36 Best Pizza Restaurants near Caseyville

“This is our favorite Domino's in the area. The pizza is always consistently very good! After staying away from Domino's for many years, my husband and I decided to give it a try again. It is the best deal around! Oh, and no one else puts enough sauce on their pizza, but this location gets it right every time!“

“Being from Chicago and being told this was good pizza, I was told right. Excellent thin crust. Chicagoans don't eat "Chicago style pizza", tourists do. We eat round, thin crust pizza cut into squares, and this was better than many pizzas in Chicago. Will definitely be back.“

“The manager helped us in mid dinner rush bc our order got lost. She jumped onto the pizzaline made our order asap and had us handled within 15 minutes. Food was amazing. Staff were very helpful and slammed! Their pizza is the best in the location!“

“We somehow were accidentally bumped off of the waiting list, so I was glad that I checked in with the hostess to see why it was taking so long to be seated. We then felt a bit rushed to finish since they were starting to clean up before we were done. Get there a little earlier -and stay on the wait list- and there shouldn't be a problem. Our waiter was friendly, there was an excellent selection of tap beers and unique pizza toppings that were all delicious. Parking was crowded. We'd definitely eat there again.“

“Hands down my favorite pizza!!! I’ve been coming here since I was a kid and now live across the river and still make the trip to come here. I’ve failed to find anywhere closer that offers pizza this great. Owner and employees are also very kind.“

“This is my first time at this place. It's a really cool looking place and the pizza is very good! They sell either the whole pie or by the slice. A slice is like a quarter of the pizza though, so you are getting plenty If you're just popping in for yourself.“

“I had my engagement party here. The food and drinks my fiancé and I ordered were excellent. This was party of about 30 guests so service was slightly slow, but it was expected with it being a large party. Overall everything was great! Service was really kind!“

“We were so happy when Peel opened a O Fallon Illinois location! We enjoy the variety of beer and cocktails that are offered. The wings were the right amount of heat! Love the new hot honey pepperoni pizza! We always order the Prosciutto Involtini appetizer, it is a must, not to mention the three dipping sauces which are included!“

“We used the private upstairs room to celebrate our daughter's 30th birthday party last night. What a great experience! The food was excellent and available exactly when we requested. Geneva helped us before and during the event - she was a wonderful hostess! Everyone had enough space to mingle, eat, and celebrate. We thank Geneva and the rest of the staff for a truly lovely evening!“

“I had a very good expirence there ....my family got done with a funeral and we decided to go put to eat afterwards....I got spaghetti and the rest of my family member had pizzas....I would definitely go back to joesany time I'm in the area....thank you very much...“

“I already thought the pizza was good, and the folks here have always been super cool when I came for pickup, but these wings though... Thank y'all for being one of the few establishments in the country (yep, I said it) that actually seasons the wings all the way through. As for me and my house, this is quickly becoming our go-to pizza spot.“

“I am traveling out of town for work and I was wanting pizza and I saw this place on Google Maps, I have never had it or heard of it. I can say based on my one visit this is easily the best pizza buffet I have ever had. There was a very large variety of pizza and they were all good that I tried. They have really good sweet tea as well which is nice. The quality on a pizza buffet is usually questionable but I was genuinely impressed by this, highly recommended“

“We originally went to the steakhouse across the street. We were ignored and came here instead. We were so glad we did!!The service was fantastic fast, and the waiters knew their stuff. The food was absolutely delicious highly highly recommended to eat here if you are in the area! My husband and I got the rigatoni for 2. There was some to bring home and we totally ate that the next day“

“Local gem! We had great pizza there. They have different pizza sauces that you can select in the make your own menu. We went on a Monday and they had half price pints. They have several TVs but it wasn’t overly loud. They seem to support the local town.“

“We had a good time here! So we're staying nearby at Drury Inn and wanted to find a place to grab some light bites and a few beers. This place really fit the mark! The bartender was so nice and attentive and they had mango cart for only $6! That's really a steal! Anyway we had the shrimp scampi. I do wish they had toasted the bread slightly, but otherwise it made a super tasty accompaniment to the poached shrimp in butter garlic sauce. Super yummy. I would LOVE to come back and try their shrimp scampi pizza. The bartender gave us a pro tip of getting the shrimp scampi appetizer blackened, so if I'm here again, will DEFINITELY be getting it that way. Anyway would totally come back here!“

