Bonnie Belle's Pastries

$ •

1520 Buckhannon Pike, Nutter Fort
(304) 622-7471


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Bonnie Belle's Pastries

Would not recommend for a wedding cake!This is the only bakery I have been to that refuses to make what the customer wants. Ask them to make something outside of what they normally make and they refuse.When asking about a wedding cake we were told "we won't do that." Could not get the flavor of cake we wanted. Lady pushes my fiance into ordering a cake completely different from what she wanted. Because "this is our most popular".The blonde with glasses who either manages or full review

Ordered 2 cakes. Price quote 24.95$ for 8 inch round. Daughter picked up cakes. They charged 64.95 for 1 of the cakes. They recommended the unicorn cake for 1 but failed to mention it was $40 on top of the 24.95$. It was way to much icing on a cake. The other cake was dry and crumbled. Icing on that one was bitter. Every person but 1 threw it in garbage. I do not recommend them. Try Sweet Nanas. I just did and wow

I just want to vent for a moment. I called Bonnie Belles Bakery to have the attached cake made for my daughter’s 7th Birthday and they told me they only make tier cakes for weddings now. So, I said “ok, it’s for a wedding” and the girl said “but we know it’s for a birthday so we can’t make it”! Is it just me or is that the dumbest thing you’ve ever heard? Just saying we’re talking semantics at this point! My review -5

More Reviews(87)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 8AM - 4PM
Wednesday 8AM - 4PM
Thursday 8AM - 4PM
Friday 8AM - 4PM
Saturday 8AM - 4PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.