47 Best Italian Restaurants near Madeira Beach

“I had the pasta primavera and it was so good! We also had spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parm, lasagna, and ziti. Everyone loved their food. Service was great as well. Definitely an authentic feel - this is not just a chain Italian restaurant, and you'll get that authentic vibe as soon as you walk in. Excellent!“

“We are local regulars within walking distance and love our regular Pizza, Sub & Salad Pit stops! Their Draft is cold and Martinis great! Their great food is also served next door at the Salt Water Hippie! The outside deck offers wonderful views of Archibald Park and the atmosphere is Beach Casual! Great Italian cuisine.“

“One of the best Italian restaurants we’ve ever been to!! Everything was so delicious and flavorful! We ordered the truffle fries - amazing. We also ordered pasta rustica (I modified and took out the mushrooms and olives, and I added chicken) it was definitely the best plate we had! The lasagna and tiramisu were also made to perfection. We definitely will be coming back here!“

“This is the second visit to this excellent restaurant. The food, menu, service, prices are outstanding. The servers make it a great experience, The chefs make the best dinners and thier sauce is the best I have had. You won't be disappointed. See you next year.“

“If you prefer NY style pizza look no further! I highly recommend the Badabing. Everything we've tried has been very good and the prices are extremely reasonable. Their delivery drivers are very prompt and on time, calling to make sure they find the correct apt. I appreciate that. The house salad is a huge portion! Enough to feed at least 2 ppl. The mozzarella sticks are on point. My fav. Fantastic pizza spot! A rare find in the land of mediocre pizza and high end overpriced pizza places. Keep up the great work guys!“

“Da Sesto continues to be a part of my annual trip to the Tampa area for Spring Training. This is my 6th or 7th year of making Da Sesto part of my dining plans and never disappoints. An incredible selection of food and beverage in a wonderful atmosphere with excellent service. Make sure to leave room for dessert!“

“Cora & Kennedy were so incredibly sweet & accommodating with the wedding dinner party! I can’t thank them enough for the service during Adelaide & Collin’s wedding party, they were phenomenal and personable ! Cant recommend Pias enough for their food & service! If I’m ever visiting from Kansas City again, Pias will be on my go to list!“

“First time I came here I was blown away. Came back almost a year later to double check. Sure enough this place is still great. Order a gourmet pizza I truly believe its the best pizza in Florida!! Brushetta and Tiramisu are always excellent. Service is a little lacking but not bad enough to dock a star. A must try if you are in the area!!Parking: Limited spots during the rush“

“OK, first let me say I could drink the Greek salad dressing...I must not be the only one because they sell it by the bottle, lol. The Greek salad is amazing they have two types.. and the sandwiches are big.. They also have a bakery section. I tried cheesecake once it was fresh and well made.“

“Was out and about in St.Pete/Pinellas Park and stumbled on to this little gem. It's in a strip mall at the end off of Park Street. The owners, cook, serve and run the business. It's neighborhood quaint. The Pasta Fagioli was amazing. The Pizza , small was enough for three people. It was a solid 9 out of 10. The sauce was good and pizza crust was perfect. The sausage was sliced not crumbled, it was loaded with toppings. It was busy and they kept everything coming out of the kitchen with minimal wait. They serve beer and wine. The wine was ok, it's either red or white, no bottles. They also serve beer. For the price and quantity it was good. It's a try if you're in the area. For the price“

“We hired them for our Annual Party and they were awesome. Great communication, showed up early, and the food was terrific! I can't wait to go downtown on my own and try some of their other delicious food selections. We would definitely use them again. Thanks again for making our party great!“

“Soooo refreshing to enjoy a true, delicious, fresh Italian Pizza! This little gem in the plaza with Publix is tucked away, but what a gem. Calzoni, meatballs, chianti, tiramisu, cappuccino… absolute heaven! So happy to have discovered it :) Bon Appetit!“

“The food is always amazing. We have been here a few times before and never has the food or service been less than perfect. My husband and I eloped recently and had a family dinner here after. The owner and our waitresses were so sweet and kind and did everything they could to make the meal go perfect (which it did!) I am very grateful to the owner and I believe his daughters who made a special evening perfect with amazing food for us and our families“

