50 Best Italian Restaurants near Key Biscayne

“It seems to be simple but honestly the flavors are on another level…. Chicken Milanese, lasagna, the OMG meat empanada even the bread with oil have perfectly balanced flavors. The incredible flavor of the tomatoes in the lasagna can only be described by tasting them and the chocolate in the dessert mousse are perfect. I recommend them and would return for more!“

“For sure the best restaurant in key Biscayne. Consistency y the secret. Great ambience, extraordinary attention and service, a great menu with real and different special dishes every day, a superb wine selection and the constant attention of the owner who is always around making sure that every detail is up to his personal standards consistently. Must ma a reservation. Enjoy !!!“

“It's always nice to have a dinner in Milanezza! Sometimes, they have live events. The Food is amazing, Try the Bianca milanezza dish! They recommended it. It's a worth a try! The atmosphere is cozy! but a little cramp, when it gets full especially during events. Overall! it's worth coming back again!“

“We had a lovely meal here with our family which included 2 toddlers. People around us were older and more dressed up. The staff were incredibly kind and helpful, they even went to borrow a extra high chair from a restaurant down the lane. We thoroughly enjoyed the food. It tasted very home made. Not oily or too salty. Would definitely recommend going back! It came across as a charming family ran restaurant.“

“If you want to try some new flavors and great meals go to this place.The pear ravioli had me amaze. You gotta try itThe best dessert, dulce de leche with coconut. So good!Thank you Tutto for the great service, atmosphere and excellent staff.“

“Once again, a lovely dinner! The commitment of this family owned restaurant to the highest quality and preparation of dishes. The truffled spaghetti had real truffles, not truffle oil. It is well worth the price whether for a family dinner or a Wednesday night meal.“

“Fabulous homemade food! This friendly, family owned business, is one of the best restaurants on Key Biscayne! The food is fresh, homemade and very high quality. The staff is friendly and very attentive. I highly recommend Forchetta to anyone looking for a great meal. Well worth the price.“

“My family has been coming here since they opened. We celebrated Mother’s Day, Easter brunch a bourbon tasting and other evenings for dinner. Our most recent visit was for Easter Brunch. Manuela took care of us and was wonderful. The food has always been consistently good as has the service and the prices are VERY reasonable for the quality of the food and the portion sizes - especially in Key Biscayne. This is still a hidden gem. We loved the personalized service and the serene atmosphere. Definitely worth the visit.“

“If I could give Luca Osteria 10 stars I would!! I first found this place from a food blogger on instagram and I am so glad I did. First thing you must make a reservation before going because there is limited seating and this place is always full. We didn't have a reservation and the hostess was so helpful to get us a spot at the bar. The manager saw that we felt very crowded at the bar so they were able to give us a table for two. Even though it's a little smaller inside, the restaurant is so beautiful and classy. We had the perfect date night. We started with a couple appetizers the patate frite and the Local Stracciattella. The patate frite was so perfectly crispy and creamy with the sharp flavor of the truffle. The creamy Stracciattella with the crispy bread was the best combo. For our entree we ordered the short rib bolognese with fresh pappardelle pasta. Now I don't usually order the bolognese, it's usually just basic flavors but I truly enjoyed this one thanks to the short ribs. My husband ordered a pasta with bucatini pasta that was delicious too. We were so full from this lovely meal but we had to try a dessert. We were recommended to ordered the Pistachio Semifreddo, it was very different. It was sweet and salty and the chocolate ganache was so perfect. One thing I really appreciated from this restaurant was the employees they were so attentive and after every single meal they cleaned and wiped down our table. I have never seen that before at any restaurant even the fanciest expensive places don't even do that for you. We can't wait to go back and try new items on the menu. And I will recommend this place to anyone that's in Coral Gables. And if you ever need anything, ask the manager JJ.“

“My new favorite restaurant in Miami. Creative excellent food, friendly professional service, relaxed atmosphere, no fuss.Ordered five dishes: carrot tartare, maitake mushroom, gnocchi, short rib and pizza. All were amazing, and our server, Lauren, was just the best, highly recommended.“

