11 Best Italian Restaurants near Cicero

“The salad was very fresh and tasty and the bread sticks were great. Not a fan of the lasagne sauce but the spaghetti florentine was delicious as well as the fettuccini Alfredo. Meatballs were small and dense and had the same sauce as the lasagna. Overall some good and some not so good.“

“We were so excited to make our first visit to this gem. It was highly recommended by friends and has so many stellar reviews Being first time callers, our choice was to eat in the bar. Sean the bartender was super busy,as this restaurant was packed, took great care of us. The patrons in the bar provided some killer recommended choices and we took advantage of them. First choice was the fried ravioli. Excellent n could only eat 2 of the 4. We split the beet salad. Perfect choice. Next was the chicken piccata for my baby's birthday n she loved it! I had the lasagna w the vodka sauce( you can choose your own). Spot on!!! Negroni n Chianti were delicious n service was great! Will be back for sure!!!“

“This place is really super special from the entrance to the end, the guy who served us the food and the place ♥️ they have a super special sauce that has the squid that he brought us when our grandmother made us a sauce similar to that, many thanks to the owners“

“Outstanding food, service and atmosphere tucked in downtown Noblesville. We started with drinks and the insalata caprese. Then our server brought bread and olive oil for dipping. Entrees were hot and delicious, with generous portions. Highly recommended!“

“My husband and I ate here tonight and were less than impressed. The food was okay, but the bad service left a foul taste in our mouths. The service provided by our waitress (Annette C.) left us feeling like we were an afterthought (she checked on multiple tables around us frequently and very rarely on us). We definitely will not be visiting this establishment again anytime soon.“

“A phenomenal hit, without miss every time. The pizzas, (1) 14", (2) 8", were cooked in a manner which honored and accentuated the reputation of Monical's Pizza. Certainly, one could find something to complain about regarding any eatery. However, if you possess over half a brain, you can recognize that restaurants are there to provide great food, not conduct white-glove inspections or hire 5 star staff. Nevertheless, I bring all of my out of state friends to Monical's as a means of showcasing that there's more than corn in Indiana. They always leave with a strengthened respect for the state's cuisine.“

“Family fun. We always add on take home meals which are all excellent and amazingly priced.Kid-friendliness: Kids meals are filling and delicious. The usual coloring and activity pages. It's loud enough that no one will notice your loud kid but not so loud as to be too much for them to settle down“

“Puccinis is our favorite go-to restaurant. So many wonderful memories have been made over delicious food at Puccini’s. I love that my kids get to experience a local spot with their friends (and my friends) and get that awesome hometown feel. There are two employees who *regularly* go above and beyond for us. They treat us so well and are always on top of everything we need before we can ask. Puccini’s days are the highlight of our week! My personal favorites are the sweet little razor back and the salads, the homemade ranch is great!“

“Puccinis is our favorite go-to restaurant. So many wonderful memories have been made over delicious food at Puccini’s. I love that my kids get to experience a local spot with their friends (and my friends) and get that awesome hometown feel. There are two employees who *regularly* go above and beyond for us. They treat us so well and are always on top of everything we need before we can ask. Puccini’s days are the highlight of our week! My personal favorites are the sweet little razor back and the salads, the homemade ranch is great!“

“My family went to this Pizza King for lunch this past Saturday. We ordered a 14" Meat Treat, bread sticks and a stromboli. This was one of the best PK pizzas I've ever had with edge to edge toppings, and I've had many over the past 60 years. The breadsticks and the accompanying dips were excellent, but the sticks could be a little bigger. My wife said her stromboli was very good. We would definitely come here again when in the area.“

“I typically order from the store once a week now for the past several months. Service is adequate and the pizza is very good, albeit pricey. I have only ever had a couple of instances where I’ve needed to call to find out what happened to my pizza. Usually received it within about 20 minutes after. One of the better pizza joints in town.“