Custom Cakes near Elmwood Park, NJ

McCrum's Bakery Bakery • $
378 Market St, Elmwood Park

“Their pastries are amazing. The service is amazing. Sweet sugary goodness. Got addicted after a coworker brought a box of the pecan danish's and I will never go anywhere else. What's nice is that you can place an order before hand for pick up since those go out super fast by high demand. They are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays which is a bummer but definitely give them a try. Small bakery but big impact on your taste buds! Love it!“

4.8 Superb24 Reviews
Vela's Bakery Bakery • $
246 Market St, Elmwood Park

“This the best bakery shop in Elmwood Par,Saddle Brook and around.The workers there are genuinely friendly; especially the owner and his family. There are two young people who especially come to mind. I've been going to this wonderful bakery since 2016 and have never been disappointed in the service or quality of their scrumptious cakes, cookies, cupcakes, special holiday offerings, etc.Definitely a bakery that values the customer aboveall else.Everyone should try out this place.“

4.4 Superb5 Reviews
Zadies Kosher Bake Shop Bakery • $
19-09 Fair Lawn Ave, Fair Lawn - 2.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Vanilla Cream Cake
Black and White Cookie
Sesame Street Cupcakes
Strawberry Mousse Cake
Lemon Merengue Pie
Everything Challah
Rainbow Cookie
Torah Cake
Rugalach
Doughnut

“They did an amazing job on my daughter’s unicorn birthday cake, it literally took my breath away when I saw it! My 4 year old had the same reaction! My daughter is allergic to sesame and tree nuts, so I’m thrilled to have found this bakery for all of her celebration cakes!“

4.8 Superb95 Reviews
Empabake Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $
334 Belleville Turnpike, North Arlington - 8.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Two Eggs and Bacon with Two Pancakes
Freshly Baked Empanadas
Two Eggs with Ham
Rice and Beans
Birthday Cake
Egg Any Style
Ropa Vieja
Tiramisu
Veggie

“excellent!!! great service, great flavors, their empanadas are so delicious! The place is cozy, clean, with an easy going vibe! the owner is very nice, and is there everytime I've visited, you can tell they pour their heart in their business! thank you! is so hard to find good food and good service in the same stablishement nowadays, keep up the great work!“

4.9 Superb54 Reviews
Stuff by SJ Bakery •
342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair - 8.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Dipped Oreos
Strawberry Cake Cup
Celebration Cakes
Classic Cupcake
Birthday Cake
Cake Cups

“Really impressed! We asked Stuff by SJ to make a custom cake for a pizza-themed birthday party. Working with them (Drew) was super easy and stress free. They were helpful, responsive, well priced and even delivered our cake to the restaurant ahead of the party. Everyone complimented the design and taste of the cake so it was a big hit. I’d definitely go back to them for our next cake.“

4.8 Superb79 Reviews
Sweet love cafe Coffee Shops • $
475 Washington Ave, Belleville - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Prosciuttol Pesto Sandwich
blt Croissant Sandwich
Caramel Iced Coffee
Iced Caramel Latte
blt Sandwich

“This is quite, cozy and very “clean” cafe. People here are very sweet and friendly. We had a piece of carrot Cake with nuts and the flavor was really great.you can definitely stop by to spend quality time with friends and family! Happy to be here.Parking: Street parking availablePrice: Affordable“

5 Superb33 Reviews
The Modern Cakery Custom Cakes • $$
385 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell - 5.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Cake Pop
Macaron

“We have been getting our cakes from here since our baby shower in 2019 & this is now our son’s 5th birthday cake. I have never been disappointed. Communication is always on point and we always get exactly what we ask for. So clean, so professional & amazing customer service. We will continue to be a forever customer. Thank you guys for always being the perfect finishing touch to our celebrations!“

4.9 Superb43 Reviews
It’s Delicious Bakery • $$
213 Main St, Ridgefield Park - 5.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cucumber Tea Sandwiches
Ham & Cheese Crossiants
Chicken Empanadas
Cheddar Scones
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“Cristal created the most amazing cake for my sister’s gender reveal! It was my first time ordering a custom cake but Cristal was very patient and helpful with designing the perfect cake for the occasion. I would go to Cristal for all my cake needs :)“

