8 Best Bakeries near Fortville

Generations Pie Company Bakery •
230 S Main St, Fortville

“I bought a small bourbon chocolate pecan pie from the downtown farmer's market and it was friggin' delicious. I will definitely be trekking to wherever they'll be selling pies in the future and can't wait to try more flavors!“

3.7 Good13 Reviews
Yummerful Ice Cream Shop • $
125 W State St, Pendleton - 7.23 miles

“Oh my! Our new fave ice cream spot! Our old favorite went out of business in Anderson so now we're thrilled to drive another 10 minutes to cute downtown Pendleton for their awesome ice cream. They have some wonderful and unique flavors (Exhausted Parent, really? LOL)My only wish is that they can upgrade their two little outside cafe tables, kind of rickety, but there is a sturdy bench close by. There is plenty of inside seating if you go in inclement weather.“

4.9 Superb27 Reviews
Tim's Bakery Bakery • $
6087 W Broadway, McCordsville - 4.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Maple Twists and Assorted Donuts
Blueberry and Cherry Fritter
Jelly Bavarian Butterflies
Red Raspberry Jam Filled
Filled Powder Donuts
Blueberry Fritter
Glazed Donuts
Apple Fritter
Cinnamon Roll
Donut Holes

“Great donuts. Worth the stop. I happened in at 10:40 am and they were just getting ready to close up at 11 am. The selection had been cleared out, but they still had yeast donuts and other pastries to fill a dozen for my order. The staff were friendly and very helpful. Next time I stop I will be getting a box of donut holes as well. The did have some seating, but it was limited. If you are planning to stop and want a selection you better be a morning person and be in line before they open at 5 am.“

4.6 Superb93 Reviews
Panadería y Repostería Emanuel Bakery • $$
3827 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis - 10.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pan Dulce
Doughnut

“I feel i have been doing this place an injustice; I've been going for months and have not shared one of the Far East sides best kept secret! This bakery is scrumptious and very reasonably priced! My all time favorite items are the tres leches, at least it's what it reminds me of and this breaks stuffed with cream cheese and jalepeno . I like to take they loaf home and warm it in the oven for a little bit so it's nice and warm and gooey like I said I've been going for awhile, lol.My daughters enjoy the cookies, churros, and donuts greatly. Luckily for them it's next to our dance studio so we definitely have frequent flier miles here.The owners are great and will answer any question you have about anything. It's quiet inside as the place is not very big, but if you sit in the parking lot you will see a constant rotation of patrons coming in and grabbing all types of goodies.If you're ever in the neighborhood, stop in I promise you won't be disappointed.“

5 Superb14 Reviews
Geist Coffee Company Coffee Shops • $
10110 Brooks School Rd, Fishers - 5.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich Bacon Egg & Cheese
Other Pastries Made Daily
Avocado Egg and Cheese
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Sausage Egg and Cheese
California Wrap Salad
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Southwest Chicken
Pour-Over Coffee
Select Muffins

“amazing place. you will not have a bad meal here. Soooo Good! the staff is always hospitable and kind! Great drinks! I don't know where they get their cookies from, but if that is in house, give that person a raise! soooo good. You all will not be disappointed.Dietary restrictions: they offer dairy free options“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
The Confection Connection Cafe and Bakery Bakery • $
1917 Melody Ln, Greenfield - 9.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cute Packaging for Cupcakes
Chicken Caesar Salad
Blueberry Muffin
White Chocolate
Grilled Cheese
Chicken Salad
Birthday Cake
Cinnamon Roll
Wedding Cake
Cookies

“Confection Connection created everything for our wedding day - Groom's cake, hotel bag cookies, and our wedding cake and we couldn't be happier. Not only did everything taste phenomenal but also looked just as good! Tons of compliments from all of our guests. They were so easy to work with and got everything perfect! Can't wait to work with them for more life events to come!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Ultimate Eats Coffee Shops •
609 Main St, Lapel - 9.26 miles

“The owner is delightful to talk with. The baked goods and food are visually appealing and tasty. A variety of hot and cold beverages are made to order. Of special note is the sugar-free items that do not taste sugar-free, but they sell out many days, so come earlier. Newer items are donuts that had sold out my last visit.“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Ms. Marsha's Sweets Cafe • $$
3827 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis - 10.44 miles

“My first time here was today, 09/15 around noon. I asked the kind man behind the counter what he recommends. The said everything was vegan and the brownies and chocolate chip cookies are great. He also stated that the cupcake is good too. I went with his first suggestion and I'm glad I did. The brownie was very good. I only wish I could have warmed it up. If I'm ever in the area again, I definitely give them another visit.“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews