10 Best Caribbean Restaurants in Indianapolis

Yaso Jamaican Grill Jamaican • $
1501 Prospect St, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken Red Beans and Rice Along w Some Cabbage
JD's Brown Stew Chicken Thursday and Friday Special
Coconut Curry Shrimp and Escovitch Red Snapper
Cheese and Jamaican Patties in Beef
Oxtail Gravy on Rice and Peas
Goat Curry and Oxtail Plate
Jerk Chicken Wings
Jerk Chicken Dark
Macaroni & Cheese
Mild Jerk Chicken

“It was long overdue, but I finally made it out to my cousin's restaurant. I've heard nothing but good things about it & finally got to taste it for myself..& it was deeeeliscious! I'm so glad it was good because I've told a million people to try it even though I hadn't even been there yet myself.. I'm already looking forward to our next visit.. I didn't see Ja'Net Edwards this evening, but I wanna catch her there so I can tell her how proud of her I am.. ?“

4.8 Superb132 Reviews
Delicia Latin American • $$
5215 N College Ave, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Spirits Liqueur Based Cocktals
Short Ribs with Ancho Salsa
Queso Fundido Con Chorizo
Caribbean Jerk Chicken
Churros and Chocolate
Curried Coconut Mahi
Cazuela De Mariscos
Chicken & Waffles
Chilaquiles Verde
Breakfast Burrito

“I love the food and the ambiance here. The food is incredible and not overly priced. The service has been great both times we visited. For drinks I tried the Smoke and Stone and the Fire and Ice, I preferred the former. This is definitely one of my new favorites.“

4.8 Superb123 Reviews
Patties of Jamaica Jamaican • $
5172 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Beef Patty's Ask for the Spicey Ketchup
Chicken Wings Peas and Rice Beef Patty
Chicken Breast and Coleslaw
Jamaican Patties
Hard Dough Bread
Curried Chicken
Frozen Patties
Jamaican Patty
Rice and Peas
Curried Goat

“This is an incredible spot that has been family ran for years! Prepare for a line as it’s very locally popular? The patties are a must, but the wings are very fire too. If you get anything though get it with their signature spicy ketchup ?‍?“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
MISS FOOD PRODUCTS LLC Caribbean • $
7747 Santa Monica Dr, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Bouillon Cabrit
Seafood Boil
Croissant

“I mean, where do I start! The food is amazing, presentation is on point. Customer service is really important to me, and they sure deliver on that front too. I highly recommend the bouillon, but everything I’ve had there so far has been delicious! Oh and did I mention that the portions are also pretty good.“

5 Superb26 Reviews
ELI'S CUISINE Caribbean • $
6335 Intech Commons Drive Suites C, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Fried Tilapia

“I tried this place off of door dash and I was impressed with the portion sizes. I got the dokuno, it was a fried whole talapia fish and rice. It came with something similar to fufu but had a lime type taste to it. Also it came with a yummy dipping sauce and 2 very hot sauces. Great experience.“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
Caribe Marisqueria Seafood • $$
8855 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Langosta Rellena de Mariscos
Camarones Empanizados
Caldo De Mariscos
Empanadas De Camar
Seafood Molcajete
Caldo De Camaron
Fajitas Texanas
Flan Napolitano
Fried Mojarra
Mixed Ceviche

“"Warning: this Mexican seafood restaurant is so good, you may need to buy a new wardrobe. I swear, I've tried every dish on the menu (twice) and each bite is more delicious than the last. The shrimp tacos? Divine. The shrimp tostadas Heavenly. The grilled fish? Ah, just take my money already! And don't even get me started on the guac - I've gained 5 pounds just from scooping it onto tortilla chips. But honestly, it's worth it. My taste buds are doing the cha cha slide and my waistline is paying the price. 5/5 stars, would highly recommend...and also suggest buying stock in stretchy pants.“

