9 Best Caribbean Restaurants in Milwaukee

Shaker's Cigar Bar Caribbean
422 S 2nd St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Bayou Stuffed Jambalaya
14 Margherita Pizza
Grilled Swordfish
Shrimp and Grits
Cajun Meatballs
Blue Crab Claws
Bruschetta

“Incredible ambiance and very friendly and welcoming staff. The food is fantastic and they have a wide range of spirits, beers, cocktails and of course cigars as well as delicious mocktails for those who want something fun without the alcohol. I will definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb165 Reviews
Mobay Cafe Caribbean • $$
1022 S 1st St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Two Meat Platter Oxtail and Curry Goat
Caribbean Shrimp Rundown
Red Stripe Chicken Wings
Carribean Shrimp Rundown
Jerk Chicken Sliders
Brown Stew Chicken
Cafe Jerk Chicken
Mobay Egg Rolls
Steamed Cabbage
Escovitch Fish

“Ordered the ox tail, jerked chicken, and island shrimp and all of the meals were on point! Your portions were fair, everything was well seasoned and the staff was super friendly while I was picking my order up. We always jumped from one Jamaican spot to the next when we shopped but I think you earned our loyalty on our first visit.“

4.6 Superb83 Reviews
Fiyahside Jamaican Cuisine Jamaican • $
7434 West Capitol Drive, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Side of Brownstew Curry Chicken Only
Jerk Brownstew Chicken Dinner Combo
Large Brownstew Chicken Dinner
Jerk Curry Chicken Dinner Combo
Large Curry Chicken Dinner
Large Jerk Chicken Dinner
Small Curry Chicken Dinner
Jerk Chicken Cabbage Roll
Side of Jerk Chicken Only
Rice Plantain Cabbage

“Decided to try something new and out of my element and got Fiyahside Jamaican Cuisine! The food itself was wonderful and tasted so good. The meat had all it's bones so if that's something that you find off-putting you may have to consider how you order your meals. For me, it was fine and I picked around it and enjoyed every savory minute. Would definitely get again!“

4.3 Superb82 Reviews
Lily Bell's 'IS Soul Food •
8103 W Tower Ave, Milwaukee

“Mrs Shea and her husband catered our home wedding ceremony. As we’re already regulars, we knew we had to serve her food to our guests! She really paid attention to the details, helped plan a menu, and went above and beyond in service & quality!! The reviews from guests were outstanding. (Especially our pup that she also spoiled!) We made sure to include her greens & Mac as options, two of our favorites! She did a follow up call to ensure customer satisfaction and take feedback. I highly recommend Lily Bell’s!!“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Jmakin Jamaican Jamaican • $
520 E Center St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Beef Patty and Egg Roll
Jerk Chicken

“The food here is SO GOOD!!! The portions are insane for the price but the quality is still there. I really recommend the oxtail. The best part is that you can tell that the owner really cares about what he does and that makes this place even better!“

4.3 Superb17 Reviews
Jamaican Season Island Jamaican • $
9207 W Capitol Dr, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken Egg Roll
Curry Chicken & Rice
Large Jerk Chicken
Jerk Egg Rolls
Oxtail and Rice
Yellow Rice
Samosa

“I finally did it yall! Tried some delicious Jamaican food ? I have drove passed this place so many times, and said I was going to try them out in never did, but today babyyyyy I did! There food is amazing! They definitely give you a nice amount of food for the price you pay. It's definitely worth trying. The flavor of the food I had was on point. I purchased, Jerk egg rolls, cabbage, rice and peas, and Jerk chicken. 10/10 I did take-out, the place is definitely a vibe if you do want to dine in.“

4 Good71 Reviews
Frankies Restaurant and Catering Caribbean • $$
1815 E Kenilworth Pl, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese
Cornbread

“This was our first time here. We LOVED it!!! The owner was our server and he was amazing, so polite and kind. The food was absolutely delicious. The j*** chicken was moist and very, very flavorful. The red beans ans rice was probably the best I've ever had. The macaroni was good, the French fries were perfect, and the corn break muffin ??? is all I can say!! My boyfriend even got a necklace. We will definitely be back, and will be telling all our friends“

3.9 Good20 Reviews
Sabor Tropical Puerto Rican • $$
2258 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Tostones Rellenos with Steak and Puerto Rican Rice
Pulled Pork Tostones & PR Rice and Beans
Soup of the Day - Caldo De Res
Mofongo Rellenos Platter
White Rice and Tostones
Grilled Spiny Lobster
Hamburgeza Con Queso
Sabor Tropical Wings
Avocado with Shrimp
Churrasco Argentino

“Fantastic experience! As soon as we entered, we were greeted by Angelica. She provided such a warm welcome and gave her recommendations. Her descriptions of the dishes felt as if she went into the kitchen and cooked it herself. We will be back!!!“

3.9 Good78 Reviews
Mangos Cafe East Cafe • $
2018 1680-1682, N Van Buren St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Guava and Creme Cheese Empanadas
Steak Mango Fries with Cheese
Tacos and Empanadas
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Caribbean Steak
Caribbean Wings
Chicken Wings
Mangos Nachos
Shrimp Tacos
Honey Bites

“Went to mangos for dinner ,the atmosphere was chill and the food was definitely delicious if I want good Salas and the juiciest chicken or steak quesadillas.you got to taste theirs and the beef empanadas was good as well.customer service was excellent and the rice and beans had a good spicy taste.go check it out bar /and club and dining.“

3.7 Good66 Reviews
Loading...
map Map