15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sebring

“I've been going a few times these past few weeks and I have to say the owner is very pleasant. The food is great I've tried the pizza, wings, grinders and soon I'll try the pasta. I got to say great work to this establishment.“

“Had lunch there today. Great food and great atmosphere. Get there early.“

“I love their oven baked subs and salads, too. The subs are baked like calzones and bread is seasoned just like they season their pizza crust, layers of flavor.

Vegetarian options: Their salads are not skimpy and you can tweak them a bit, take something off or add something more. The pizzas are flavorful and can be vegetarian unless you don't eat cheese. They have onion, pepper choices, mushroom, olives, pineapple, etc.

Parking: This is in a strip mall, there are 3 or 4 rows of parking beyond the curb spaces.“

“I would love to thank the team for the fast and fresh pizza I picked up to serve 30 kids for a back to school celebration... everyone enjoyed the variety of pizza slices we provided for the group... Thank you all for what you do... Kudos to the staff and management team 👏...“

“Absolutely the best pizza....the sausage is homemade and the Pizza is tasty.“

“Let me say I have eaten a lot of pizza in my 61 years and last night we got the best pizza I have ever had and cheese sticks and wow they were here n no time . From the ordering process to delivery it was fantastic. So on the night of March 16th crew in sebring Fl Crew ! Great job !“

“I’ve been ordering pick-up from this Pizza Hut almost weekly (my kids might as well be the official Pizza Hut fan club presidents 😂). Their deals make it easy to feed my family without breaking the bank, and the food is always ready on time. The staff is kind and consistent, which makes every visit a pleasant experience.“

“As far as Little Ceaser's is concerned, it's a very solid one. Sometimes they have the greatest pizza you'll ever eat, other time's, it's just okay. Employees rotate with some frequency, but they typically have very good staff, everyone at the time of my writing this is excellent. Their credit card machine has had issues with receiving gift cards for an extended period of time and their mobile app doesn't accept gift cards, which has caused issues more than once.“

“Update (9/18/2025): I am not going to change my previous review because I want everyone to read it and SEE how Zacks Pizza MADE it RIGHT!!. I was surprised at work today with a delivery of 2 big pizzas and 2 orders of wings. When the delivery girl came to the office, I said I think you have the wrong office. She looked at her phone and asked for Michelle? I’m like, yes that is me, then she said my last name, and I said yes. I knew I did not order any pizza but then I asked the girls at the office to read the box. The pizza was from Zacks pizzeria. I was surprised. I have to say the pizza looked good 🙂. The presentation of the Sicilian pizza was beautiful 🙂. The flavor was good; it was not great but good. We enjoyed it today, and the wings were good as well 🙂. They replaced the whole order that I had previously purchased. I have to say, I gave them an A+ for customer satisfaction. WELL, DONE! 👍👏👏👏👏 I also updated their STAR review. Clapping hands
(9/16/2025): I ordered Sicilian pizza, and it was the worst pizza I tasted in Florida. I wanted to try their pizza because the one in the mall was a little expensive. I was hoping for a good Sicilian pizza. Omg, what I got was a soggy pizza, and it looked like flat pizza. I also ordered mango habanero wings; it was so spicy hot that I couldn't even finish one. I'm very disappointed ☹. If I'm buying a Sicilian pizza, and I can't go to Sarasota or Orlando, I will go to Sebring Mall. mango habanero wings I'll stick with dominos... 😔. AND they are expensive as well. I will never buy again 😒“

“Hands-down, the best pizza place ever in Highlands County. I will not go anywhere else. Every time I go in there it’s the best experience ever owners are the greatest and always attentive and very good. Yummy food every Friday or Saturday the hubby and I go to eat there, and we will not change our favorite pizza spot“

“My friend and I came in yesterday to take advantage of the new coupon on Saturday salads. I chose the Greek with grilled chicken and it was HUGE - I've had 3 meals from that 1 order! All the greens were fresh, crunchy and delicious, the feta cheese and Kalamata olives 🫒 were numerous and yummy 😋. Definitely will be back to try some other offerings that had my mouth watering.“

“Wow pizza has been spot on! I had been craving Pizza Hut but was reluctant to try it, knowing that so many locations are subpar. My family and I have picked up several weeks in a row and really enjoyed it! The staff inside are always on it and super friendly. It's becoming our weekly tradition. Still miss the ole' buffet though 😥. To the owner: keep up the amazing work!“

“Pizza was good, but they messed up the order. We got two Buffalo chicken pizzas instead of the two chicken alfredo pizzas we ordered. I like Buffalo chicken and it was good but for the ones looking forward to those alfredo pizzas, it was pretty disappointing.“

“I don't believe they can and I don't believe that they want to. Address on my bag was wrong and I received cold pizza like it set out all night it was horrible I spent $25 on one large hamburger mushroom and extra cheese with four wings that came to $25 now I'm 67 years old I live on Social Security and I just threw the pizza out because that's how bad it was. I called them up and told them and then they said they have to rely on doordash well I would think if other people complain which I believe they do you wouldn't use doordash you would hire drivers. I know I'm not the first person to say how bad they are is horrible it's a shame it's downright cruel. no I will not be calling them back no I'm done with hungry Howie's I'll make my own pizza thank you, that was the very first time I called... goodbye hungry Howie's“

“Well they took care of the cheese problem they put plenty of cheese on it now I would say their Pizza is perfect and the people are friendly it's a good place to go to. Well I guess they're closed today I saw someone in there but the door is locked you can't go in.“