“One of the best restaurant experiences and some of the best food I’ve had in Miami anywhere. Servers were super knowledgeable and the food seemed well thought out and intentional. Pasta and appetizers were excellent, but dessert was not as exciting. Would definitely recommend!“

“Was looking for a chill, but good vibe Italian restaurant and came across this place. I absolutely loved the food! The food was amazing, tasty, and our waitress Sole was marvelous! I would definitely recommend if you’re looking for friendly service, good food, and good drinks!! I recommend the strawberry mint and the bucatini cacio e Pepe!!“

“This is the most underrated place in Miami. My husband and I are foodies and honestly we have had the opportunity to go to many well know places with Michelin stars between Miami and New York. Let me tell you, Fiola has nothing to envy those places. The service I would dare to say is the best I’ve had in Miami, we went for our anniversary and from the moment we walked in the door it was all smiles. Kevin and Edwin (i hope I’m writing their names correctly) were AMAZING!!! So detail oriented, knowledgeable and sweet. The food was also incredible, a must would be their wagyu pasta with osobuco. Their pastas were so fresh and perfectly cooked. Would recommend this place to anyone. We are a younger crowd, but when it comes to food we take it seriously. Skip all the overrated Miami places that are all show and make a reservation at Fiola.Also I’m a vlogger and I really appreciate when people don’t get annoyed by it. In this place, they made sure to let me know when they were about to do anything that would mess with the aesthetics of the BEAUTIFUL plates so that i could record or take pictures. Kevin even provided me with good lighting? without me asking which I thought was very sweet.“

“Had a wonderful dinner here with my family on the last day of our vacation and it was an excellent choice! It started raining when we were sitting outside and they immediately arranged a nice spot at the patio, especially for our daughter who was in her wheelchair. We felt very welcome. Agata was our server and she was so friendly and helpful. We had a nice chat about Poland. She made our last dinner in Miami memorable. Dziękuję Agata! The food is very good and tasteful, good portions. When in Miami we will come back!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a special ramp where you can easily enter the patio.“

“Boia De is very special. Bold flavor with a delicate execution. The staff are humbly proud of their accomplishments and the Michelin Star is well deserved. The smoked muscles were delicious you need them. Steak tar-tar you must have. The gnocchi will change your life and the lamb could alter they ways of man & possibly change the world. No liquor needed here. Creative mixology with sake & Pilsner will make you happy. Desert a must… buy 2. Or 3.. Love from Mary & Peter“

“Visited Limoncello for the first time in Miami and I am so impressed! A little piece of Italy in Miami with incredible authentic food and lovely, friendly staff. Me and my friends had the burrata starter with carpaccio, bolognese, octopus & some limoncello cocktails, finishing off with espresso martinis and tiramisu. All the dishes were 10/10. Can’t wait to come back! Thank you so much ❤️“

“Amazing restaurant! Beautiful decorations across 2 floors with outdoor terase. The service was indeed 5 stars, waiters being so professional and knowledgeable. The spicy lobster spaghetti was perfect and the squash carpaccio is the best we ever had ! The tiramisu called crema inglese in the menu was super delicious ! Overall best food and service in Miami“

“My husband has always wanted to eat at Carbone in NYC, but the waitlist is so long. We were happy to score at 5:30pm reservation while visiting Miami. There is both indoor and outdoor dining. The vibe is that of old NY Italian. We were seated and our server immediately introduced herself. She took our drink order and the fresh bread, fennel and cauliflower were brought out to the table. For an appetizer we ordered the prosciutto and mozzarella. The mozzarella was so fresh it was still warm! It was so good!!! The prosciutto was sliced perfectly and tasted amazing. We shared the lobster ravioli. The ravioli was 99% lobster and stuffed. It was amazing. The sauce was creamy yet light. For our entree we ordered the shrimp scampi that was priced per piece. These shrimp were gigantic! We each had 2 shrimp and it was plenty. We were so full we decided not to have dessert but our server brought out some Italian cookies with a candle for my husbands birthday. This meal is definitely in our top 10!“

