We had a little miscommunication with my order but the staff was helpful in resolving the issue.And... Let me tell you that struggle was worth it because the moment I got this pie in my ride the scent of stale cigarettes and gasoline were replaced with aroma of fresh baked pizza.Every. Damn. Second. Of the drive home was filled with that temptation... You know that temptation we all have when bringing a pizza home for the family... "What's one road-slice for Dad? No one will notice. After all shouldn't that be my reward for transporting this box of allurement?"However with great patience comes great reward because upon bringing the pizza home and finally prying open the box, we were greated with the golden glistening slice of paradise that some only dream of and, upon that first bite, I knew that the struggle was worth it.
First Last
Calzone was severly undercooked and came without pepperoni and sausage. I called the restaurant to bring it to their attention and they were argumentative and rude. Stay away from this place.
First L.
Just a terrible experience all around. Calzone was doughy and of the 6 garlic knots 3 were doughy and 3 were burnt. Staff is unprofessional and rude. Avoid at all costs!
Chris Londono
I try all the pizza places in the area to see who's good or not, but I'd never go here again. Asked for Buffalo chicken pizza, and I get something that tastes like a frozen cafeteria pizza.. garlic knots undercooked to. Wouldn't recommend this place to even my enemies.
Crissel Torres
Ordered a cheese pizza and I received a burnt one. Ordered a deluxe calzone and was sent a deluxe pizxa instead amd ordered a tiramisu and it atrived in pieces with a bad tasty. You used to be my fave pizza place. What happened? I ordered through uber and received a refund but this is very dissapointing.
Mark Chester
The staff needs to read the menu and learn what's in a veggie stromboli. When the menu States spinach, feta, mushrooms and mozzarella, one would expect that to be what they receive. Instead I received a stromboli with toppings like onions, broccoli, olives, and mozzarella. I checked menus on every delivery service and even copies of menus online. I was extremely disappointed with the Stromboli because it definitely was not what I ordered. The tiramisu is good, the cheesecake is good, the baked ziti is acceptable, the sauce that came with the Stromboli is disgusting. I'm not very impressed and I'm not happy about the mishap with my stromboli. The staff seems to think it's supposed to have what a veggie pizza has, whereas the menu States otherwise.
Alex Hoffman
Ordered a Lasagana pizza, got a burnt cheese pizza that was the worst I've had from here. I am a regular customer at this location though the quality this time is unacceptable.
John-Michael Gilday
This place is awesome!!! I'm a native New Yorker and let me tell you there's no place that comes as close to real New York pizza as NY pizza baby does. Highly recommended.
Kyle Ray
This place has the best NY style pizza in the area that I've tried. That said, I don't recommend going through Slice or any delivery service, call or walk in for pick up.
ACenteno Official
We had your pizza for dinner for the 1st time yesterday and our kids and my self loved it so much that we had to have it today. Omg I haven’t had a taste of good NY pizza since I moved down here. Thank you so much Michelle and the owner for being so kind and the chef for cheffing up some good NY pizza.
Pizza was cold, didn’t taste that good, the knots were great tho?
Linette Laureano
With new management, the pizza is absolutely delicious! JC definitely puts his heart in making the food.
Juicy Seafood Lee
So stupid. Very rude staff. On the last day of 2021, I was pushed out of your store because I didn't wear a mask. If you are scared, please post a mask required at the front door and lock your door. But you didn't post nothing.
Meachy T.
Haven't had pizza this good in awhile!! Best my style pizza in winter park! The crust perfect crisp, great amount of topping not too much not too lil and the nicest staff ever!!! The delivery guy an older Spanish man was great and whoever the girl operating the phone was the sweetest!!!
Nysom Productions
I came here a few weeks ago for the 1st time I was blown away at how good my slice was. Today I come in and all of the ingredients have been changed! What happened?! ?
We had a little miscommunication with my order but the staff was helpful in resolving the issue.And... Let me tell you that struggle was worth it because the moment I got this pie in my ride the scent of stale cigarettes and gasoline were replaced with aroma of fresh baked pizza.Every. Damn. Second. Of the drive home was filled with that temptation... You know that temptation we all have when bringing a pizza home for the family... "What's one road-slice for Dad? No one will notice. After all shouldn't that be my reward for transporting this box of allurement?"However with great patience comes great reward because upon bringing the pizza home and finally prying open the box, we were greated with the golden glistening slice of paradise that some only dream of and, upon that first bite, I knew that the struggle was worth it.
Calzone was severly undercooked and came without pepperoni and sausage. I called the restaurant to bring it to their attention and they were argumentative and rude. Stay away from this place.
Just a terrible experience all around. Calzone was doughy and of the 6 garlic knots 3 were doughy and 3 were burnt. Staff is unprofessional and rude. Avoid at all costs!
I try all the pizza places in the area to see who's good or not, but I'd never go here again. Asked for Buffalo chicken pizza, and I get something that tastes like a frozen cafeteria pizza.. garlic knots undercooked to. Wouldn't recommend this place to even my enemies.
Ordered a cheese pizza and I received a burnt one. Ordered a deluxe calzone and was sent a deluxe pizxa instead amd ordered a tiramisu and it atrived in pieces with a bad tasty. You used to be my fave pizza place. What happened? I ordered through uber and received a refund but this is very dissapointing.
The staff needs to read the menu and learn what's in a veggie stromboli. When the menu States spinach, feta, mushrooms and mozzarella, one would expect that to be what they receive. Instead I received a stromboli with toppings like onions, broccoli, olives, and mozzarella. I checked menus on every delivery service and even copies of menus online. I was extremely disappointed with the Stromboli because it definitely was not what I ordered. The tiramisu is good, the cheesecake is good, the baked ziti is acceptable, the sauce that came with the Stromboli is disgusting. I'm not very impressed and I'm not happy about the mishap with my stromboli. The staff seems to think it's supposed to have what a veggie pizza has, whereas the menu States otherwise.
Ordered a Lasagana pizza, got a burnt cheese pizza that was the worst I've had from here. I am a regular customer at this location though the quality this time is unacceptable.
This place is awesome!!! I'm a native New Yorker and let me tell you there's no place that comes as close to real New York pizza as NY pizza baby does. Highly recommended.
This place has the best NY style pizza in the area that I've tried. That said, I don't recommend going through Slice or any delivery service, call or walk in for pick up.
We had your pizza for dinner for the 1st time yesterday and our kids and my self loved it so much that we had to have it today. Omg I haven’t had a taste of good NY pizza since I moved down here. Thank you so much Michelle and the owner for being so kind and the chef for cheffing up some good NY pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was cold, didn’t taste that good, the knots were great tho?
With new management, the pizza is absolutely delicious! JC definitely puts his heart in making the food.
So stupid. Very rude staff. On the last day of 2021, I was pushed out of your store because I didn't wear a mask. If you are scared, please post a mask required at the front door and lock your door. But you didn't post nothing.
Haven't had pizza this good in awhile!! Best my style pizza in winter park! The crust perfect crisp, great amount of topping not too much not too lil and the nicest staff ever!!! The delivery guy an older Spanish man was great and whoever the girl operating the phone was the sweetest!!!
I came here a few weeks ago for the 1st time I was blown away at how good my slice was. Today I come in and all of the ingredients have been changed! What happened?! ?