12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fernandina Beach

“dang good pizza and best bang for your buck!“

“Customer service was great! Food was delicious. Would definitely recommend! And Nettie ( sorry if I spelled it wrong) was very helpful“

“Best pizza I've found on the island! The pizza bottom is browned, and large slice with house salad makes a perfect lunch. Servers were great, and attentive!!“

“I came here for dinner and it was amazing. Once we got seated, the wait was a little bit to get served, but our waiter did a great job when he did get to us. The food was delicious. I had a Garden Salad with grilled chicken, and it was so good.“

“This Italian restaurant gem is one of my favorites. They make the best stromboli & lasagna & have a wonderful salad bar. The service is good, considering that it's just one person waiting tables many times (the owner has told me that she has trouble hiring & keeping reliable help). I eat there as often as possible.“

“i’m from the New York area and their pizza is the best I’ve had in Florida. This is the only place I go for pizza on the island.

The only thing I don’t like is that it can be very noisy inside the restaurant they have these noisy arcade games where you punch little thing that pop up and it’s ridiculously noisy. the wine is very expensive but it’s all worth it for the great pizza. The frozen yogurt is pretty good.

Vegetarian options: Well, you can design your own pizza so if you don’t put meat on it, then you have a great vegetarian option!

Kid-friendliness: There are a bunch of arcade games for kids and the kids seem to really like the frozen yogurt. It’s beautiful outside with a big lake. It’s the on the Amelia Island Plantation atmosphere. We go there about once a week.“

“Amazing food. Had the Hawaiian pizza and bruschetta - both prepared perfectly Friendly, attentive waitress - Lisa“

“Best NY style pizza in the area!“

“Wayne (pizza specialist) made the best pizza I've ever had from dominos last night!! yum!“

“what in the floppy disk pizza is this? we put it in the oven when we got home and it was still Flopsy Mopsy Cottontail. severely undercooked and raw dough. Not great“

“We dined for brunch on 3/9/24 and had an absolutely wonderful experience. It was a VERY rainy morning which meant there were no outdoor tables for anyone. There must have 10 people waiting for a table in their reception area at the time of our reservation. In spite of this, the staff remained smiling and cheerful while they delivered a great dining experience. Their hostess worked very hard to communicate the status of everyone’s place in line along with those customers who had made reservations as well, again with a very pleasant demeanor. Now to the food! They have quite possibly the best French Toast I have ever had. The brioche bread was thick and perfectly prepared. My wife had their Caprese omelette and cheese grits which was also just terrific. The wait staff were attentive without overdoing things. Coffee cups never got empty before a refill was offered. One of our group was a tea drinker and she had a teapot of hot water and tea bags seemingly within seconds of ordering. The highlight of the meal came when we mentioned that one of our diners (the lady with the tea) was celebrating her birthday. The owner of the restaurant, a lovely woman, came out and actually gave gifted her the tea service that was on our table! She would not hear of us paying for the set and said she wanted to make a gift of the set. Completely unexpected!! I cannot recommend this restaurant any higher. In spite of a very difficult morning, none of which was their doing, the staff and management made everyone’s morning better!“

“Excellent burger’s and good soup 🥣“