“I have come here a few times for drinks but today was the first time I ate in the dining room. The food and service was amazing. Marco was a fantastic waiter. He always ensured our waters were filled and regularly checked in on us at a frequency that was not annoying. The food was way above what I expected. Living in brickell I have accepted that most places focus on presentation of the food rather than the quality. Here all three meals were highly rated. The star for me was the hueco estralledos. The chicken and waffles were very filling for my companions and they both said it tasted homemade. Highly recommend this place!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian here. There’s enough vegetarian options to satisfy out diet.“

“Absolutely wonderful! I'm trying to convince my husband to go back tonight, our last night in Miami. There is nothing I didn't love about this restaurant. The atmosphere was like being in my Nana's home. Sure, it's tight on space, but so was Nana's kitchen. And it was packed on a Monday night, a generally slow night for restaurants. Our server, Tomas was a pleasure to work with. Attentive, but not bothersome. He offered suggestions without pressure that we felt at another Italian restaurant nearby. We shared an excellent Caesar salad with anchovies to start. So good! Next, I ordered the Tagliatelle Alla Bolognese, which was heavenly. My husband had Pappardelle Al Ragú Di Agnello, which he thoroughly enjoyed. I didn't get to taste it because I wouldn't share mine. Fair is fair, I suppose. Tomas paired our meal with a wonderful Primitivo Puglia that was perfect. Then he suggested dessert, and although I was stuffed, we shared a cannoli. It was delicious also, but I really didn't need it. The surprise limoncello, on the house, was a perfect ending to a perfect meal! An aside? Watching the pasta being made in the front window was a bonus. I learned some things I'll use at home!“

“I really NEVER write reviews unless it's really bad, or really good. For our first time in Miami and restaurant to eat. All great things to say about this place. Everything from the ambiance, food, and service from Giuseppe, staff, down to the manager Allegra. If you're on the fence, just do it. If your experience will be the same as ours, you won't regret it.“

“We had the BEST experience at Mister 01 and cannot wait to come back! Our waitress, Abbey made all the difference. It felt like fine dining in Dallas’ Harwood District. Worth the wait on a Friday night. We had giggled about whether the pizza would really be “Extraordinary” and it actually was! Especially the crust. They also have gluten-free and vegan options. Be a sure you take the time to let your server give you the backstory on the restaurant. It’s pretty awesome!! The icing on the cake was upon leaving when Abbey gave us handmade origami hearts with encouraging words inside. She didn’t know it, but we sure needed those sweet words! Thank you Abbey and Chef for a wonderful evening.“

“Everything was extremely positive, from the welcome from the manager on the front line, to the impeccable and fast service, Martina, the girl who served us, was friendly, precise and very nice, the quality of the dishes was excellent. It's worth spending an evening there....Italy in Miami is only the pasta chef“

“Me and my friend had dinner in this typical Italian restaurant, well, what can I say, terrific!Stefano took good care of us, suggesting the best plates of the house, the list of wine is pretty nice, but the food was so authentic, definitely worth it.Grazie Stefano, sei il migliore!“

“Bravo!!! The food was outrageous, service impecable and wine selection impressive. An upscale Italian restaurant in the heart of coral gables. It’s obvious they use only the finest and freshest ingredients in their dishes as the branzino melted in your mouth as did the mushroom risotto. A memorable meal made even better by attentive and professional service staff. 5 star all around!“

“I am having a 4 day stay in Mid Miami and Piola is absolutely the freshest Modern Italian Restaurant!I went for 3 lunches and 2 dinners with amazing service each time. Gloriana being one of them was so attentive and professional even going outside the box to give my son the best experience.This place is not part of the Hampton Inn, totally seperate and deserves attention from many with a lavish taste but not the large price tag.Everything is so fresh, my favorite being the guacamole with delicious breadsticks.I give this place 5 stars in all areas! Give it a try and you will leave in with great energy!Thank you all for the best experience!Kindly- jen“

“Hands down the only place where the food matches the service, which matches the ambiance and combines for an experience that you just can't replicate anywhere else. This place is a Miami monument for a reason, and the moment you walk in you know you're in for an incredible experience. You can't be within 100 miles of this place and not come take in the amazing time to be had at Eating House!!!“

