16 Best American Restaurants in Princeton

Seasons 52 Steak House • $$
3535 US-1 Suite 100B, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Caramelized Grilled Sea Scallops with Broccoli
Filet Mignon and Maine Lobster Tail
Wood-Grilled Kona-Crusted Lamb Loin
Brick Oven-Roasted Chilean Sea Bass
Wood-Grilled Shrimp and Grits
Wood-Grilled Tenderloin Salad
Brick-Oven Vegetable Gnocchi
Cedar Plank-Roasted Salmon
Lump Crab and Shrimp
Maui Tuna Crunch

“Went Easter Sunday. Table was ready when we got there. Our server 'Alex' - she was the best. Kept an eye on us to see if we needed anything. Food absolutely out of this world Nicely spaced between appetizers and main meal. Gave us time to digest. Absolutely must come here.“

4.6 Superb348 Reviews
Metro North Italian • $$
378 Alexander St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Parmesan Truffle Fries
Grilled Pear Salad
French Onion Soup
Blue Cheese Salad
Bang Bang Shrimp
Eggplant Lasagna
Chicken Marsala
Chili Calamari
Eggplant Tower
Buffalo Wings

“This joint was jumping on a Friday at 6:30. We would have been turned away without a reservation. The pork chop scarpariello, short ribs and filet were excellent entrees. This was a birthday celebration, which is why we went a bit high-end. This venue at this time of night might be a bit noisy for some , but no complaints here - just an excellent meal!“

4.5 Superb219 Reviews
Jagrah's Restaurant American • $$
1 Wheeler Way, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Burger with Mushrooms and Sweet Potato Fries
House Salad with Salmon
Oxtails Sample-Sized
Short Rib Noodle Bowl
Blackened Catfish
Shrimp and Grits
Braised Oxtails
Fried Apple Pie
Seafood Gumbo
Caesar Salad

“Their signature culinary culture is an exceptional customer service with an esoteric culinary experience. If you want to try a cross between Deep South Soul, Asian and American dining, Jagray's is a gem in the Princeton dining area. Located right on the Princeton Country Club Golf Course property itself, Jagrah's is the best culinary experience at this golf course since 1999. Why? The ownership cares! They serve dishes that have had several TV and local new reviews that make this hidden gem one of the best eateries for a private romantic experience after hours. Full bar and table service by experienced waiters and waitresses, Jagray's aims to please. Their fusion menu of Soul, Asian and American is very unique. You will be very impressed and surprised of the flavors and quality of the offerings on their dinner menu. Well worth checking out.“

4.5 Superb101 Reviews
Roots Ocean Prime American • $$$
98 University Pl, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Petite Filet Mignon Cooked Rare
Shaved Brussels Sprouts Bacon
Seared Barnegat Sea Scallops
20 Oz Dry Aged Cowboy Steak
Chilled Seafood Platter
Iced Blue Point Oysters
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare
Popover Bread Pudding
Salmon with Asparagus
Layered Carrot Cake

“First I would like to acknowledge our waiter, Joshua B. He was such a pleasure and so attentive and personable. The recommendations were great and his personality was an experience in itself. The manager was also amazing and my only regret was not getting his name. Now let’s get into the food…EVERYTHING, and I mean EVERYTHING prepared was delicious. The tuna tartare and lobster bites were my absolute favorite apps. The entrees were phenomenal. I have the surf and turf and my wife had the cowboy with the lobster and cherry pepper topping and we thoroughly enjoyed it. The atmosphere was lovely and the drinks ESPECIALLY THE POMEGRANATE SPRITZ and Pomegranate Sangria …AMAZING !“

4.3 Superb94 Reviews
Elements Fine Dining
66 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Amuse-Bouche Beausoleil North Atlantic Oyster from New Brunswick Canada Caviar Trout Roe
Shrimp Dumpling in Clam Sauce Topped with Trout Roe
Summer Truffle & Wild Mushroom Buns
Japanese Wagyu
Wine Pairing

“Excellent experience. My wife and I went there as a belated Valentine's day treat for ourselves and did the 17 course tasting menu. We also sprung for the wine pairing. I think 16/17 dishes were excellent and there was only one that was "just ok". Wine pairing was excellent and pours were generous. My only advice would be to pace yourself, don't need to eat and drink everything! A little expensive but worth it for what you get.“

4.4 Superb136 Reviews
Tommys Tavern + Tap Sushi Bar • $$
3535 Brunswick Pike Suite 370, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari with Homemade Marinara and Garlic Aioli
Pulled Pork Mac and Cheese
10 Personal Classic Pizza
Warm Sticky Toffee Cake
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chocolate Lava Cake
French Onion Soup
Firecracker 50 50
Steak Sandwich
Lobster Bisque

“In Princeton for a weekend visit with friends who moved here recently and they took us to their favorite spot! It did NOT disappoint! We ate so much food!! We had lychee martinis which were ok (too limey and not enough lychee) but the food was amazing so it made up for it! They had a little bit of everything! So whatever you feel like eating, they probably have it! Or if your in a group and you all can't agree on what type of food to get, this is a good compromise: pizza, nachos, wings, sushi, burgers, salads, they literally had everything!!“

4.4 Superb120 Reviews
The Meeting House American • $$
277 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Slow Cooked Boneless Short Ribs
Crispy Rhode Island Calamari
Artisanal Mushroom Flatbread
Fried Chicken & Pancakes
Brioche French Toast
Sweet Pea Guacamole
Buttermilk Biscuits
Rotisserie Chicken
Mushroom Lasagna
French Fries

