33 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wonder Lake

“Amazing food ! High quality ! Tasteful! Iwas born & raised in the city and this HIT home! No other resturant has beat this one! Friendly staff too. Its a win win ! & they are the only resturant that delivers to east wonderlake because I have not found 1 that does unless ur paying extra for like door dash! My kids were amazed. Happy husband & happy kids makes a happy MOM ❤️ Thank you everyone at East End Pizza youll be seeing a lot of me❤️“

“Excellent people, food, and service. Pizza is second to none.“

“SO GRATEFUL we were too hungry and exhausted to cook for ourselves tonight. Both my husband and I have typically been largely disappointed every time we go out to eat in southern Wisconsin, but this was absolutely top notch eating. We ordered 2 appetizers and their Milwakee pizza and everything was amazing. They have the best pizza hands down anywhere near Walworth county. We can’t wait to go back and try more food on the menu! Matt, the chef, really cares about what he is feeding people and you can tell by the quality meals he plates. Thanks so much for a great night out eating delicious food!“

“The BEST frozen pizza out there based on my 68-years' experience. The rim of the crust is a warm, crumbly, "cookie" that is transformative! Impossible not to devour the entire pie. And hats off to management: the pizza was cleverly and attentively wrapped and boxed with smart instructions. That was appreciated.“

“Jude's has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants in downtown Crystal Lake. I love the variety of internationally inspired options and the size of the plates is perfect. I brought a very large group of ladies there for Black Friday, everyone has particular tastes and was able to find something they liked. They have a very trendy area in the back with a huge couch/bench for larger parties which was so comfortable. To top it off, the staff are always kind and accommodating during our visits!“

“I didn't know so I want you to know! We were searching for a place to hold our funeral luncheon. We needing something McHenry local, good food, and could accomodate us on short notice. BuddyZ answered the call. They had a banquet room in the back with access to the patio. We had the pizza, salad, chicken fingers, mostaccioli bar. The food was brought out as soon as we arrived. There were tables of varied heights which accomodated our entire family. Carrie, Caitlyn & Kirsty were so friendly, professional and attentive.Thank you all for being there for our family when we needed you.“

“The food was so delicious that we when back the next day. On Friday night we went in for the fish fry and Saturday we went out for the prime rib special. Both days were delicious. The salad bar was amazing both days. I will definitely be back.“

“Like speed Gonzales 100 % recommended“

“MUST GO! Found this place from a quick Yelp search while in the area. The reviews are so accurate. Amazing pizza at an even more amazing price. One thin crust, one deep dish, and a soda was $7!!! Don't let the fact it's attached to a gas station deter you. Some of the best pizza I've ever had. The service was super fast and friendly. Adequate seating. Will definitely make the trip back and try more!!“

“Dillon is phenomenal! Great customer service! Going out of his way to make sure what you ordered is good to go. I got there for a pick up and he informed me it would be a few minutes longer because he felt the first one might be too overcooked. Every experience has been a pleasant one and they really care about the customer. Thank you! Keep up the good work. Btw, I recommend their breakfast pizza. ?“

“Their truck came to Scorched Earth. Was kinda surprise pulling up. And a great surprise. We had both the sausage and pepperoni pizzas. And what goes better with a great micro craft beer than a wood-fired pizza? Pretty much nothing else. We'll be heading to their brick and mortar store soon.“

“Celebrated my fiancé 30th birthday there and it was the best. Kenny made sure we had everything set days before the party, showed up to the party to help out and make sure everything was great. He would keep up with checking in every so often which was nice to have the owner involved and actually care how it was all going. The bartenders were super awesome and made sure to check on everyone who was in the golf simulator on drinks and food. Overall I’m so thrilled we did his party there. Would 100% recommend lulu’s to anyone who is looking for a nice, clean, laidback vibe and overall fun. Thank you guys for being so awesome!“

“The inside is beautiful. The food has been excellent so far, the pork belly appetizer was one of our favorites. All the pizzas we have tried were delicious. The drinks are delicious and potent. The atmosphere is wonderful, with some classic beats and songs playing on vinyl.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free, vegan, and more options“