“Such a cool little pizza joint! Definitely the local pizza place, service was so good by the girl working. Very personal, treated us as though we were regulars. The food is very good. Loved their cheese bread and garlic knots! They have an awesome sauce that they heat, which is always the best. They do sell beer which is a BIG PLUS! Their atmosphere was quaint, but fitting. March Madness on TV with an awesome music playlist running in the background. So glad we went out of our way to try this place!“

“What a gem! This little place is outstanding on all fronts…I hesitate to add another 5-star review for fear it will get so popular that we can’t get a reservation, but Gusto deserves every star! The food was super tasty and the presentation was top-notch. We sat at the bar and the service was spot-on: welcoming and informative without being overbearing. Will for sure be back many times…“

“On my last visit to St. Pete I was driving after 10pm looking for where to eat pizza and all the restaurants were closed and searching on Goggle I found this pizza place that is not only excellent but is open until no more and no less than 3am and when I tried the pizza I ordered half Pepperoni and half cheese and it turned out to be one of the best I have eaten in recent times and an excellent service, authentic flavor and freshness in its ingredients 10/10 this pizzeria is 100% recommended by @ followmeyengordaOn my last visit to St. Pete I was driving after 10pm looking for where to eat pizza and all the restaurants were closed and searching on Goggle I found this pizza place that is not only excellent but is open until no more and no less than 3am and when I tried the pizza I ordered half Pepperoni and half cheese and it turned out to be one of the best I have eaten in recent times and an excellent service, authentic flavor and freshness in its ingredients 10/10 this pizzeria is 100% recommended by @ followmeyengorda“

“This restaurant is phenomenal. Our family loves trying Italian restaurants on our travels and Casa did not disappoint. Our waiter was great! Made us laugh, gave us recommendations, and the food….wow! Everyone enjoyed their meals so much, we even had dessert which we never do, but it was worth it. You can feel the Italian family atmosphere in this place, and it shines through in every way. Don’t miss out on a meal at Casa Italia!!Kid-friendliness: Great for all ages!“

“Immediate great vibe on entering. Served quickly and even got a custom order made by the staff that was phenomenal. The pizza is phemonal, generous portion sizes and a fun friendly staff and great place to grab a quick filling lunch or dinner.Not only is this my goto pizza place whenever possible, but now i stop in even if i just want a great salad!Dietary restrictions: Had no problem at all getting a low carb awesome chicken salad made custom for m when I shared one of our party was on severe dietary restrictions. Not only a great salad but one of the best salads I've tasted in a very very long time!“

“Good Food, but Rushed We were the first customers of the day—early for us. I think the servers meant well, but everything was rushed. I felt like I was in a fast casual restaurant rather than a place where I would spend $125 for the two of us. Slow it down a bit and let us digest for a minute before dropping the next course. The food was good. We started with the recommended Bruschetta. It isn’t typical. Instead, the topping is in an accompanying bowl. The topping was delicious—how can you go wrong with tomatoes, basil and garlic in balsamic vinegar? We then shared a bowl of their special tomato bisque and it was delicious. We also shared a Caesar salad which my wife thought was too garlicy (I’m not sure that’s possible), so I ate her share. The server had asked me if I did or didn’t want anchovies on my salad so I said sure, but on the side. I had no idea that I’d be charged an extra $2.50, especially since it didn’t say that on the menu. Shame, shame. For mains I had the Pasta Pescatore which was good, but a little oily. My wife had the Chicken Piccata which she enjoyed. We accompanied those with some wines by the glass from their decent collection and they were fairly priced. I might go back, but I’d be clear with the server about not being rushed.“

“DeRusso's (or Marco's as we still refer to it) is a gem on Tierra Verde and surrounding. A solid and reliable experience with good pizza (request "very" well done and double cut) apps (meatballs and garlic knots), subs, salads, dinners and more. They have a bar and small dine-in area that is cozy and convenient and don't forget, they deliver!! ??“

“This was our first time ordering here and I can definitely say "I'll be back soon and often" .Pizza was excellent - my wife and I ate the whole 14". Great Crust and plenty of toppings. Carlos makes you feel like an old friend from the neighborhood.“

