14 Best American Restaurants near Sister Bay

“Sara who answered the phone to take our reservation was so friendly, helpful and so sweet! We ate inside and it was so good. We had the salmon and steak and both were amazing! The bread was so good as well as the side salad. It was our 1st time trying LURE and it was 10/10 and we will be back!! Can’t wait to try everything on the menu as it looked top notch… keep doing an amazing job LURE! Even with it being such a busy weekend- service was quick and top notch!!“

“Consistantly good pies, fun venue and good-natured staff. Beautiful views of the bay a great area to walk after taking in a meal. Right on the main strip in Door Co so it is usually a struggle to find a parking spot. Always enjoy our visit here and we will return!“

“Our server (Gail) was delightful. Food was fine. Fries were mediocre, sweet potato fries were much higher quality. Big portions. The diet cola was very bad. Pull tabs available.Vegetarian options: Black bean burger and impossible burger available, some vegetarian sides and apps.“

“We went tonight for dinner. It was busy and there was an hour wait. It was totally worth it. We had a new waitress Jess who did an amazing job . Our food was perfectly done and tasted amazing. We had the Rib-eye, Prime Rib and Full Rack of BBQ Ribs. All were superb!! I would highly recommend!“

“Stopped for breakfast midweek. Service was very attentive. Coffee cup was always hot and full. Breakfast was delicious, served quickly and hot.Food & drinks: Great place in Door County for breakfast. They also offer one of the top white fish boils.“

“Went there tonight for dinner with my husband. He had the perch dinner. I had the seafood chowder & whitefish sandwich. Let me tell you, that chowder was SOOOOO good!! I'm going to rave about this because I just loved the taste. The rest of our food was good too. Definitely would return when coming back to Door County.“

“Fantastic lattes, all the food was wonderful. We had a variety of dishes with our group and all were very good. Neat little place!Kid-friendliness: My only caution would be that if you're dining with kiddos, this may not be what they're looking for. Check the menu ahead of time, especially if you have a picky eater.“

“Owner and staff were awesome! Met a couple out there and ended up golfing with them the next day, super fun atmosphere! The course was in fantastic shape considering the dry spell! Hands down the most fun 9 hole course I have played! We had a burger and fish fry, food was good.“

“Love this restaurant. We try to get to Barringer's every time we get up to Door County. Excellent steaks and love the shrimp cocktail. We also had the special which was halibut and it did not disappoint. If planning a trip to Door County, make reservations at Barringer's and enjoy a wonderful meal.“

“The food and atmosphere was great but the lady at the front that greats you ruined are experience she yells at everyone even at a old man she has no respect for anyone. That girl should be running horses instead. She is also bartender I would not be surprised if she had a few drinks herself.“

“Excellent above average bar fare. Matched by excellent service. Rotating and core menu is great. Big bar with video games. Adjacent dining room and outside dining space. All of this adds up an to multiple lunch stops when we stay in Sister Bay. Popular with locals which is understandable.“

“I ordered a ribeye steak. First couple bites were good but after that it was mostly gristle. We told waitress but she didn't do anything about it. My husband had the prime rib which was really good. Very disappointed. We've been there before and it was always good.“

“The food was absolutely wonderful except dessert. Fabulous tenderloin steak and chicken marsala. We would order these again and again. But, when your waiter says "the all too often overlooked dessert", there is likely a reason. We were served a very dry "Slice of Paradise Cake" which was Keylime Pie, Coconut Sponge Cake & Passion Fruit. Sounded wonderful until we were served a small slice so dry that the two of us couldn't finish it. Other than dessert, we were absolutely happy with our meals and would return.“

“Fun find!! Friendly hole in the wall place. We sat at the bar and bartender was attentive and helpful. Surprised when she brought my husband his beer she said "oh I see there is a chip in the glass" and instead of getting him a new glass she just turned the chip away from him! And Then proceeded to give him his second beer in the same chipped glass. Wings were phenomenal!“