“I’ve passed this place on so many occasions, this time a group of us went after church. No wait and food cameExceptionally quick, I was glad because I was hungry… Nice server and even brought half the order boxes because we were semi rushing… Customer service goes a long way! Good prices will be back soon!“

“Food/Taste/ - ordered a Large Deluxe Pizza which has sausage, mushroom, onions, green pepper, and bacon. We wanted to try a "Original St. Louis Style Pizza" since they advertise their thin, crispy, and crunchy crust. I quite enjoyed the pizza overall as the toppings compliment the thin crust compliments quite well. The SO who only loves fluffy crust wasn't the biggest fan but rated the pizza well overall still. - super friendly and quick serviceAmbiance: n/a - ordered food to goValue for price: 5/5 - great food, reasonable pricing, friendly service!“

“Stepping into Imo's Pizza in Collinsville, Illinois, I knew I was in for a treat, but little did I know how my taste buds would be dancing with joy. The pizza here isn't just good, it's a culinary masterpiece that makes you wonder if you've ever really tasted pizza before. Each slice is a perfect blend of cheese, sauce, and that indescribably delicious crust.And let's not forget the bowling alley – it's like stepping into a parallel universe where pizza and bowling combine to create the pinnacle of entertainment. I mean, who needs anything else when you can strike down pins and then reward yourself with the best pizza in town? It's almost unfair how Imo's has mastered the art of both pizza making and entertainment.So, if you're looking for an 'okay' pizza and a 'just fine' bowling experience, this place is definitely not for you. Imo's Pizza in Collinsville is where the magic happens, and you're seriously missing out if you haven't been here yet.“

“The staff at Silver Creek is very friendly. I have been a few times in the last year and I always look forward to going back.Get the roast beef sandwich, it never disappoints. They have great live music every weekend. I didn’t get a picture of my plate it was late and too dark for food photos. Enjoy the pictures of the band!“

“Our first time to dine inside Fazoli's was very pleasant. One orders at the counter and the servers bring the food to the table. Soda station for free refills. In the evening, there were more drive thru clients so inside restaurant was quiet and we could enjoy a long visit. Food was tasty. Took home half of the meal.“

“I went with my boyfriend the first time.. I was having so much fun chatting with guests and enjoying their entertainment my BF left me there alone. I was worried about a ride home but two handsome men and a bear offered to take me to their homes. They were so sweet and hunky I rented us a motel room so all three could have me all night. I always meet a new friend to entertain me after hours almost every time I go. I absolutely LOVE Club Escapade, it's good service.. cute boys, and good people period.... this gay bar is a real class act!“

“Very good, recommended for our Latin community, the only thing you know is that you have to know how to order your order in English and if it is difficult for you, they will help you with everything with patience.Vegetarian options: SaladsParking: Very spacious and safeKid-friendliness: Child-friendly environment“

“I like being able to bake it myself, ensuring that it is hot and fresh. They always have it ready when I get there. Or they make it quickly and do a great job. The staff is nice and will make the order as you specify. No problems. There's always easy parking, in and out quick.Parking: Lot's of parking, easy, quick parking close to establishment.“

“This is a really good Jets. It seems like the owner really cares about how the pizza is supposed to eat. It’s a perfect balance of sauce cheese and toppings and it’s very consistently that way. Enough good things cannot be said about Jets.This puts Domino’s and Pizza Hut to shame. Instead of buying from Domino’s or Pizza Hut give your money to jet’s. This is a real mom and pop shop operation, but only on a national level. The dough is made fresh every day the cheese is ground fresh every day the sauce is made fresh and house with Mediterranean tomatoes it’s whole milk mozzarella and it’s very special cheese from very special cows. The toppings are of the utmost highest quality. And it is a real value. It is so rich and filling. Not necessarily from the thickness of the crust but from the richness of the flour product used. The tomatoes are much richer. This is really an amazing pizza. After being in the pizza business for 30 years at a real mom and pop shop this is really impressive.They have a special for two slices and a drink for only six dollars is a real value. But overall a pizza for just nine dollars for a whole one is an overall great value considering how much work goes into making them. You are getting a real homemade pizza here.“

