21 Best Caterers near Lake Hiawatha

Jeremiahs Catering & Cooking Studio Caterers • $$
44 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha

“We had Chef T cater our son’s baptism. My husband and I couldn’t be happier with the quality and quantity of the food provided — and everyone was raving about it! There was not a single item that I wish I had not chosen, and there were so many more options that we are excited to try in the future. The ordering process was easy and Chef T is extremely friendly. Thank you for helping make our son’s special day even better!“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
David Alan Caterers Caterers • $$$
12-16 Littell Rd #5C, East Hanover - 4.77 miles

“David Alan Caterers, catered our Thanksgiving this past month and it was stupendous!!! We hosted our thanksgiving in Montclair, NJ and we coordinated ALL of it from California. We had not worked with a caterer in New Jersey before, but we will definitely use them again. Our point person was Lisa W., and she was on top of all of it!!!! The food was delish and the staff was spectacular. They handled everything for 20 people. Food, rentals and presentation. We can't recommend them enough!!!“

5 Superb48 Reviews
The Park Savoy Estate Caterers
236 Ridgedale Ave, Florham Park - 6.19 miles

“The most STUNNING Venue! The staff goes above and beyond! On your wedding day you will feel like a celebrity, they think of everything and are always two steps ahead of you! Everyone we worked with was so warm, welcoming, professional, and kind! Not only are the grounds, venue, and chapel gorgeous, but the food will exceed your expectations! Our guest have not stopped telling us how amazing the food (cocktail hour, entrees, desserts), service, and staff were. The bridal assistants, wedding coordinators, maitre' D pay attention to every detail! You will be over the moon if you book your wedding at The Park Savoy Estate. They really treat you like family or should I say royalty! The best around! I hope we have a wedding to attend here soon, because it is OUTSTANDING!“

4.8 Superb77 Reviews
Crystal Plaza Caterers •
305 W Northfield Rd, Livingston - 6.73 miles

“The Crystal Plaza is such an Iconic wedding venue! Any time I get to photograph a wedding here it is such a treat! All of the staff is so great and on top of things and the upgrades they made to the inside of the building really makes it shine!The back area where they have ceremonies and where you can do photos makes my life as a wedding photographer so much easier as its filled with so many great options for breath taking photos! (see attached)I highly recommend having your wedding here! You definitely wont regret it!“

4.8 Superb68 Reviews
Sugarlips Donuts Donut Shops •
145 Main St, Madison - 8.88 miles

“Got here late but better late than never. 4 donuts left. I bought 3 maple bacon. . Crispy bacon on a maple frosted old fashioned donut was delicious. Sometimes a maple bacon can be greasy but these donuts were not. Perfection. I will definitely come back to try more of their donuts. Parking out front on street. Open until 2PM on weekend. Get here early or pre-0rder. Really nice owner. Please patronize this donut shop.“

4.9 Superb40 Reviews
Giuliano's Catering Service Caterers •
6 Deforest Ave # 1, East Hanover - 4.33 miles

“I cannot say enough positive things about the service we received from Giulianos this past weekend. From the drop off of the food for 125 guests to the pick up and everything in between was handled with such professionoalism and positivity. The guests raved about ALL of the food and the desserts were off the charts. There were no left overs, because everyone was thrilled to bring some home for the next day! Michelle was was flexible to work with and always responsive. The suggestions she made to accomodate special requests were perfect. WE will definately be using Giuliano's again in the future!“

5 Superb28 Reviews
The Wilshire Caterers Caterers •
350 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange - 7.93 miles