5 Superb22 Reviews
Mo & Jay Pastry Pastry shop •
44 Main St Suite 1, Little Falls - 5.84 miles

“***4 1/2 stars**I'm not sure how crazy I am about this place being a few blocks from where I live, but I suppose that's not Mo & Jay's fault. I've been aware of this bakery/pastry establishment for a few years (I think it showed up in this relatively new apartment building on Main Street two or three years ago), but hadn't actually thought to go inside until yesterday morning. I was entrusted with obtaining a dessert for a weekend BBQ, and it occurred to me that this was at least the easiest spot to quickly grab something. The fact that the desserts were extremely good ended up being a pleasant accident/bonus.I brought one of my top tier chums to assist with the purchase. From very brief research, it seemed like the eclairs were the big selling point here. I thought it would also be a little wily on my part to get them because I tend to not enjoy eating food that has stuff in it, and figured I'd be unlikely to do anything too naughty with that. That turned out not to be accurate, but I digress. We got the five for $25 éclair deal, and procured a raspberry, a lemon meringue, a nutella, a pistachio and a cookies & cream. Just as we were about to wrap up, I also impulsively grabbed a cheddar/bacon scone, which was humongous and understandably caught my eye.The eclairs were definitely a hit. My personal favorite was the cookies & cream. The flavor was incredibly on point, and it was almost like a meta ice cream experience. The only issue with that one specifically was that the cream inside was runnier than the other pastries, which made it a little messy. Not a huge deal. The runner-up was probably the raspberry for me. Again, extremely flavorful, almost to a fault - it was overwhelmingly tart, which is obviously kind of a calling card for raspberries but if you're not into that, I'd stay away. The nutella was actually a little on the bland side for me but not bad. The lemon meringue was a big hit for everyone else, but I'm not a huge fan of that flavor to begin with - I don't think that's a mark against this place by any means. In hindsight, we probably wouldn't have gotten the pistachio, but none of us are hardcore pistachio fans. The cream consistency and dough for all of these was very high quality, and understandably a lot of this is going to come down to how you feel about specific flavors.In a final twist later on, I sampled the scone around dinner time and was very pleasantly surprised - the scone was very moist and tasty, and was reminiscent of a Red Lobster cheddar bay biscuit, though probably at least twice the size and with actual pieces of bacon in it. Very strong recommend on that front.The service was very good. We had a pleasant female cashier assisting us as my chum was literally squatting on the ground eagerly peering into the display case squealing out flavors to get. Zero issues there, and we were in and out within a few minutes uneventfully. There were also a lot of cakes and other types of pastries, so I expect I'll be returning shortly to obtain their assistance with another BBQ.“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Huascar & Co. Bakeshop Bakery • $
453 W 54th St, New York - 11.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mini-Cupcakes Dozen Box
Creme Brulee Cupcake
Confetti Cupcake
Custom Cakes
Cupcakes
Cookies

“Went and got a few different baked goods. Flan and Chocolate chip cookie was absolutely DELICIOUS, the flan was sweet and smooth and the chocolate chip was soft and not too sweet. Caramel apple cupcake was super cute and tasty. Haven't had the chocolate cupcake yet but it looks absolutely lovely. Only thing was the pistachio macaron was okay, might have just been a bad batch. Overall very tasty and glad I gave it a stop!“

4.7 Superb61 Reviews
Gio’s Gelato & Espresso Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
822 Franklin Ave, Franklin Lakes - 9.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bomboloni

“The best gelato in NJ hands down. I'm from Europe and always have a hard time finding authentic gelato, well this is it! I drive from NY to Gio's for the affogato with nocciola gelato, and my girls love the strawberry one. Delicious, local, and the owner/staff are wonderful people.“

4.9 Superb26 Reviews
Bradley Bake Shop Gluten-free Bakery • $$$
55B River Rd, Bogota - 5.01 miles

“I'm really grateful to Bradley Bake Shop for fulfilling my last-minute cupcake and cake order. The kids absolutely loved them, especially my daughter, who can't stop praising how delicious they were. This bakery has been my favorite spot since my daughter was born. The owner is incredibly kind and always looks after their customers. A big thank you!Dietary restrictions: No peanut, nuts“

4.8 Superb35 Reviews
Petal Dust Cakery Bakery • $
11 Rodney St, Glen Rock - 4.09 miles

“I can't be more impressed with the owner herself ie Christina and her beautiful creation of a yacht cake that she made for me at the very last moment. The cake was perfect and it was melting in the mouth and really yum. I will surely return for any future orders.“

4.8 Superb34 Reviews
Dulce De Leche Bakery Bakery • $
55 W Palisade Ave, Englewood - 7.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Egg and Cheese on Brioche
Ham and Cheese Croissant
Table Harvest Salad
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Breakfast Sandwich
Milanesa Sandwich
Spanish Tortilla
Western Omelette
Spinach Quiche
Chocolate Cake