4.3 Superb75 Reviews
Jamaican Breeze Sports Bar & Grill Caribbean • $
Recommended
4189 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Ital Stew Veg with Rice and Peas and Steamed Cabbage
Jerk Chicken White Baby Back Ribs
Jerk Chicken Wrap
Jamaican Patties
Jerk Pot Roast
Curry Chicken
And Cabbage
Jerk Shrimp
Jerk Wings
Coco Bread

“I ordered jerk chicken(finger licken good, spicy as expected but sweet sauce that glazed the chx). some veggies along with hands down best plantains I’ve ever had!! To drink I had a custom run drink they make to top off and some H20 lol. Love this place.“

4.2 Good107 Reviews
Jamaican Style Jerk Jamaican • $
7023 Michigan Rd #2742, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken with Rice and Beans
Steam Cabbage
Oxtail Meal
Smoked Ribs

“The restaurant was clean and inviting BUT be prepared to wait in line. I stood in line for 30 minutes with only 3 people ahead of me.. It’s only one person taking orders and payments, preparing the orders.. also make sure you go at least an 2 hours before the restaurant closes they run out of food.. I got there 730pm and oxtail among other items was sold out.“

4.2 Good36 Reviews
Negrill Jamaican Restaurant and Bar Caribbean • $
3701 W 10th St, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Jerked Ribs Spicy Sauce and Spicy Rice and Cabbage
Fresh Pressed Juice
Curry Chicken
Curry Goat

“As others have stated, the people cooking and running the place are quite friendly and accomodating. I was able to discuss my health related diet restrictions and get recommendations on entrees that fit my needs.The decor inside is lush with colorful murals giving a nice Jamaican vibe along with a handful of TV screens. They had a soccer game on loud enough to make conversation difficult with the staff. That probably isn't a problem unless you're having a detailed conversation like we were.I got the white meat j*** chicken meal and had enough food for two meals and I'm a big guy. The chicken was grilled in the outdoor smokers and was nicely flavorful as a result. The spicy sauce was not terribly spicy by Thai and Mexican standards but was nicely flavored for all that. Definitely hoosier level adjustments made there. The tables do have additional hot sauces for those (like me) who prefer more heat.The rice was plain steamed and the cabbage was also fairly plain with a bit of seasoning. Some vinegar-based sauce would help both.The meal also came with a few pieces of fried plantain and I have to agree with other comments that this item definitely needs help. It probably started out nicely crisp and possibly moist on the inside. But, like all but the meat, it was pulled from a steam tray and suffered badly as a result. It was gummy and yet oddly dry as well.I've seen this at other restaurants in town and it drags down the experience of the meal noticeably. If there's anything that can be done by the restaurant to address this, I highly recommend looking into it. Perhaps serve plantain chips instead or possibly do a finish cooking of partially cooked plantain right before serving.Given the total experience, I think 4 stars is reasonable. They've obviously put a lot of thought and effort into their environment and offerings and I'll look forward to trying other dishes they recommended as I have time.“

4 Good64 Reviews
Jiallo's African Caribbean Cuisine African • $
7940 Michigan Rd #17, Indianapolis

Customers` Favorites

Curry Goat and Rice and Cabbage and Carrots
Jerk Chicken with Rice and Plantains
Jamacian Beef Patties
Oxtail Rice and Peas
Island Jerk Wings
Beef Short Ribs
Curry Chicken
Whole Tilapia
Grilled Lamb
Oxtail Stew

“Delicious! You arrive, place your order at the counter, and you select your beverage out of the cooler. No alcohol available. You pay at the counter. They have tables for you to eat inside or you can take your food to go. All good arrives in to-go containers. I ordered the chicken curry dinner and chose 2 sides. I chose the cabbages and jollof rice. The amount of food and the price is very reasonable. It was perfectly seasoned! I plan to come back and take an order home for dinner n my way home. We had a large group and they took very good care of us. Definitely recommend!“

4 Good49 Reviews
Loading...
map Map