“First time in this restaurant, we were not disappointed.Angie is exceptional as a waitress, her good humor is infectious!The dishes are careful and well presented.Ordering was quick and prices are average at Ocean Drive.I recommend you go there for breakfast.“

“Mohammad was an excellent server and made our experience beautiful! ! The food was wonderful and it was great to be on the outside seeing all the people walk . It was a great time with me and my husband . When we visit again from Ohio we will be sure to come back and hopefully see Mohammad again !“

“The service is excellent, you know it from the beginning to the end.Food also very good, the beef carpaccio very tender, the wagio sliders very tasty and the pasta with seafood was good but I sense that the seafood is not freah but from a frozen kind, I didn't ask..The place can be noisy if there is a group of young guys ?‍? talking very loudly“

“The food was great. For dinner we had New York Steak and it was cooked to perfection, $35 for a large portion. For those staying at this hotel (like us) 20% off. The breakfasts are excellent and at a very good price. I recommend.Updating my review.Also we were here for lunch.My son ordered pizza a second time, my husband tried Paella and I enjoyed delicious BBQ Ribs.I love that place so much ?“

“This delightful beachside panino shop quickly became our favorite spot in Miami and our #1 recommendation for friends and family visiting - already miss it! The freshness and quality of the ingredients is only rivaled by the owners, who are incredibly friendly and cool and know how to make a place feel like home. Hands down Botta serves the best food around, especially the panini; coming from two discerning Italians with deep culinary roots and keen appetites that's saying a lot! ?“

“I sat a people watched from the best place I've been since arriving to Miami. The service was great. My server, Tony, was great. He has a beautiful smile and personality. I'll definitely come back if i visit Miami again... don't judge me, i love cheese!Chicken parm ?“

“We had an epic experience at this gem called Log. Our server Gonzalo was absolutely perfect and visited our table the absolute perfect amount to make this amazing. Even the table busers were on topOf their game. Highly recommend and will definitely take visitors here!!!!“

“Atmosphere 8.5/10Pretty cool, dark atmosphere - great for a late night cocktail. Best spots are around the bar. A lot of tasteful design elements and details (animals and history). Upscale - stylishDrinks 8.5/10Substantial cocktail menu for every taste. “Very strong baby” is a signature Negroni - was good. Fino Martini however was a bit boring. One of the coolest coasters i have seen - super stylish and high quality. Custom glasses for every drink.Service 8.5/10We had to wait 20-30min for a seat at the bar on a Fr night. The bartender team is cool and friendly. Water served immediately. Would recommend to focus on drinks instead of food, here.20% automatic gratuity, is not my favorite feature, but for this place appropriate.“

“A Five-Star Experience!I recently had the pleasure of dining at Pummarola, and I must say, it was an unforgettable culinary experience from start to finish. From the moment we walked in, the warm and inviting ambiance set the tone for a delightful evening.The menu at Pummarola is a true testament to authentic Italian cuisine. Each dish is meticulously crafted with fresh ingredients, bursting with flavors that transport you straight to Italy. The pasta dishes, in particular, were cooked to perfection, showcasing the chef's expertise and passion for quality.The service was impeccable, with attentive staff who were knowledgeable about the menu and eager to make recommendations based on our preferences. Our server guided us through the wine list, helping us pair the perfect wine with our meal, enhancing the overall dining experience.The attention to detail was evident in every aspect of our meal, from the beautifully presented appetizers to the mouthwatering desserts. The portion sizes were generous, ensuring we left fully satisfied yet already planning our next visit to try more of their delicious offerings.Overall, Pummarola exceeded my expectations in every way possible. It's not just a restaurant; it's a culinary journey that leaves a lasting impression. I highly recommend Pummarola to anyone looking for an authentic Italian dining experience that is sure to delight the senses. Five stars without a doubt! Pummarola is the future. I’d also like to add that Lorenzo Exemplifies Excellence in Service: Lorenzo at Pummarola is a standout waiter whose service elevated our dining experience. His menu knowledge and thoughtful recommendations enhanced our meal, and his genuine enthusiasm and professionalism made us feel valued throughout. Lorenzo's impeccable timing and attention to detail ensured a seamless and enjoyable evening. We highly commend Lorenzo for his exceptional service and look forward to returning to Pummarola for another memorable dining experience with him. Grazie mille, Lorenzo!“