“This restaurant participates in the 'Too Good to Go' program where good food that has not been sold is offered at a fraction of the retail cost. We had never been there, but when we were able to get a surprise bag of pizza for $4, we decided to give it a try. We got to try 3 different kinds of pizza, and it was all great! This is a wonderful way to keep food from the landfill. We will definitely be visiting this restaurant again.“

“The timeliness of a to-go order on a beautiful, busy Saturday afternoon was great. I'd highly recommend the Salmon with the bourbon sauce. It would have been nice if the sauce wasn't so much as a soup in the container, though it did go well with the mashed potatoes and the broccoli. I also ordered the Reuben rolls as an appetizer. I feel these would have been better enjoyed at the restaurant itself. They were a bit soggy by the time I made it home. Overall very satisfied with this establishment and the food. I did not get acknowledged or greeted (other than by the hostess) for a few minutes with several people behind the bar (they were just chatting with each other, that could be improved)“

“I’ve always been a fan of Antioch pizza in Antioch Illinois. Pizza by the slice and far more than one variety. Very good pizza and this operation is replicated in a perfect way in McHenry love this place love the pizza took the time to eat outside in their little patio because they don’t have indoor dining but they don’t need it. They have a great product and they’re very friendly. Nice people highly recommended by Me.“

“Definitely worth trying for pizza & pasta lovers!! We've never had anything that we didn't love from Nancy's!! They have amazing quality regular, thin, & deep-dish pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches. The menu is always current with plenty of different options! The prices may seem a bit more than your usual pizza place, but once you try it you'll understand why. Their ingredients are always very fresh and nothing ever tastes old or greasy, which makes a huge difference in quality. They have a great app with coupons or you can call and ask for a coupon for what you're ordering, that usually tones the price down for us!! Every employee is genuinely nice and ready to help you order or answer any questions! If you pick up your order, you can clearly see the employees making pizzas and how clean the environment is, which is a huge plus! We specifically love the Island Lake location!!Vegetarian options: You can customize anything from Nancy's to be vegan or vegetarian!! They will help you over the phone with your questions.“

“Gaming, food, service and atmosphere is second to none. Food is hot, drinks are cold, and so relaxing to be there. Ownership treats us like family. Come and see what I’m talking about it.Parking: Front and side parking. Lots of lighting.Wheelchair accessibility: West front side of building.“

“They accidentally forgot my jumbo slice of pizza on a pickup order. They called before we even noticed and then even delivered it to us. It's not often you see great customer service like that.Edit to add: hot dogs were a big hit in our group 10/10“

“Thank you for accommodating our large party on Friday night! Jimmy was very patient and easy to work with. The space and food was perfect! Everyone had a great time.“

“We had our Christmas party at Mary’s Hideway. We were a party of 11. Mary and Carla were very attentive making sure we were taken care of. Service and food was great! Variety of food and drinks and very reasonably priced. Will definitely be back!“

“I have driven by this place more than a few times and never really gave it a second notice. Mainly because the sign and building art are confusing during the day. Maybe at night it lights up like a Christmas tree and easier to understand.What is a Zeria? I pondered on that each time I drove by. Is it some type of specialty type of chicken wing from the hidden fields of Zeria? Even after eating there and Googling the word, it remains a chicken wing folk lore mystery..On to the food! This was just a quick pop in for a snack, and we ordered the Beer Nuggets and a basket of 10 wings with the hottest and not so hottest sauces. Both were good quality and tasty as well.Speaking from experience, since I often make my own wings for the family, including having bowls of different sauces as I take orders from the kids and flip the wings to coat them for ech of their orders, these wings had the crispiness I desire and the sauces to add the zing to my taste buds.The Beer Nuggets were unexpected in how puffy and tasty they were. I make my own breads, of which I have been experimenting with doughs for many years. It is hard to pinpoint what the dough was. It was like the puffiness of a Hawaiin Roll and the softness of a pizza dough. The flavor was on point, not as much as beer flavor, but buttery with little colorful herbs on the exterior. I think the name would indicate they go well with a beer.To sum it all up, I would go back and expound upon the menu options to see how the other food compares to what we already tried. Before I forget, the service was on-point, polite, and friendly.“

