“I had the Squid Ink Mafaldine. I liked the soft texture of the pasta combined with the sauce, but it didn't have much flavor, in my opinion.My guest had the Potato Gnocchi, and I could really taste the truffle and cheesy goodness, (although it was a bit salty).I know how much a review can weigh a restaurant down, and being that I don't LOVE Italian food to begin with, I'm giving it a 4/5.Our server Max was great!“
“Wonderful Sunday lunch here with the family. Everything was so fresh and perfectly prepared. The chicken was juicy, homemade pasta delish (only homemade pasta on Park Ave they I was told), pizza also very good. My mom’s minestrone soup was also excellent. It is a little gem and we will be back.“
“A friend and I stopped by here after leaving the pottery painting place next door. The smell was too good to ignore. I kind of have high standards when it comes to pizza, so I'm not impressed easily. This pizza...was soooo good. Honestly one of the best I've ever had and all I had was a basic plain cheese pizza. It had plenty of cheese on it and the crispy edges of it were delicious. This place was clearly popular too because people were constantly coming in to place orders or pick up. It's a good thing this place isn't too close to where I live because I could see myself coming here every week if I could. Will definitely be coming back at some point.“
“I was really craving some New York style pizza and had never tried this place. I went there and ate inside. It's a small place, clean, and has a great atmosphere. The waitress was friendly and attentive. When we paid, I think it was the owner, he explained that everything was made fresh at the restaurant. He makes his own sauce from scratch and it was the best pizza sauce I have ever had. I ordered a medium pizza with garlic knots and it was the perfect size for two people with leftovers. I highly recommend this place. Next time I go, I am going to try their pasta. He makes his Alfredo sauce from scratch and also makes a delicious looking lasagna.“
“Went there for my lunch/dinner all the guys in there are super friendly and nice dudes! They were advertising that they would be doing specialty pizza, and the one I had today was a taco pizza really flavorful and all around a great slice of pizza!“
“Antonella's is a solid 10/10 when it comes to the quality, freshness and flavor of their food. You can conclude that the standards are high and accounted for here, which overall makes for a fantastic experience.Service is always quick, professional and courteous as well. Their recipe is truly phenomenal - and true pizza lovers will not be disappointed.“
“Nice little place for wine and pizza!Returned for a business lunch and was not pleased with the food or the service. The chicken piccatta - tastes like the just poured the caper juice out of the jar (no one was willing to eat.) The spaghetti sauce with the chicken Parmesan looked liked chef boyardi - only ate the chicken. Would still return for the pizza.“
“This place saved my lunch! Was gonna go to Ethos Vegan Kitchen and drove all the way from Cocoa Beach to go BUT the Health Department closed them down! SO it just happens that this lovely little Italian Pizzeria was right in the same parking lot. We all had something great. They had a Cauliflower pizza crust and Vegan cheese with all kinds of veggies!!! So Yummy I’d drive back just to have it again. Staff was great. Inside and outside dining. A little bit small area but very nice and clean.Vegetarian options: Vegan cheese and lots of veggies for pizza“
“Been our favorite place to get pizza since I was a kid. Staff is friendly and the food is good.Kid-friendliness: Once the kids are seated they are more than happy to give them a piece of fresh dough to play with. Always a unique experience.“
“I love all the fresh & tantalizing options for the build-your-own 11-inch pizza. You can custom order your pizza to be as healthy (or unhealthy) as you want. Super delicious! And the prices are very reasonable: $10.45 (as of March 2024) for the pizza or the pick-two option (half a pizza with either a side salad, meatballs or cheesy bread).“
“3/8/2024Love love love this place. All the Below Mushrooms are good but this is my favorite location. It is so mellow. The pizza is great, I love the house special.2/18/2022I love pizza in general and like many places and varieties but nothing comes close to Mellow Mushroom. As i started in my original post, Winter Park is my favorite location on top of that. It has the most Mellow feel of all the locations I've been to.Original PostMy favorite Mellow location. My favorite pizza and totally laid back. LOVE IT!“
“The dressing for the house salad was the best I’ve ever had! Many salads said they came with Kalamata olives, but we were served black olives. Further, this is NOT a kid friendly atmosphere. It’s more of a first date or girls night then for families. Super dark inside but that creates the ambiance. Bread is available, but only upon request. No butter for the kids, just olive oil and garlic. I’d definitely go back, but not as a family.“
“This place doesn't get enough credit. Their pizza is fricken delicious!, one of the best we've had. Eat it there when it's fresh out of the oven and take the rest home. The people are super nice and always on top of it. It's right next to Donut King, so pay this place a visit, keep them in business and enjoy the heck out of the food!“
“a little small, but yet comfortable. At times crowded & a little noisy, but like being back in New York. Food & service was friendly & quick.Pizza was exactly the way I wanted.Parking: It's the typical shopping & bar & restaurant outdoor center. Depending on time of day & type of movie being shown, the parking could lead to frustration.“
“My wife and I had dinner here last night. The food and atmosphere were good! We both really enjoyed our food and sitting outside on the patio. The downside was the service. Our waiter never even bothered to introduce himself, talk about specials, ask about allergies, nothing at all. It was mainly “are you ready to order”, “do you know what you want to drink” and that was it. We had to ask another server for bread after asking our waiter twice and never receiving any. Although the food and atmosphere were fine, the poor service overshadowed the evening. We probably won’t visit again for a while.“
“I am not from Florida. I cane to Winter Park because my son is in the Advent Health Winter Park Hospital. I was here for 2 months. My son recommended this place for its food. Boy, was he ever right. I have enjoyed everything I've order so far. Unfortunately, my son is still in the hospital with pancreatitis, but this visit I am stopping there as I especially miss that Italian sausage sandwich. Thanks Fratellos.“
“This is my favorite pizza place in this galaxy. I've been eating here since I was in college, and I never want it to change. The staff is friendly and professional, great atmosphere and consistently phenomenal pizza. Try the Bianca with spinach, or the buffalo chicken. My favs.“
“FINALLY!!!! A GOOD CHICAGO PIZZA PLACE!!! ITS PERFECT. I ORDERED THE MEAT MANIA IN 18 INCH AND IT WAS AMAZING. THE WINGS ARE BEYOND HUGE AND GARLIC PARM IS AMAZING ON THEM. I DIDNT GET THE YOUNG LADY'S NAME UPFRONT BUT COMPARED TO TODAYS WORKERS SHE WAS REFRESHING. THANK “
“Love this place, workers are always super nice and the pizza is delicious. From the crust to the sauce to the toppings, everything is great. It’s also the first pizza I like refrigerated just almost as much as hot. New favorite pizza place“
“We came in on. Wednesday evening. There was a good size crowd but we’re were able to get a table. We had a Margherita, and a Fig and Prosciutto pizza, a roasted Beet and Goat cheese salad and Olives. The salad was excellent, beets properly prepared and the salad well dressed. The pizza was authentic, wood fired oven Neapolitan. The wine selections are great but a good bit overpriced in my opinion. The service was excellent. Great place. Will return.“