“We're been passing through the area after the eclipse and decided to try the local fare instead of Dominos. I'd never had St. Louis-style pizza before but I'm from NYC so I was skeptical, but it was very, very good. I usually shy away from thin crust pizza because it can be so dry, but this stuff is delicious and flavorful and not dry at all (but the crust is still so crispy - how do they do it?!). My husband got their "Great Tastes of St. Louis" special that had a little of everything - those raviolis are amazing! I love, love, love the sauce, as well.Knocked one star off of "service" because the dining room was closed at 8 and we had to use the drive-thru, but we still received prompt service and fresh food that tasted wonderful.“

“We order from here way more than we should and food is consistently delicious! Cheesy bread is a regular in our house, as well as the buffalo wings. Delivery times insane which is understandable if not enough help, so we tend to DoorDash when we are feaning for Marcos pizza. It literally never disappoints. I did pick up once and the wait was long, but the ladies behind the counter were awesome! The guys working prep and boxing were literally amazing because it was obvious they were slammed but they put extreme care into each order prepared so the wait didn’t bother me. Keep it Marcos at Central Plaza!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“A young woman named "Brook" assisted me with an order over the phone last evening, April 6th. She was the most delightful, empathetic, and helpful representative I've ever experienced from any fast food establishment. We have always enjoyed pizza hut cuisine. Last nite's verbal exchange on the phone, exceptional service and assistance, and delivery was an absolute pleasure.“

“Papa Johns has always been my favorite pizza delivery place over Pizza Hut, dominos and little Caesar's. It's a nice comfort food when you don't feel like going out. They have different shaped pizzas for special events like the Super Bowl (football shaped) and Valentines Day (heart shaped). Their stuffed crust is always a good option, and I also love their cheese sticks. I have never had any issues with service or quality at this location and have been going here for about 3 years now.“

“I want to show my appreciation and gratitude towards Jen (the manager) and the entire staff at O'Fallon, IL. Pizza Hut. Sometimes establishments forget that good service is just as important as the product. Thank you for your world class service. Your hard work is noticed, valued & appreciated.“

“We've been to this Chuck E Cheese multiple times, but they've recently remodeled a bit and I really like the changes. They now have the littlest kid games sectioned off differently and have installed a little trampoline park type area with it. Today when we were there, all the games we played were functioning properly (an issue at arcades these days), the staff was friendly, and they had a salad bar, that although we weren't eating there this time, actually looked like a really good food option for adults, since we all know only kids enjoy the pizza here.“

“Just went there today for lunch. Very friendly staff. Fast service. We ordered mozzarella sticks, and 2 beefs sweet with also hot peppers. Everything came out hot and delicious! Also thanks for the military discount. We appreciate your business acknowledging our service.“

“Had the sweet heat pizza last night, was probably the best pizza I've had from there in a long while. Everything tasted just right. Props to whoever made it. Only thing I wish that the dining room was open longer than 10pm, but I understand. I worked in food/retail for years and understand. And to the dude complaining about the pizza being runny, do you know what you're ordering? Let the pizza sit for a few and it'll workout just fine for you. You'd complain if you didn't get enough sauce either.“

“The food is good. The service is usually wonderful. It's not super pricey, and you get your money's worth of food. I got a triple cheese burger, and it was very yummy. Our group ordered spinach dip and grilled zucchini as appetizers they were very good. So were all the entrées. I can't remember what everyone got, but they were all happy with their dinners.“

“Haven't tried the food but the service was nice for drinks. New owner, definitely making some improvements to the bar it used to be and said "more to come". Stopped here on the bike over the years. Nice patio now! Def will be back to see the changes :)“

“10-15 min waitOne place to sit inside ( it’s meant for pickup and carry out)Friendly staffFairly clean insideWill go again for fast and good quality pizzaCrust was good!Ingredients were good!Reasonable price for size ?$0.99 for red crushed pepper. Comes in cute little shaker“