“Ate dinner here for the first time Friday night and everything we ordered was very good. HUGE portions - we got pasta dishes because we saw so many being ordered and they didn’t disappoint. Service was good despite them being busy, we even brought dessert home. We will definitely be back or try the convenient pickup window, there’s so many other things we want to try.“

“We have been coming here yearly since 2011. This trip I had the pollo verducci and my wife had the rigatoni ala vodka. Both were outstanding. The woman who served us was a delight. We’ve never had anything but a great experience at Verduccis. We highly recommend this restaurant and hope to return for many more annual visits.“

“Oh my goodness, what took us so long to finally stop and eat at Circo Italian Kitchen after driving past it twice daily? Their homemade pasta is out of this world; their sauces to die for; their homemade bread served with sweet tomato jam and Kalamata olive tapenade is a mouth-watering start-up. If there is a finer Italian restaurant anywhere—and I’m including Italy, too, as I have dined all over Italy—I know not where it is. We absolutely laud the chef at Circo (we did to his face as well tonight). He definitely has mastered the multiple savories in Italian cooking!“

“We absolutely love this place. The food is amazing and so are the people. We have been ordering from here almost every Friday night for over a year and we have not gotten one disappointing pizza. We can’t say that for any of our other beloved spots in the area. And the cannoli cheesecake….DEvine ♥️“

“A small, quarky yet great place with fantastic food that was delicious, an excellent staff to guide you through the experience. I highly recommend this little gem!Vegetarian options: I am vegetarian and recommend this place. Great food, it is homemade, so there will be calories, but it is well worth it!“

“A great experience. The eggplant parmesan was Yum..excellent, delicious.Had..the Godfather sub was very, very good.Everything everything is delicious there at a cup of cappuccino yum..was like eating in italy ?? thank you so much. The customer service was genuine and very helpful,“

“The pizza was really great. My fav since we moved in Pinellas Park area in Oct. The crust was good, nice cheese the toppings were delicious. I wish it was a little greasier but others wouldn't agree so ?. The wings were good. Cooked just right & they were a nice size. We had mild sauce it had a nice flavor. The salad was a nice salad but I wouldn't recommend the house dressing. It had ZERO taste. No vinegar, no seasoning, just the lightest of extra Virgin olive oil. It's as though they don't have a voice in the dressing dept.“

“Went with my wife March 15th for the first time on recommendations from friends.We started with salads and they were great. (Caesar and House)Ordered a carafe of their Cabernet Sauvignon which was very good.The bread and Olive Oil with their seasonings was the best we ever had.I ordered Chicken Parmesan and the wife Eggplant Parm.Both were fantastic.We split Tiramisu and loved it.Jenna took care of us and she was very friendly and helpful with suggestions.We did not order pizza but iot looked good.“

“Amazing bread, salad and huge food portions! Our waitress was amazing (I wish I remembered her name!) It was our 2nd visit there (and won't be our last!) We are from Pennsylvania and will visit there again! Wish we had room for dessert but we didn't! Leftovers for lunch the next day, Chicken picatta and Spaghetti with meat sauce!“

“Some of the best Manicotti I have had. Our whole party loved their meals. We were in the area on vacation and we will be back next year. Only downfall was the server was not in a good mood and didn't really check up on us. But could have he been the end of a long day for her.“

“Amanda is an excellent server. Our dining experience could not have been better. Food and atmosphere was inviting and relaxed while providing a warm welcome. The staff at Tyrone Carrabba's have elevated the casual to one of the areas best while maintaining a value unmatched in this space. Thank you, Carrabba's at Tyrone or as we say... "Un lavoro ben fatto"“

“New and amazing Italian. Not the same pizza place it was, under new ownership and renovated atmosphere. We usually go downtown St. Pete for good Italian food, but so happy to know there’s a great place nearby. From food to service, it was honestly amazing. 100% recommend and we will definitely be back.“

“My wife hosted a meetup group here which was attended by 6 people. This was our first time there, as well as for most of the party. The food was amazing, and ther service was above expectations. we had seen it passing by, as we just recently moved to the area, and are both so glad we hosted the meetup here, and will definitely be returning.“

