22 Best Italian Restaurants near Sedalia

“We had a fabulous anniversary dinner at Gabriel's last night. The succulent lamb was the highlight of our 3-course dinner in The Old House, and it was cooked to perfection. Another plus was our server Vera, who was so knowledgeable and pleasant. She helped make this such a special evening!“

“Best gluten free Italian cuisine I've had in years! The gf arinicini is divine! So excited that they offer yummy gf bread with marinara. The gf fettuccine Alfredo is dreamy! ? Great space with top shelf friendly service! ?Dietary restrictions: Gluten free“

“Great locally owned pizza place that has charm for days. Big Bill’s looks like what you want a hidden gem, hole in the wall pizza place to look like - lots of old dark wood, booths for seating (with lots of people dining in), has a great mural on the wall in memory of 9/11, you can see people making your food and the staff is really friendly.Our pizza had a great flavor. It was well made and the ingredients tasted fresh. Nothing about it (or the business itself) is exceptionally fancy, but everything was solidly good.Families and foodies alike, if you’re looking for fresh ingredients without the fuss, this is your stop. And be sure to try their homemade meatballs and cheesecake - both are delish.Vegetarian options: Vegetables tasted freshParking: It’s in a strip mall with plenty of parking in the lot.Kid-friendliness: I brought our toddler in and she immediately asked if we could eat in. It has such an inviting and warm atmosphere. I saw a lot of families with children dining in. We’ll definitely be back and eat there.“

“We had the Tortallini Alla Fini & the braised short rib ravioli, both were delicious & had plenty of left overs for lunch the next day! As was the garlic bread, but we had to order that separately. They had a lovely Rosé. The calamari was disappointing, a bit rubbery. (you might say, well ?‍♀️ Colorado for calamari? but we have had much better locally.) We sat on the patio, which has been extended into the road, so there is no in front parking. There was construction on the side of the building, so we didn't wonder around. Maybe next time, worth a second visit :)Parking: There is a parking garage next door, can't say for sure if it is free or paid. Google shows there is parking in front of the resturaunt, there is not. Those spots have been turned into additional pation seating.“

“Absolutely a winner of the first plate club. We had been meaning to try for a while now and finally got the chance. Upon entering, it was a little dark, but honestly I don't mind that. It creates an atmosphere of seclusion at your individual table.The menu is short but robust. Honestly, this kind of quick meal and drink place, but with table service is what I love. Give me a cheese board, but then take it real seriously...YES. We all love lunchables still right? This takes it to a whole new level. We also got the meatballs which were a nice compliment to the "Table Board." And of course the wine list rounds everything out.Then you have the service. Let me tell you, Elise is the kind of server that makes going out so enjoyable. Jovial, attentive, encouraging, and knowledgeable. An all around great human being.The cherry on the top was honestly that the pricing was reasonable. Everything's more expensive and we are not complaining about any of that. But comparatively for the type of food we're getting, we felt like this was a very reasonable price and exactly what we were looking to pay.My partner and I both agree that we need to come back and start eating our way through the menu. We honestly can't wait :-).“

“Random Tuesday evening got a table right away. Bacon Blues salad was great! Plenty of bacon. Wings with their House smoke and spice sauce, we should have got the 10 count. The sauce is amazing! 4H pizza you won’t be disappointed. If Brecklynd is your server you are in luck! Also should add, my wife is gluten free and their crust is amazing!Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza is amazing and I’m not even vegetarianDietary restrictions: Great gluten free crust!“

“Second time visiting and just like the last time everything was delicious!! Every appetizer every side and every main course was highly rated by my family and friends (party of 10). Can’t wait until my next visit. Staff also let us have a mini baby shower and took photos for us as well.“

“This was our first time trying Farro Italian and we were very happy. The food was REALLY good and we will be going back. Reservations are recommended for a Friday evening and I was so glad I made them. Highly recommend! It was a good casual date night.“

“Service and food were great and the atmosphere fits the menu perfectly. Location is off the beaten path. We were traveling from GJ and found this on Trip Advisor and are glad we did! Family feel. Great taste. Great service. Son loved chicken parm sandwich and fries. I loved the special ground beef spaghetti with a little spice but so flavorful. I can’t wait to share this place with my other family members. Five stars!“