“This place is amazing! It's always clean, nice, and neat. They offer delicious options for desserts and grab-and-go meals. I love that they have a simple yet fulfilling menu. The atmosphere is super chill and totally worth it. My family and I love to grab a few pastries to take home, and now it has become our go-to gift store. Whenever we have an event or an office meeting, we travel all the way from New City to Englewood without hesitation.The only details that sometimes disappoints us is that at the end of the day, the staff's attitude or vibe is not as nice as in the mornings. We totally understand that it's the end of the day and they want to go home, but it would be great if they could maintain their friendly attitude throughout the day., and that it only opens at 8 am, so work commute to grab a coffee becomes hard. However, around 90% of our experiences there have been nice, and we look forward to visiting again soon“

4.6 Superb121 Reviews
Bebe Bakes Bakery • $$
939 8th Ave, New York - 11.86 miles

“Bebe Bakes does it again! Beth Bennett is my go-to gal for custom cakes and cookies. She did not disappoint for the twins’ 17th birthday…a Shiba Inu in a red Formula One Ferrari! Vanilla cake with chocolate mousse filling! Gorgeous and delicious!“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
GoodieBox Bakeshop Bakery • $$
374 Palisade Ave, Cliffside Park - 9.01 miles

“Don't miss this jewel box of a bakeshop for celebrations both big and small! We ordered a lemon raspberry cake for a family celebration and it was such a big hit. Tall, elegant, and sprinkled with freeze-dried raspberries to hint at the flavor inside. It looked like the top tier of a wedding cake! Everyone was so impressed with it visually but once we tasted it, we all loved how moist and lemony it was. The guests were all raving about how balanced the buttercream was. The texture and sweetness was just right. The guest of honor even swiped some extra frosting off someone else's plate, which I've NEVER seen him do!In this day and age, everyone wants a cake that photographs beautifully. But sometimes a gorgeous cake will be too dry/dense or the frosting just tastes like colored butter. You never want a second piece. It really can be a lottery sometimes. But with this gorgeous, delectable cake we definitely hit the jackpot!Thank you, Carrie, for putting as much thought into the flavor as you did on the presentation. It really made our celebration feel special.“

5 Superb18 Reviews
Bella Vida Pastry Cafe Bakery • $
1197 Main Ave, Clifton - 2.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookies and Dessert
Vanilla Flan Slice
Birthday Cake

“Ordered a gorgeous 2 tiered cake for my daughters 3rd birthday (Under the THREE themed) and Bella vida did not disappoint! Not only was the cake aesthetically appealing, but it was delicious! Very light and moist, the cannoli filling was to die for, and the dulce de leche filling was fantastic! Extremely flavorful and the details were intricate and you can tell there is a real passion for baking! EVERYONE was raving about the cake and asking where I got it from. Simply delicious!! We will absolutely be ordering our cakes from here from now on, I won't go anywhere else!!“

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop Bakery • $
256 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst - 6.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black and White Cookie
Birthday Cake
Cannoli
Bakery
Pie

“I ordered a custom cake from Lyndhurst Pastry Shop and it was perfect! They walked me through everything over the phone. They went above and beyond by adding flowers to the cake, just beautifully decorated. So delicious, too. The person on the phone was lovely, and the customer service in store when I went to pickup was amazing as well! Just super<3“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Karla Jiménez Cakes & More Custom Cakes •
78 W Main St, Bogota - 4.93 miles

“My friend at work referred me to Karla’s Bakery, I was looking for a place to order a customized cake for my daughters birthday, I ended up referring my sister to her and we are not disappointed, Karla made a wonderful, tasty customized cake in town, I will definitely will spread the word to everyone I know that this bakery is one of the best and the owner is super nice and detailed on all customers requests. Keep up a great work I will definitely order all my cakes to you.“

4.6 Superb45 Reviews
Pierre & Michel Authentic French Bakery Bakery • $
38 E Ridgewood Ave, Ridgewood - 5.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Tart Pain Suisse Mocha Latte
Ham and Cheese Croissant Sandwich
Passion Fruit Cake
Apricot Croissant
Chocolate Eclair
Apple Croissant
Strawberry Tart
Creme Brulee
Croissants
Macaroons

“Lovely Bakery Cafe with a classic, relaxed ambience and old world charm. Came late afternoon on Presidents Day and there were lots of customers but also plentiful seats available. The croissant lived up to its reputation! It was large, crumbly and flaky on the outside and very affordably priced. Cashier was very friendly too! She offered to heat up our croissant and brought it out to us on a plate. This place is definitely worth a visit!“

4.5 Superb89 Reviews
Rispoli’s Pastry Shop (Hawthorne) Bakery •
1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne - 4.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

American Cheesecake 7
Strawberry Shortcake
Italian Cheesecake
Anisette Biscotti
Assorted Cookies
Chocolate Mousse
Macaroons 1 4 lb
Chocolate Chip
Lobster Tails
Birthday Cake

