Bakeries near Old Lyme

“Elana made delicious cupcakes to celebrate my son’s birthday. Elana delivered her goodies precisely on time at US Coast Guard Academy with paper plates and napkins! I highly recommend and will place orders with Elana in the future. Below is a screenshot of my Elana recommendation at the Facebook USCGA Class of 2025 Parents Group page.“

“The food at the village cafe is incredibly good. The meals are delicious and made with real ingredients. The owners and staff are always welcoming and go out of their way to accommodate customers. I have been going there since they opened and everything is always kept meticulously clean.“

“Great service and food, even when they are busy the line moves quickly. Everything I've had there has been delicious and you can make a preorder ahead of time for events or if you just want to guarantee you get what you want. If you're in the area for sure give them a try. The ambience is neighborly/ family friendly .“

“First, I don't normally like chocolate flourless cake. It tends to be dense and dry so not worth the calories. But this ...this cake...is everything. It's smooth and silky...unless you're allergic, you have to eat this. Your mouth will thank you! The cheesecake is light and whippy, and not too sweet, and the fruit are fresh and happy just sitting there on top with powdered sugar. You must eat have it!!“

“I’ve now ordered for 2 business events and again for Thanksgiving from here (not to mention some trips in between). My customers were blown away by the attention to detail on the sugar cookies for both events and we have not had a single item as a family we wouldn’t recommend (a few favorites- morning glory muffin, cinnamon sugar donut, pumpkin cheesecake). Amazing service, amazing desserts!“

“So finally I stopped in for my mans birthday week. It's a smaller version of mystic and limited quanity because I was looking for the lemon tart, which is absolutely delicious. They didn't have it, but the woman told me to call ahead of time to see if available next time. Got macaroons and a sugar cookie. None of the other desserts were allergy friendly for me. They also had sandwiches and baked goods. ? Just don't go in hungry. It could be bad for you. Everything looked tasty.Ya having this place close by isn't a good thing for my waist. It's also a place where you have a variety to choose from, which makes you want to keep coming back.All things pumpkin right now! Im in heaven...my go to usually is their lemon tart and oatmeal blueberry cookie. It's also nice to try something different. They had a croissant filled with pumpkin. They were going fast, but I was able to get one. It's always good when you leave and have a big smile and a sift bag.“

“Sweet little dessert shop with pastry and cakes to eat in or takeout. Coffee available. Excellent German specialties like strudel, stollen and Liebküchen. Small counter with only 3 stools though. We stopped by after lunch out at Fresh Salt.“

“Some of the best bread I have had...comparable to Hungry Ghost in Northampton and Standard Bakery in Portland ME. Not just bread, great scones, cookies and sweet rolls. We haven't had the pastas and other things but they really do use the best ingredients and take their time with their yeast and sourdough breads. A true hidden gem.“

“I love this Pepperidge Farm store. It is not very big, but it is always fun to come down here and explore all the things they have, not just their signature goldfish, but also things like Tim Tams and the Chessmen Butter Cookies (my personal favorite. It is just a cool experience. I only really go once a year since I don’t live anywhere near by (4+ hours), but when I do I enjoy coming, and the staff is always really friendly.“