“Googled best restaurants in Castle Rock and this one came up. We had fried mushrooms and garlic bread for an appetizer and they were delicious. My brother and sister-in-law had the chicken marsala and they said it was absolutely delicious too. I had the penne pasta vodka with meatballs and talk about a huge serving! I was able to take enough home for two more meals. Oh, and it was fabulous! We were totally impressed with the food and the service! They got a calzone to go to and it was huge! Highly recommend and we will be back!Parking: It was a bit hard to find as there was not a large sign up high, only the sign on the door.“

“the Staff! 3 of us ladies came in for lunch today, 7/13, after not seeing one another for 20 some years. Emily was our waitress and was so sweet AND patient! April! Amazing and funny! Thank you ALL for tolerating us and being such great Hosts! we will be back!“

“One of my favorite pizza spots in town and my friend’s favorite when he comes to visit (Italian restaurant owner from GA). They use tipo 00 flour which doesn’t bother a lot of people with gluten issues (they have a gluten free pizza too) and they have buffalo mozzarella as an option too (which also doesn’t bother a lot of people with dairy issues). Great pizza overall regardless what issues or not you have ?.“

“We love the food and the service. We eat here a lot. A few times, something has been missing from our to-go order and they go above and beyond to fix the mistake. Chris, the manager, is awesome has been wonderful to us. Definitely recommend for some yummy food!“

“Fun engaging atmosphere for pizza or the full menu of Scileppi'sMy boyfriend and I love to sit at the bar and share a bottle wine. I love to order their pizza by the slice; the sauce and crust are perfect.He enjoys their fettuccine, which may be the perfect balance of cream, butter and cheeseMegan is wonderful, engaging and attentive.My teen children and I also love to grab a table here and enjoy them full menu.Eggplant fries, Parmesan fries and garlic knots are a must.“

“It’s an Olive Garden of course it’s amazing. But the staff were the best part. We came pretty late but it wasn’t like about to close it was 9 and they closed at 10 but this place was empty. There were only like 7 more people sitting down and eating and most of them were finished. The staff weren’t like “ughhhh (tired noises) what do you wantt ughhhh” they were actually talking KIM! Kim wasn’t a good experience she was yelling on the floor and going crazy and then she took off her pants and threw them at some guy then she smashed plates and stuff but that’s off topic. The food, I don’t have to explain of course it’s good. Atmosphere was like any other Olive Garden an Italian theme. But I’m telling you if you want good service come here. If you want to experience Kim also come here but mostly the serviceKid-friendliness: They were super kind to my youngest brother“

“Always a great experience when we come here. The food is fresh and delicious and the staff is very friendly and helpful. This is probably the only place that my kids and husband can all agree on when we decide we want to eat out ?Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. Offers kids meals for $2 with purchase of adult meal.“

“I ordered the Italian, it was good. My son ordered the Meatball sub. It came with 4 big meatballs. My only complaint was that the bread was hard. We ate kind of late so the bread was probably not as fresh as it would be for lunch. The gentleman behind the register was super nice and answered all of our questions. Would definitely go back and try again.“

“When my girlfriend lost her job and needed a pick-me-up, they delivered. We got the gluten free pizza (fire btw), but wasn't able to add pineapple on our fav menu option (The five boroughs). In the comments we explain the situation and asked for pineapple and they were able to provide it ♥️ also with a lil message. Thank you guys, really made her night.“

“Good pizza and wings. The pizza dough says alot about the pizza, theirs is freshly made, soft, perfectly flavored and is balanced out well with the toppings and the sauce. The wings are really good, not fat, but cooked to a nice crunch and tossed in a good Buffalo sauce. Would recommend coming for lunch as $10 for their lunch special is worth it.“

“Food is always delicious! The pizzas are really good and remind me of a pizza I had while on vacation in Northern Italy. The service is consistently good. The restaurant has a nice atmosphere and we especially enjoy sitting on the patio during the summer.“

“Carmine's is a treasure. This was out first time there on a recommendation from good friend. She said the tiramisu is supposed good and was she right. We also had the baked lasagna that was delicious. We'll be back for sure. Thanks Carmine's!“

“First time coming here. Nicole was outstanding at recommending and top notch service. Loved her. We had the Gorgonzola and pear pockets….delicious. Bread and dip delicious too. Caesar salad loved the presentation. Main entree my husband got lobster ravoli amazing. I had blackened shrimp and Salmon over the top. Atmosphere was perfect and watched as the entire staff was hustling to make sure their customers were happy. They all worked as a team and helped each other. Loved the vibe. Can’t wait to come back!“