Cafe Sitaly

$$ • Pizza, Italian, Sandwich Shops

Hours:
1710 Naamans Rd, Wilmington
(302) 475-1120

Ratings

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Tips

Reviews for Cafe Sitaly

Decided to stop in here tonight for take out. After reading numerous positive reports, figured this shop must be decent.Ordered large cheese with ricotta. Pizza was not cooked and basically rushed out is my assumption. Further to the pain, I had to recut the pizza once at home prior eating. Pizza was shared by 3. Everyone commented not good. This was the worst pizza that I have sampled in months.Got wings too. Asked for extra crispy. Got standard wings with a mediocre hot...read full review

Meh Yeah, my expectations were reasonable going; how hard is it to make a cheesesteak? The sub roll was soggy, yet the meat was dry; wth, how did you manage to achieve this? We swapped out the American cheese for the provolone, yeah could barely taste if there was any cheese on it. You're close to Philly, we all expected more from you. Pizza was just okay, lotta cheese and barely any sauce

Used to be so delicious and attention to a perfect pizza. During 2019-2020 we ordered probably 12 different times for take out. Always the same pizza. A pretty simple one - pepperoni with extra fresh garlic. The first pizza was a masterpiece and wonderful. Subsequent pizzas had no garlic or little garlic Each time the person on the phone had to be told 3 or 4 times for the extra garlic and still we encountered the little or not garlic pizza. One time we got home and had bacon!...read full review

More Reviews(156)

Hours

Monday 10:30AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday 10:30AM - 9:30PM
Wednesday 10:30AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 10:30AM - 9:30PM
Friday 10:30AM - 10PM
Saturday 10:30AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.