“Really amazing pizza with great daily deals makes it hard to justify NOT going to Pummarola! Very friendly and welcoming staff, too. Always willing to accommodate and go the extra mile for their customers.Not too many tourists wander in here, making it a great local spot too not too far from Lincoln Road. Highly recommend!!!“

“The drinks are really good if you want to come and just have drinks. The food was good as well. The waiter was super nice and took his time to answer any questions and explained everything as well. The environment is nice and you can people watch as you enjoy your drinks/food.“

“Immediately upon entering we were greeted by Mirna and offered different options. Our waiter, Jose was extremely attentive and made several suggestions from the menu. The food was amazing and the ambiance is great. Definitely a great place to eat where the staff makes you feel like family .“

“My visit to Mosaico - Maurizio Farinelli in South Miami was a sublime culinary experience. The cozy atmosphere and elegant decor anticipated an exceptional meal, which truly exceeded all expectations.The menu is an impressive fusion of Italian flavors with touches of Japan and the Middle East. I started with an exquisite tuna tartare that stood out for its freshness and flavor. I followed with tagliatelle bolognese and cacio e Pepe, both dishes prepared to perfection, showcasing the quality of the local ingredients. The Gnocchi alla Norcina was another triumph, with a texture and flavor that invited you to continue enjoying.The service was exceptional, every detail was meticulously taken care of, Mosaico - Maurizio Farinelli is a gem in South Miami and a must-see destination for lovers of good Italian food.“

“Loved this bar! Yary absolutely killed the hookah on a Tuesday and Mili killed it on the drinks! Really Yary straight knew what we needed, had great recommendations and was super fun to have! The environment is super comfy and chill too! The manager also hooked us up! Wonderful experience all around! Highly recommend!!!“

“Very authentic Italian food! I got the gnocchi and it was cooked to perfection. Mine was a little greasy from the cheese and it could have used a little seasoning. The atmosphere sitting on Lincoln road and people watch is always a treat! Friendly service and you know they have fresh ingredients as they make the pasta fresh in the window!“

“Place had a cool look, calm and understanding employees, an enjoyable and calm atmosphere, and delicious pizza. Would recommend for the employees to cut the pizza a bit more evenly so it can be shared fairly among groups and siblings Overall 4.9/5“

“Great spot ! We stopped here after a visit to Vizcaya and it was the perfect place. The food was so fresh and delicious ! It was hard to choose what to eat because everything looked good. Luckily our waiter was super helpful on recommending great choices . The service was incredibly kind and helpful. When in the area we’re definitely coming back side“

“Wow! What a wonderful, super Delicious and delightful restaurant!! All the food was so amazing! It was above and beyond! Highly recommend period!! We look forward to coming back and making this restaurant one of ours at the top of the list! Thank you! thank you again! Liz, Gregg and “

“What a pleasant surprise. We all are exposed to Reels and Tik Toks to the best this and the best that. Specially when it comes to Restaurants. But this pizza spot is genuine, unique and cozy. With a great ingredients, an honest menu and a traditional Roman pizza, Casa Roma is worth stopping by.And wait til the word gets out on the patio. It’s like Rome all over again.I had the Margarita, a Pepperoni and a Fried Bolognese Risotto that was amazing.Congrats!!!“

“Fresh and delicious sushi, salads, tempura, desserts, sangria and many more. Great place to have a meeting, enjoy time with family and friends. A perfect spot for a date. The atmosphere is pleasant and amazing service with smile. I highly recommend it!“

“Great neighborhood restaurant with extensive menu options! Food, service, atmosphere are outstanding! Manny, Marcos and the rest of the staff make you feel welcomed and part of a family…highly recommend this gem! Thank you for making our brunch/reunion so special.“

“I visited L'Artisteria for the first time and absolutely loved everything! The atmosphere and vibe of the restaurant is very inviting and high end, our server and the high quality ingredients of the pizza's. You must go when in the Brickel area!“