Italian Restaurants near Sylva

“A true gem. Not only was the food top-notch (and we are foodies from NYC!) but we got a special cocktail and chat from the cocktail-master as well as some hiking advice from another staff member. All very lovely. Probably the best restaurant of the year for us!“

“Update - I called and complained and the manager made it right - a new pizza that was cooked properly. Just be aware.Normally I like this place - especially their garlic bread - but my last order left something to be desired. I ordered a to-go pizza since I hadn't had one in awhile. I specified on the phone that I wanted a medium size. When I went to pick it up, I thought the bill was a little more than it should be, but I know everything is up in price. When I got the pizza home, I could see why it was more - they gave me a large rather than a medium. And it's a good thing I don't mind a burnt crust as much as some people - I should have taken the pizza back but it was a lot of trouble. Waste of $20.“

“Menu here is so vast a space telescope couldn't take it all in. I honestly can't think of. an establishment with variety like you'll find here. Order at the counter, then server promptly brings it to your self selected table. The walls are nearly full of historic photographs and memrobeal that I hope to take a closer look at, WHEN I go back.“

“We didn’t know what to expect when walking in from shopping but man are we glad we stopped by. We are making coming here a tradition when we visit Maggie Valley. Service was great. Our waitress had a sense of humor and the food is stellar!“

“The food was amazing for the most part, but we were there about 45 minutes to an hour before we received our food. When we were seated and our waitress came to ask our order after about 10 minutes, she asked if we wanted appetizers. We said no, and her response was "oh thank God." This struck me as very odd. Would recommend if you like good food. Would not recommend if you are hungry at the moment you get there.“

“We've never had a bad experience here. Multiple meals have all been spot on delicious. It is a great relaxing meal to take a break from the casino in Cherokee. Their pastas are perfect and the steak is the best in the resort. 10/10 would recommend. We will eat there again on our next trip.“