NY Pizza Baby

$ • Pizza

7124 Aloma Ave, Winter Park
(407) 790-7526


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for NY Pizza Baby

Probably the closest to real NY pizza I've had since the last time I was in NY. They were a little skimpy with the toppings, but the taste was on point & the crust was just right. Great prices too! We will definitely be ordering more pizzas for lunch from here in the near future.Sure, the strip mall it's in isn't the nicest, & the restaurant is small & mostly caters to take out/delivery, but the pizza was really, really good & that is what counts!

Ordered the Chicken Parmigiana pizza and the Alla Peyton Alexis pizza, along with some Garlic Knots and a Cannoli. Absolutely delicious.The chicken in the Chicken Parmigiana was seasoned perfectly and the breading had a nice crispness to it. The Alla Peyton Alexis is a new favorite with all of its ingredients and wonderful flavor.Ordered take out through Uber but believe it or not this place was open on Christmas Day. Will be ordering more.

An employee (without a mask) came to my apartment complex today, and left flyers on my door for their menu. Given COVID-19 this type of solicitation doesn’t seem appropriate, and as a result I definitely won’t be eating at or ordering from this restaurant.

More Reviews(107)


Monday 11AM - 10PM
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.