening Day yesterday and literally every staff member was so kind and had smiles on their faces despite all of the chaos going on. Compared to how you get treated at bars downtown etc. it’s made me realize how much I truly appreciate this place.“
“We came here late one Saturday evening because our group wasn't quite ready to call it a night and we ended up almost closing the bar down! It's your typical bar - a step above from a "dive" bar, in my opinion. The staff was nice and we got our drinks quickly. The gin and tonic was reasonably priced and tasted as expected. Overall a perfectly good late night drinks option with friends, but it was very very loud. The music was blaring and the people were trying to top it with their conversations. This is definitely not the place to go if you want to have a conversation with your group without yelling. They did have darts and some slot machines in the back.“
“I gave them 5 Stars for Atmosphere but don’t expect a 5 Star restaurant this is a quant small town bar/ restaurant. We go for the Friday Fish Fry, they take your order when you arrive and seated when food is ready. I had the Baked Cod I have a big appetite and was very satisfied with the LARGE portion at a reasonable price. They are always packed but with their efficient system you get served in a reasonable time.Dietary restrictions: I had the Baked Cod with Butter no sides .Parking: Parking lot can get full when busy but there is street parking adjacent to restaurant.“
“Beautiful place and more beautiful people preparing your food. The burgers are hand made with seasoning that doesn't contain just salt n pepper. Onion rings are delightful and they were very nice to us. Would go back again for the flavor.“
“Quaint little rural village setting; charming atmosphere with rustic wooden tables and stone walls. The menu includes salads, gourmet mac and cheese, brisket platters, salmon, and more! Everything we had was delicious - no complaints or suggestions.“
“Easter Sunday and one of the few places I found open. I was out for a @WiscoMary Sunday Bloody Mary, and I was not disappointed. Magoo's has their own Tito's infused vodka with jalapenos, their own special Bloody Mary mix, their Worcestershire sauce includes dry rub seasoning. My bloody was served with a cheese curd, before stick, and olive . Connor was an excellent bartender/server. Definitely a great place to watch the game and have their delicious wings. Great staff, great atmosphere, great food.“
“This is a great bar, service is great! Bartender very friendly. Order the Boneless Garlic Parmesan Chicken, didn’t have much flavor. Hubby had the Spicy Garlic and Blackened Cajun Rub. He loved the dry rub but Spicy Garlic wasn’t spicy (for him)! Overall a definite stop if in area and we will be back to try other flavors of wings and of course other menu items!!“
“This is a great local restaurant/bar. The people were friendly, even though I wasn't a regular. We ate at the bar, the bartender was nice, with a little sass.I had the Rib Special. Everything about it was good, the ribs fell off the bone, pretty good BBQ flavor.I will definitely go back.“
“I just want to Thank Libby Montanna's for accommodating our reservation for 18 people . Our waitress staff were amazing , the food was delish and was delivered by multiple people to make sure is was delivered hot and all together I can't say enough how awesome this resturaunt is. Once the food was delivered our waitress asked how our food was and how everything was in general....which was good follow thru. Afterwards we saw Joe 2.0 which was exceptional..what a great night and thanks Libby Montanna for being q part of it.“
“It's a really nice little corner type bar that is next to the train tracks on Duplainville roadI just had one drink there this time I did not eat, I was hoping to catch up with a friend of mine who bartends there. It was awesome to see her! Their food is typical small bar food, kind of like a greasy spoon but they make really good wraps, I haven't eaten there quite a while but I remember the wraps were awesome.“
“We had our Friday night rehearsal dinner at Richfield Roadhouse, and cannot say enough about how pleased we were. Food was delicious, and Bryan was so helpful in planning this event with us. He let us come in early to decorate and when we arrived, food and cocktails were all ready to serve. Thank you so much for making this event so special for us. The friendliness and professionalism was outstanding. Not to mention GREAT food!!!“
“When in doubt Colonel it out … to my fan”s of true Wisconsin taste ? and treat the Bloody Mary here was hands ?? down taste only the best yet I have had here in Wisconsin hollander .. will need to step it up for me … salute Mr.Knippel …. When I need my go too he was there 10/10… I will be back for another half off night … when I say best hidden good time … in a long time … to another escapade.. Parking: Great service Mr.KnippelWheelchair accessibility: Yes street level“
“This is one of my favorite spots to go in Milwaukee for fish and chicken the service is awesome if it ain't right they will make it right in my opinion...love this place I give them 5 starsParking: You just got to know when to get there...it can get crowed at times but its worth it...“
“My food was not perfect but it was perfectly prepared my beer was not great but it was drinkable my shot of crown must have had a leak but it was good next time a2x hog shot or 4 will do noteI did have my liquor before my beer and felt great“
“Clearly a hot spot in Menomonee Falls, their fish fry didn't disappoint. It tasted "different", actually. It felt innovative. Moreover , they have more options for fish fry than the usual ones on at any restaurant on a Friday night. Our server was great. He was attentive and personable. It's a fun place, so it's loud and noisy...don't expect a romantic ambience. I'm looking forward to going back for trivia night!“