9 Best Ice Cream Shops in New Haven

Gioia Cafe and Bar Italian • $$
150 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Ember Roasted Squash Agnolotti
Complimentary Garlic Knots
Complimentary Garlic Bread
Rigatoni Carbonara
Garlic Rolls
Panna Cotta

“Fabulous food, wonderful atmosphere and great staff. Noise was a bit loud, but being in a booth made all the difference. Our waiter was great, but very busy and he had a lot of tables so it took awhile to order. He was great after that - very attentive and many other helpers. Our 3rd time there and definitely my favorite spot in New Haven!!!“

4.6 Superb190 Reviews
Elena's on Orange Ice Cream Shop •
831 Orange St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pieces
Cross Cookie Sundae
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Dip
Brownie Haven
Secret Sauce
Waffle Cone
Hot Fudge
Brownie

“A dessert shop known for soft serve and high prices but justifies its cost with extremely quality dessert.Would definitely recommend getting more than just a soft serve such as the ice cream with cookie simply because combinations items are better and you will have a much better experience2nd in dessert only to Elm St. Diner***Ice cream + cookie = A brown butter chocolate toffee cookie with a hint of espresso is a rare find and exemplifies the sophistication of flavors in each of their items. Definitely a flagship itemBrownie Haven = An interesting flavor which may not be appealing to all flavor pallets but definitely delicious“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
The Clay Date Ice Cream • $$
146 Amity Rd, New Haven

“My wife and I took a private pottery throwing lesson with Emily. She inspired us to take a six week lesson followed by another six week lesson. We then became members. We love it there. What a wonderful pottery community! Thank you Jess!Side note: the paint-your-own is super popular there, as well as glass fusing, candles, and mosaics. It’s a great place to get together and drink some wine and be creative or bring the kids for a party!“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Arethusa Farm Dairy Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
1020 Chapel St, New Haven

“We love Arethusa! Best ice cream in downtown New Haven - you need to try their seasonal flavors, especially the new hazelnut with chocolate espresso beans . The seasonal pumpkin flavor is also excellent, and the sweet cream flavor is also always a go-to. Pro-tip: You can get one scoop split into two flavors - just ask! I only wish that they were open later because sometimes I crave ice cream past 8 pm!“

4.3 Superb92 Reviews
Taqueria Jalisciense LLC Ice Cream Shop • $$
271 Grand Ave, New Haven

“Stopped by 1 afternoon for some traditional Mexican and this place did not disappoint. It is a mid size spot in the center of town in Wallingford. When you walk there are about 6 tables with the person taking orders by the register. The place is super casual and the girl working on the front super friendly. We had burritos and tostadas which were very good. The burrito which was what I had was super big and flavorful. Burritos are one of those meals that you can't go wrong with. The tostadas were what you would expect, crunchy with lots of toppings. Definitely a place to stop by while in Wallingford.“

4.6 Superb12 Reviews
Ashley's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
280 York St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry
Coffee Oreo
Chip

“Such a good experience! I love ashleys its my favorite ice cream shop ever. And their black raspberry ice cream is unbelievable my favorite flavor ever. And I hate raspberries. They staff is decent they could be nicer is my only feedback. Sometimes they look like they hate their job. This location doesn't have outdoor seating just in case the one in branford does though! It's retro style and cute.Vegetarian options: All vegetarianDietary restrictions: All dairy heavyParking: Its right by Yale the parking is impossibleKid-friendliness: Decent for kids but almost no seating so get takeoutWheelchair accessibility: It's fairly open a bit cramped for a wheelchair“

4.3 Superb61 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $
159 Temple St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan
Strawberry

“Ben & Jerry's in New Haven, Connecticut is a family-run, locally owned and operated ice cream shop that has been serving up delicious scoops since 2012. The shop is located in the heart of downtown New Haven, just a short walk from Yale University and the New Haven Green.The Ben & Jerry's in New Haven is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. The shop is always busy, but the staff is friendly and efficient, and they move the line quickly.The wide variety of unique and creative ice cream flavors, including vegan and dairy-free options.The high-quality ingredients and delicious taste of the ice cream.The friendly and efficient staff.The convenient location in the heart of downtown New Haven.“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
254 1/2 Kimberly Ave, New Haven

“How can I begin this review? The staff at dairy Queen should have their own sitcom. They are so much fun but professional at the same time. I ordered the Cherry dip cone. The same kind of treat I used to get as a child. Actually, I felt like a child again. This smooth chocolate taste combined with cherry flavor was so good. As I said, the whole package is awesome. I think I'll call the manager or owner and tell them what a nice experience I had there.“

4.1 Good23 Reviews
Insomnia Cookies Ice Cream • $$
240-242 College St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Cookie Sandwich
Insomnia Chocolate Cookie Butter
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Mint Chocolate Chip
Cookie Selection
Birthday Cake
Snickerdoodle
Sample Box
Vegan

“Always so fresh and warm each cookie I’ve gotten over the last 4 years. The staff are friendly. I was able to get a sample of a vegan chocolate cookie which I’d never usually try on my own and been hooked ever since thank you. Always quick as well, and the location is great so many things to explore and experience but even better ending the night with freshly baked cookies from you guys.“

4.1 Good78 Reviews
Loading...
map Map