“The service was slow but not due to the workers. More due to management not properly staffing the establishment. The bartender/waitress deserved some large tips for handling the plus 30 people in there today. I just went in to pick up three pizzas and had to patiently wait to be served. But she had an almost full bar and another 15 people at tables. Food was good but it seems management is lacking.“

“Domino's is very basic, inexpensively pizza. I think we're all aware of that. I would say that the quality has gone up quite a bit, compared to, say, a decade ago. I gave up on this place years ago but decided to give it another try recently. I was pleasantly surprised. Pizzas were good and still reasonably priced. Order was ready on time, delivered right to my car. Will return.Wheelchair accessibility: One nice thing about Domino's is that they offer delivery to the car window as a standard service. So, accessibility is essentially a default. Waaay easier and less stress on the body compared to pretty any other place. The process worked smoothly and it's one of the things that makes me want to visit again in the future.“

“Great atmosphere with staff who go above and beyond! Our food was fantastic and the service was even better!“

“Went to visit my mother who stays and Woodstock IL and was going to another place and I saw Papa Murphy's Pizza and it was worth the stop. I have issues with my stomach and they offer gluten free crust and dairy free cheese if you need it. They also offer regular pizza and have kid friendly options too. They are not to expensive either which is a plus and would be great for any occasion. FYI the pizzas are take and bake but the fun part is you get to watch them make them. I will visit again to try some other things.Dietary restrictions: Offer gluten free crust which is a big plus for me as it is so hard to find places to eat that offers gluten free options. Also dairy free cheeseKid-friendliness: Can purchase kits to make your own pizzas and kids love hands on stuff.“

“Great time watching sand volleyball, pizza, IPA’s. Terrific venue, very reasonably priced.“

“I will give this store a 5 star!!! A few Reasons why, one is for their service. The employees all have great attitude and great service. you can tell they all care about you as a customer and the food they give you. There are two that stand out I forgot the gentleman’s name and the ladies name but I will update my review with their names. Another reason is the how clean and nice it looks when you walk in. Even the refrigerator with the bottles are all stacked with their labels facing out. You can tell they try and care. Just a great all around Pizza Hut. Great deals if you sign up on the app. Which I would recommend because you get points and free food! Who doesn’t like free food??Wheelchair accessibility: Their is a handicap parking spot right up front with the little entry to the sidewalk up to the sidewalk“

“Had ordered a pizza for myself and a few coworkers. Asked to have it cut pie style but the employee cut it square style.It was a timed work lunch so I didn't have time to wait and have it remade as they suggested. In return they gave me 50% off the pizza and a 2 liter of Pepsi for the inconvenience.As I explained it was not the end of the world. The staff was very apologetic and I left a very satisfied customer.Oh and as a bonus....the pizza was devoured by all!“

“Tonight we held a work meeting and ordered 2 family trays, everyone was working so hard when I picked up my order, even a little early, and they were all so friendly, helpful and this food was delicious! Thank you for doing such a great job for us!!“

“Great pizza. They make a delicious gluten free crust too. We always ordered super thin crust as I am Diabetic and have to watch the carbs. This way you can enjoy more of the toppings.They have the perfect ratio of crust-cheese-sauce-toppings.Sadly, we moved to another state and there is no Rosati's anywhere close.“

“Great sports bar with lots of Chicago sports memorabilia, great service from a lot of friendly staff, but the food only hits halfway home. The pizza comes in two kinds of cooked; either halfway done or really overcooked and still undercooked under its shell. But the wings? They're an amazing different story. Better than Buffalo Wild Wings to me.“

“We ordered a catering package from Papa Saverios in Crystal Lake for Mother's day and the food was outstanding. Our package included the Italian beef, mostaccioli, fried chicken and swapped out the garden salad tray for their chopped salad (for an extra cost) but was so happy they were able to accommodate us. Everyone commented on how good the food was especially and surprisingly the fried chicken. It came crispy, moist and delicious. We will continue to do our catering with them! Thanks Papa Saverios for an outstanding job!“