“The wedding venue is beautiful. The food was great especially the desert the outside grounds are so beautiful for pictures. It place was really clean and just a great place to have a wedding. Joe'l was amazing!!! Cannot say enough about Joe'l super nice very professional, accommodating !! Cannot say enough about her. My only complaint was the attendance that took care of my daughter..... or should I say was supposed to take care of her. They did help with pictures etc... they asked many times if we needed additional help but I had to go to clean the room can we have more champagne that should be done automatically I should not have had to run up and down stairs to ask to have a room tidied up and also to get more champagne also we had to ask for hot coffee.,. My biggest disappointed was the mai'tred at the wedding not once came up to my husband or I or even the bride or groom once asking us if we needed a drink he introduced himself said he was there to help us after that no show. We waited on long lines just to get a drink. My other daughter's wedding we were waited on hand and foot. Especially the bride and groom should have been treated differently. lastly a little disappointed my baskets for the bathroon were never put out again I had to find the attendance to ask for them that something I should not have to do. When we received the baskets back they were empty there was no way every wedding guest took everything out of the baskets just kinda strange they wold keep everything????? Again the hall is great, amazing ......but the staff running the wedding questionable. If you go ask for Joe'l you will love her!!!! She's the best!!! She actually was getting the parents of the bride a drink she saw me waiting on line so that tells you a lot about her.“

4.9 Superb36 Reviews
Michelle's Catering Caterers • $$$
622 NJ-10 #3, Whippany - 4.46 miles

“I hired Michelle's Catering for a pre-New Year's private party for 25 people in my home. To call it a night to remember would be an understatement. Everything was PERFECT! The food was incredible and plentiful, her staff were professional and attentive, and the atmosphere was just what I wanted. All of my guests were happy and enjoyed themselves. I am already looking forward to my next party with Michelle! I recommend her unreservedly.“

4.8 Superb50 Reviews
The Hanover Manor Caterers • $$
16 Eagle Rock Ave, East Hanover - 3.87 miles

“my association has used the Hanover Manor for over 20 years another association who also has monthly meetings here for the past 30 years. Monthly meetings of 30 to 40 members and a yearly symposium for 250 to 300 are all handled by Angelo and his team. Some of our members moved there company affairs to the Hanover Manor.“

4.7 Superb60 Reviews
Ronnie's Catering and BBQ Caterers • $$
315 Palmer Rd, Denville - 7.38 miles

“Wow oh WOW Ronnie's BBQ review here we go!I started planning (4 months ago around April) a Surprise 30th Birthday party for my fiancé that was this past Saturday 8/19. After looking up countless caterers trying to find the best "fit" for the party I was envisioning, I stumbled upon Ronnie's Catering & BBQ just from a simple Google search. Located right in Denville, not too far from where we live, I started first of course by browsing their reviews. What seems like one 5-star review after the next, it was clear that Ronnie's knew what they were doing when it came to feeding a party! I decided to reach out & I coordinated the entire thing with Danielle, who was efficient & an amazing communicator with quick response time. I spoke to the owner Mike a few times as well. They were both so great in answering all of my questions/concerns & super helpful with helping me plan this surprise party for 70 people. Their "Old Tyme Picnic" package was perfect for the event. All I have to say is, my guests could NOT stop coming up to me telling me how delicious this food was. From the BBQ chicken to the ribs to the grilled veggies, everyone could not stop raving about the food (which made me SO happy to hear!). Food is one of the most, if not THEE most important part of having a successful party full of happy guests, & Ronnie's made it happen. I cannot thank you guys enough for being so awesome along with the 2 cooks who came to set up & grill for us for the party. Everything went so beyond smoothly from start to finish. There was plenty of leftovers which we are still feasting on today! Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU! I cannot wait to plan another future party & have Ronnie's come back to cater again.“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
Ferraro's Italian Food Specialties Italian • $
166 Halsey Rd, Parsippany-Troy Hills - 3.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Classic Italian Sandwich Pasta Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Biscotti

“Great, fresh, AUTHENTIC, food! No matter if it is a catering order or a to-go order, you'll be very happy with your purchase!! The chicken vodka parm woth pepperoni along with the French dip are a personal favorite! ? The fried ravioli and wings are AMAZING! I highly recommend!!“

4.7 Superb53 Reviews
Eight Hills Caterers Caterers • $
542 Bloomfield Ave, Verona - 7.85 miles

“I’ve entrusted Eight Hills Catering with our Highland at Hilltop resident summer and holiday parties for three years now, and they consistently exceed expectations. Their food is consistently delicious, the staff is amazing, and their professionalism makes the entire process effortless. Highly recommended for anyone seeking top-notch catering services!“

