Mattarello Bakery & Café

$ ‱ Custom Cakes, Coffee, Tea

254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
(973) 337-6275


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

It was a tale of two experiences. The Bombolone was great, light and the Nutella was creamy. My cafe americano was perfect also. But the lobster tail just didn't do it for me. First it had a dent on the top of it, which I can deal with, but it wasn't flaky and cream was too dense. When I bit into it there was no crisp and was chewy. I'm almost certain that these were made a day before and were refrigerated. Score is a 3.5 because the other 2 were good.

Bam! Let's get into it. At 11AM on a Saturday on my way to Anderson Park with Archie, I was hankering for a cold libation (that's right an iced coffee--it was 91 degrees). I happened to come across a new kid on the block. However, this kid had the maturity that exceeded my expectations. There were two very mature gentlemen, Ray and Bill, sitting outside on a bench. I asked (in a neighborly kind of way, "I see you have a coffee cup in your hand. Is this place any good?" One full review
Just wow! My husband and I had gotten back from a trip out of town after which we felt like we needed something real "Jersey." Immediate thought cannolis! We were passing by this bakery, which I am assuming is either very new or very hidden, but regardless, we were so pleased we went in. Let me start by saying the staff was super nice! We were overwhelmed by the options so asked many questions, and they were not the least bit annoyed. They allowed us to mix and match so we full review

More Reviews(49)


Monday 6AM - 7PM
Tuesday 6AM - 7PM
Wednesday 6AM - 7PM
Thursday 6AM - 7PM
Friday 6AM - 7PM
Saturday 6AM - 7PM
Sunday 6AM - 7PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.