Cousin Vinny's Pizza
$ • Pizza, Chicken WingsAbout Cousin Vinny's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Breadsticks with Dipping Sauces
Ranch Buffalo Chicken Pizza 10
Steak Formaggio Pizza 10
Meaty Hawaiian Pizza 10
Boneless Chicken Chunks
Mushroom Gravy Hoagie
Cheddar Bacon Hoagie
Garlic Cheesy Bread
Florentine Pizza 10
The Boss Pizza 10
Cousin Vinny's Pizza Reviews
185 ratings
Share your opinion about Cousin Vinny's Pizza
New management has made this place worth coming back for more. Customer Service is 2nd to none , and the quality of the food keeps you coming back for more. Its time Muncie gives this place another chance.
I was beyond impressed; one the food is so cheap; cheaper than mcdonalds/Taco Bell. Two it's so tasty and full of flavor. For 9$ they have sandwiches that are mouth savoring! They have pastas that are beyond delicious; and their loaded Philly steak tots!!! Omg you haven't lived until you've ate those tots!! This is my new favorite food place in Muncie!!
Let’s not play games here. It’s great pizza for what you pay for. They are quick, reliable, and consistent. I really like the Florentine pizza (no mushrooms obv).
Hours
| Monday | 4PM - 3AM |
| Tuesday | 4PM - 3AM |
| Wednesday | 4PM - 3AM |
| Thursday | 4PM - 3AM |
| Friday | 4PM - 4AM |
| Saturday | 4PM - 4AM |
| Sunday | 4PM - 3AM |
Cousin Vinny's Pizza in Muncie is known for its good pizza at an affordable price, with the added benefit of late-night hours. While the online ordering experience can sometimes be inconsistent, with issues like incorrect drink orders and long wait times, the food itself often receives praise. Customers particularly enjoy the Cream & Crimson pizza and the cookies. The restaurant has also earned a good reputation for its traditional wings, with many claiming they are the best in town.
Service quality can vary, but there have been positive experiences where staff members are friendly and efficient, managing to keep customers informed about their orders. However, some customers have expressed frustration when issues arise with their orders, especially when they feel their concerns are not addressed effectively. Overall, Cousin Vinny's remains a decent pizza option in the area, though the dining experience may differ based on the day and the staff present.