Nicholas Creamery

Name: Nicholas Creamery
Address: 1500 NJ-35 unit 19, Middletown, New Jersey, 07748, US
Telephone: (848) 225-3476
Price range: $
Rating: 4.5

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
1500 NJ-35 unit 19, Middletown
(848) 225-3476

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

Nicholas Creamery Reviews

4.5 (45)

Write a review

March 2024

With several locations along the Jersey Shore, this Middletown location is the newest. Huge, bright, airy, and busy but no seating on the inside which is kinda sad because I wanted to enjoy my ice cream while looking at what other flavors I should get next. Your only option is either the two benches outside or your car. The servers looked tired but the young man who helped me was nice enough. I picked the Vegan Speculoos Cookie which was AMAZING! The texture was different but...read full review

January 2024

This place is great. It is both my and my kid's favorite ice cream spot. The Peanut Butter Palooza is delicious. The customer service is good also. They always give more than the alootted scoop. And they give tons of candy when you add in a topping. They are great. The ice cream is great. I love it!!

January 2024

Initially my brain said, "that's kinda expensive for ice cream..." But once I tasted the ice cream it was clear you pay for what you get. This is high-end ice cream. It's worth it. SPECIFICALLY they do flavor of the months each month, last month they did a collaboration with Delicious Orchards and mixed an entire pie with cinnamon vanilla ice cream. It was sinfully good. Can't wait to see what they mix up in the future.

More Reviews(45)