D'Amato's Seafood II

$$ • Seafood Markets, Seafood

423 Whalley Ave #1, New Haven
(203) 498-2722


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for D'Amato's Seafood II

From their old location on Grand Ave, in the Fair Haven section of New Haven to their more posh dine in/take out location on Whalley Ave. D'Amato's does not disappoint. The flounder is light, flaky, and coated with greatness.I stand behind everything on their menu. They even have prepared meals you can get yourself, take home, and heat up. No mess no fuss!Well worth the price.

Went there before like crazy, when they were smaller. Food was great then, even down to the hush puppies. But NOW... no thanks! Hush puppies are oily all the time, fish marination could be better and fries were already salted yet there was added salt and pepper. They need to do better.

Came here for catfish (researched places all over to find it) but they were out. If there's something you want here call ahead to make sure they have it. It's all fresh so they run out of stuff. They were also out of cod. We opted to share fish and chips with flounder. It had good flavor, enough to share. The fries were really great. Everything super fresh and right out of the fryer. There's tons of picnic tables outside and some type of indoor dining right next door which is...read full review

More Reviews(187)


Monday 10:30AM - 6:30PM
Tuesday 10:30AM - 6:30PM
Wednesday 10:30AM - 6:30PM
Thursday 11AM - 7:30PM
Friday 11AM - 7:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 7:30PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.