4.8 Superb31 Reviews
Chef Loryn's Caterers • $$
250 Main St, Madison - 9.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie

“Food options change They offer daily lunch specials and have the best homemade ice cream sandwiches. They offer takeout of one individual meal or full dinners for the family that will look and taste like you cooked it yourself. Not a lot of room to eat in just 1-2 tables if you are lucky enough to have one. You can always take it home to enjoy the great food, quiches, salads , and sandwiches. They also do big party catering.“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Summit & Main Caterers • $$
1 W Main St, Denville - 5.26 miles

“My wife and I were looking to get our reception party catered. After the first attempt at one deli, we decided to look elsewhere and stumbled upon Summit and Main. We are so glad we did. From the day of ordering to pick up everything went smooth. My wife and mother in law were sat down and went over menu, and all of our questions were answered. They suggested their best sellers and how much of everything to order. Everything was a hit and everyone loved the food. We can not recommend Summit and Main enough. The roast beef sliders are out of this world. If you're looking to cater a party wedding birthday etc, look no further.“

4.6 Superb129 Reviews
American Bbq Company Caterers • $
94 Ford Rd #1, Denville - 6.41 miles

“We catered our son's first birthday party with American BBQ and we received SO many compliments about how delicious the food was! The delivery/setup was prompt and super quick! I had numerous email exchanges with Roberta going back and forth with ideas and she was absolutely wonderful to work with! Highly recommend!!“

4.8 Superb22 Reviews
The 53 Grill Sandwich Shop • $
383 E Main St, Denville - 5.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Brisket Quesadilla
Classic Cheesesteak
Mozzarella Sticks

“Absolutely awesome little deli. I love the comic book decorations. They always have great music playing.House made smoked brisket is phenomenal. It makes it hard to try other sandwiches. I finally broke my trend and tried the Ranchero. It did not disappoint!Every sandwich is made with the utmost care and love. It's hard to explain, but it makes a difference.“

4.7 Superb26 Reviews
Creativa Catering Caterers • $$$
236 Boonton Ave, Boonton - 2.42 miles

“Seriously the best catering I’ve ever had. I used Creativa to cater to Doctors offices for years. They were always on time and they always blew the minds of everybody who had the pleasure of eating their food. The only reason I don’t use them anymore is because they are outside the area that I work in. Those were the days!!!“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Town Cafe Deli & Catering Deli • $
84 Ridgedale Ave, Cedar Knolls - 5.54 miles

“I had a spinich/mozzarella omelette w/ side of sausage, home fries and toast. It was fantastic; fluffy eggs, not over done at all. 2 large, tasty sausage patties. This meal is like $7 or $8 more at other diners. Exceeded expectations on price, taste, portion and quality. I will absolutely return to try something off the lunch menu soon.“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Blue Basil Cafe & Catering Caterers • $$
325 Columbia Turnpike, Florham Park - 6.61 miles

“Finally had dinner from here last night. Wish I had done it sooner. Everything was fresh, the potrion sizes were generous and you can't beat the price. Thank you Chef Anthony for helping my family beat the heat and taking care of dinner for us! I highly recommend the food as I will absolutely be ordering from here in the future!“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Eatery Cafe Kitchen Cafe •
1275 Bloomfield Ave Suite 82, Fairfield - 3.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rotisserie Chicken with Rice
Rotisserie Chicken Half
Beef Gyro Wrap Meal
French Fries
Gyro Platter
Falafel
Bagel
Fish

“Came here for the first time for lunch. I’m in the complex. I think I drove by at 25 times before I even noticed. Just had the most incredible chicken platter. I can only eat half of it. I’ll have the other half tomorrow..Fresh chicken nice and hot, Excellent veggies. Everything was. Fresh Thank you!“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Brianna's Nutrition Kitchen LLC Personal Chef Services Caterers • $
17 Bank St, Morristown - 7.99 miles

“She is absolutely outstanding! Brianna is super professional, she catered for my event and everyone was delighted. Presentation was amazing and the flavors were on point. I couldn't be happier to have found her, I go to her all the time for meal plans and I definitely notice a difference in my health. She is a miracle worker in the kitchen!“

4.9 Superb8 Reviews