“Rose at Rispoli’s is a delight! Best service and pastries in Bergen County! The lobster tails are to die for. Just ordered a birthday cake and Easter dessert. Not to mention the fresh bread baked all day long. You cannot go wrong with this gem in our backyard!“

4.5 Superb68 Reviews
Mattarello Bakery & Café Bakery • $
254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair - 6.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail Napoleon Rainbow Cake Raspberry Mousse
Bombolone
Tiramisu

“This was my first time visiting Mattarello bakery and I will definitely come back!When I walked in - I was welcomed by smiling and happy barista.It was hard to choose what I wanted to try,they have a lot off different cookies,pastries and cakes,the lady who was working there helped me to choose the perfect pastries to try.I had bombolone donut with custard cream, lobster tail with chantilly cream and a large cappuccino.Everything tasted amazing.Fresh,a lot(!!!)of filling which made me really happy.For coffee lovers - they have different types of milk to choose for your cappuccino,latte or matcha latte.I had a cappuccino with almond milk and look at the cute bear!I can’t wait to come back another time to try something new!?☕️ “

4.5 Superb65 Reviews
Dulce Cakes & Desserts Bakery • $$
100 Park Ave, Englewood - 7.06 miles

“Wow. Dulce really delivered for our daughter's Toy Story-inspired baby shower. Everyone loved the cake, desserts and favors! The Dulce de Leche cake was next level goodness. And the owner even threw in a complimentary diaper cake as a gift that really stood out.“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Chic Sugars Bakery • $$
28 S Dean St, Englewood - 7.53 miles

“We LOVE Chic Sugars! It's fully kosher with a great hashgacha and the sweets are the best you'll find in the tristate! Our family's birthday and holiday cakes ALL come from here. They are next-level beautiful and delicious -- a whole different kettle of buttercream that's superior to any other bakery around. Note for Uber Eats users: Chic Sugars is available there but is not listed under kosher eateries. Just search the name and it will pop up.“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Flavor For Favors LLC Bakery • $$
222 Fairway Ave, Belleville - 7.67 miles

“Wow wow wow! I ordered 3 dozen Minecraft themed cupcakes for my son's sixth birthday, and they were amazing! The cupcakes looked amazing and tasted even better! So soft and fluffy. And the buttercream topping was so smooth and not too sweet. Jason will not disappoint if you need a baked cake for an event. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Rudy's Pastry Shop Bakery • $$
23 Willet St, Bloomfield - 8.22 miles

“We ordered a custom cake for my wife's birthday celebration and it was perfect, as tasty as it was beautiful. Colleen worked with us on finding the perfect design, and helped us choose a great filling. Highly recommend Rudy's for a special occasion.“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews
Dairy Cream Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
320 Fairview Ave, Fairview - 8.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookies and Cream

“STOP STOP STOP RIGHT HERE... you gotta have some of this.Everything prepared here is tasty and satisfying to the mind, body and soul.The service is like going to your grandma's house for dessert. She makes sure your dessert is made just the way you want it... SATISFYING!Old school ice cream shop perfect for recalling great memories and creating new memories. Her welcoming smile and hospitality warms the heart then the ice cream cools it down.“

4.6 Superb14 Reviews
David's Custom Cakes Bakery • $$
1237 Belmont Ave, North Haledon - 5.68 miles

“We had a custom Ups truck made for our wedding on September 30th, 2023. They did an amazing job!!! The cake was magnificent. There wasn't a person who wasn't blow away when they saw the cake. It tasted good, too. We will always use David's Custom Cakes when we have an event. Their communication and delivery were also perfect.“

4.5 Superb20 Reviews
Argentina Bakery Bakery • $
1611 Bergenline Ave, Union City - 10.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dulce De Leche Filled German Danish
Small Sweet Roll 50c Each
Classic Argentinian Cake
Alfajores De Maizena
Dulce De Leche Roll
Argentinian Cakes
Chicken Empanada
Tres Leches Cake
Caramel Pastries
Assorted Cookies

“I love bills, Milanese samwish and more. It is a place that has been giving us the delicious taste of Argentina for 35 or more years, bringing memories and a piece of South America to New Jersey. Thank you for still keeping your Argentina alive...“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Baked Meringue Patisserie/Cake Shop •
67 Ridgefield Ave, Ridgefield Park - 6.13 miles

“The owner is an amazing person. The cakes are delicious and very well decorated. She always works with her clients especially with the details of the cakes. She is also very professional, friendly and the love for the work she does shows on her creativity and cakes. Thank you again for an excellent service ?“

4.6 Superb10 Reviews
Loading...
map Map