“What a hidden gem!!! Randomly picked this place and can honestly say it was better than some places in the North End in Boston (where we live). Garlic knots are amazing!!!! I had the Fettuccini Alfredo Primavera- it was delicious!!!!!! I'm a pasta patty and usually find a problem somewhere in the pasta or sauces but not here! Hubby loved the steak tips, daughter enjoyed meatball and spaghetti... Also both find issues but CD ROMA nailed it!!!“

“Very good pizza. The downside is that they had NO hot drinks, even on a very chilly night! Service was okay, but the waitress was rather snarky. The atmosphere was simple, like the small diner it is, but they had Great music playing! I'd go back again.“

“Ippolito Italian Deli catered my son’s rehearsal dinner. We had 102 people attend this event in June. Catered was an Italian dinner buffet and the food was amazing. Everyone loved the food. I would recommend Ippolito Italian Deli for any event.“

“Food is always good here! Also I love when I call 80% of the time there is a ??happy employee on the other end making me laugh when I start screwing things up??. There are some nice and funny delivery people.. It's I making them starts Laughing cause I am dodging my MOTHER-IN-LAW trying to get the food around from back . . ANYONE KNOW ABOUT? SCARY MOTHER IN LAWS?.LOL. ??“

“This is a nice spot for good pizza. The cheese is real, and the pepperoni is greasy :) We got a supreme, a pepperoni, a white plane, 2 cheese calzones, and garlic knots. There was plenty of leftovers even after me and 3 growing boys attacked it all. The pies are huge! Large lives up to its name. The crust is nice, easily foldable but solid enough to eat without folding, so choose your way. The supreme was my favorite, but the others referred the calzones. One did straight cheeses, another did with onions and garlic.Parking: It is in a strip mall but there is usually ample parking. Few right in front and many just across the entry path/road.Kid-friendliness: Great food kids will enjoy. A small arcade in back. I would have enjoyed as a kid :)“

“Raquel was absolutely fabulous she went above and beyond, she met all our needs and she cared about making sure that our experience was a great one. I recently had surgery and was struggling leaving the building, she walked me out of the building making sure not to slip and fall. An absolute pleasure. Thank you again“

“Untouchables has the best pizza I have ever tasted. It is always cooked to perfection. My sister loves there chicken wings. Over the last 4 years we have tried many of there dishes and have taken calzones to parties. Always a hit. I live in NJ but go to Untouchables as often as possible while in Largo. Yummmmmmm.“

“We have now been here a few times and no matter what we order we have never had a bad meal or service! I’m very picky when it comes to my Italian food, as my grandparents came from Sicily. Everything we have tried is so full of flavor and tastes fresh! So glad we happened upon this spot as it is one of our favorites!“

“Very good pizza and pasta dishes. It’s been awhile since we’ve been there and we’ve always loved their wings. We decided to go last week. We quickly changed our minds on the wings when we saw the price of them! I know wings have gone up in price and we still order them at our favorite places but 2.00 per wing !! WTH Bro’s that’s crazy! We might be back but unfortunately it won’t be for wings like it was in the past.“

“Very accommodating! Looked so pretty online and it's even better in person. Definitely a whole experience and great way to celebrate our anniversary! Get the table side cesar salad closest thing to NOLA I have found in FL as far as ambiance and taste! We have had lost reservations in the past at other establishments and other bad experiences so it's nice to just be able to enjoy it. We will be celebrating here for now on“

“The service was excellent and the food was even better.I had the shrimp and scallops with a lobster sherry cream sauce that was perfectly prepared (I could drink the sauce)! My husband order the beef tips special which was perfectly seasoned.“

“One of the best hungry howies. I use to live by the very first one on 4th st. in st. Pete the original. They number 1 and yall number 1.5. I've been to all different hungry howies in the state and city. I'm a gulf veteran was wondering could I get some coupons or discount.“

“We had a great late lunch April 14. Saw the sign board on the main drag, checked Facebook, good reviews so we stopped. I had a lunch special pizza. My wife had a calzone. Both were excellent. We had a chance to talk with the owner which made our time there really nice. When we are in Larfo again we know where will eat!“