18 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Bern

“The best pizza around!!!!“

“We’ve been eating at Gina’s for YEARS! It’s a family favorite!!“

“just moved here from the north east and this pizza is by far the best pie around. highly recommend and will definitely be back“

“The chef at Beartown recently accommodated a very specific food request for a child's birthday and it was wonderful. It was the only request my kiddo made for his birthday and we were so fortunate he was willing to help make it happen. Thank you for the wonderful meal and gentle attention you and your workers provided.“

“I have eating at Sara's since she opened. He menu is one of the largest if not the largest menu in New Bern. everything I have ever eaten at Sara's is delicious. The meatballs are large and delicious, and I love the marinara sauce. Service is always good with a smile. and I don't know of another restaurant that earned 100% from the NC Health Department.“

“The girls at the drive through were polite. The only issue I had was the amount of time my order took and the lack of explanation but the store manager gave me a call and explained the delay. Very pleased with their professionalism and quality of service. The cause in my delay was due to the cook. I used to prefer the Glenburnie location until we moved closer to MLK. The past 3 times we've been to the MLK location we've had great service and this was the only time my order took long.“

“It's domino's at the end of the day but I will say this location tries its best. We've had multiple order mishaps and the manager is always quick to try and correct the order by either remaking it entirely or including extras like drinks or deserts. All in all they've earned our loyalty and the customer service is top notch“

“We have consistently had great pizza of every kind from this Domino’s. I seriously don’t understand the not 5 star across. We have ordered from them almost weekly for two years. Their pizzas of all types are excellent, crust whether crispy or garlic original is delicious. The brownie bites are gooey and good. Parmesan bread bites are awesome. Salads are good but not a lot to those but it’s not a salad bar so you do get decent portion. Service by driver is always friendly and quick to arrive. My only suggestion is for management to consider adding a cauliflower crust pizza, then we might order twice a week! To me, it’s the best pizza comparable to any great Italian restaurant.“

“The best pizza is the best Italian food“

“Fastest delivery in town. My last 3 orders have been in my hand within 15 mins of completing my online order! Driver even brought a dipping sauce (random choice) when they saw I didn’t select one with my order. That spoke volumes to me… even the driver wants me to get my moneys worth. PayPal and ApplePay option is outstanding too.“

“Famous is our favorite place to eat in New Bern. The food is always delicious and the service is top notch. Today, Kimberly was our server and took excellent care of Becky and me. She was prompt, considerate, friendly and just a delightful addition to our time spent at Famous! You can’t beat Famous for food and customer care.“

“Lunch at 37th today. It was delicious!!! Service was friendly and prompt. Could not have asked for a better experience. We have been coming to New Bern for a few years now and 37th is one of our go to places. We will be back!“

“I have try so many different pizza .. this pizza take me back to NYC it's taste great.. love it.. the cashier was not really helpful 😕 she look like she didn't want to deal with us I even saw her roll her eyes on a other customer she did not let me know they will be right out with my order or nothing.. so her service is poor. But other then that everything good.“

“I'm from Chicago and I miss Chicago pizza terribly.
I've lived in MA, CT and now NC and have not found ANY pizza that I could even like, let alone continue to order from.
I just had to say, while it's still not Chicago pizza, this particular restaurant does not disappoint.
When I ask for extra sauce and extra cheese, they give me exactly that! The pizza is very good and I do order on a regular basis.
I've learned to make my own, somewhat comparable to what I grew up on but when I'm feeling lazy, Papa John's on Glenburnie is it!!!
Thank you! ?“

“Ordered late night delivery on Saturday Nov. 12th of 22. Our order was placed at around midnight close to 1am and arrived on time and fresh and hot. Requested my pizza to be in the shape of a heart and they nailed it! I loved it! It was perfect! It was beautiful AND delicious. Toppings were just as requested as well. Seriously, whoever made this za, you need a raise .😎🍕“

“Food and service was excellent. Nice salad starter followed by delicious Manicotti and Veal Parm dinners. Five stars.“

“Great food & super people! Love their food. And it's always nice & clean. I eat there frequently.“

“Amazing atmosphere,service and excellent pizza. It was our first time dining here and we will definitely be back.“