“Nice bar, their vodka martini was perfect. They have a decent selection of specialty cocktails, and everyone enjoyed the drinks. The bar area is comfortable, the patio looks like a perfect place to hang when the weather turns nice. I heard the food was good, looking forward to going back. Service is good, easy parking in the back.“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
The Dinky Bar & Kitchen Bar • $$
94 University Pl, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Bao Buns
French Onion Soup Dumplings
Dinky Maine Lobster Rolls
Margherita Flatbread
Black Bean Hummus
Flatbread Pizza
Chicken Wings
The Dinky
Slider

“This is my second visit to The Dinky Bar and Grill in Princeton which offers great views of the campus. We were going to see a play at McCarter and it is so convenient being across the street. The Dinky has an intimate vibe. Being the original Train Depot the feel of the place is still a train depot which I love. The menu is limited but certainly enough to choose from. There are shareable plates as well full entrees. Very good food and drinks. Our server Kayla was amazing. She needs to be recognized because she was extraordinary. A very busy place pre theater but Kayla never stopped smiling Great experience all around. Will definitely be going again.“

4.2 Good82 Reviews
Salt Creek Grille Steak House • $$
1 Rockingham Row, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Mesquite-Grilled Baby Back Ribs
Pear and Goat Cheese Salad
Slow-Roasted Half Chicken
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Shrimp Tempura Roll
Warm Sourdough Loaf
Ahi Tuna Sandwich
Spicy Tuna Roll
Ahi Tuna Stack
Caesar Salad

“I love this restaurant so much! I went last night with some family and we had an excellent time. Our server was fantastic and the food was incredible. I got the house salad and their delicious fries which are my favorite. I also was able to get a nonalcoholic margarita which was tasty and made my dinning experience much better. Overall this is one of my favorite places to eat, I'll definitely be back.“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
Witherspoon Grill Steak House • $$$
57 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Warm Goat Cheese Salad
Oyster Sampler Platter
Baked Five Onion Soup
Filet Mignon Tips
Mashed Potatoes
Lobster Bisque
The Witherspoon
Fried Calamari
French Fries
Rack of Lamb

“Witherspoon Grill was amazing. We were greeted by our server within seconds of sitting down. He took excellent care of us, from talking about the daily specials to ensuring our drinks were topped off. The food was simply amazing. I had the fresh caught cod with a lemon beurre blanc sauce and the house salad. 10/10 will hopefully be back soon!“

4.1 Good95 Reviews

11
Mistral

Mistral American • $$$
66 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Whole Black Bass
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Seared Diver Scallops
Grilled Bavette Steak
East Coast Oysters
Pork Belly Ramen
Szechuan Wings

“One of our “go to” restaurants/bars. Mistral offers a unique blend of American cuisine infused with a touch of ethnic flavors. I also appreciate the changes in their menus based on seasonal abundance. My favorites are the chicken wings, salmon bites and grilled kale salad.The bar area is one of my favorite local hangouts.“

4.2 Good271 Reviews
Agricola Eatery American • $$$
11 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Barnegat Bay Scallops with Garlic Sauce
Mushroom Flatbread Pizza
Lore Pumpkin Ravioli
Margherita Flatbread
Mushroom Flatbread
Short Rib Hash
Cheese Board
Shrimp Tacos
Chicken Parm
Sandwich

“Had brunch here with friends. Very cute place, and the food and drinks were tasty. The server was nice as well. Main reason for not 5 stars is that the tables are small (so takes some shuffling of plates if in a group) and are so close you overhear the conversations of every table around you, and they hear yours. Not ideal for a gossipy girl brunch or flirty dates, but otherwise we really enjoyed the experience. Would eat here again for sure - I had the scallops and they were perfectly seasoned and cooked just right.“

4.2 Good125 Reviews
Winberie's Restaurant & Bar American • $$
1 Palmer Square W, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Beer Baked Pretzel Sticks
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Cajun Mac and Cheese
French Onion Soup
Vegetarian Burger
Chicken Pot Pie
Tavern Burger
Chicken Wings
Pork Nachos

“No-frills pub with a menu of classic American food & drinks + both bar and table sections I had a great experience when I came here with my GF and my friend. All of our food was delicious and the service was great. The portions were very large as well.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
The Peacock Inn and The Perch at Peacock Inn American • $$$
20 Bayard Ln, Princeton

“This hotel is absolutely gorgeous. A short walk away from Princeton University and all of the shopping of downtown. The heated floors in the bathroom were a huge plus for this southerner. The beds were extremely comfortable, as well as the pillows. The continental breakfast was delicious, especially the blueberry muffins. While this is a boutique hotel, the prices are fairly reasonable. I would recommend staying here if you're in the area.Walkability: Located half a mile from Princeton University and downtown Princeton.Noteworthy details: Heated floors in the bathroom were a wonderful touch.“

4.2 Good82 Reviews

15
Olives

Olives Bakery • $
22 Witherspoon St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Mac and Cheese
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Breakfast Sandwich
Italian Hoagie
Mexican Salad
Chicken Salad

“Genuinely my favorite breakfast sandwich ever! Get a bacon egg and cheese w/ salsa verde & avocado... it's a game changer. Also, the Santa Fe chicken sandwich w/ chipotle mayo is incredible. Their souvlaki-style chicken is to die for. Great service every time! One of the highlights of visiting my boyfriend in Princeton.“

4.2 Good41 Reviews
Nassau diner American • $$
82 Nassau St, Princeton

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Stuffing Cranberry Open Faced Sausage Gravy
Chicken Fried Steak Country Fried Steak
Cowboy Burger with Slaw
Our Signature Pancakes
Beef Patty Burger
English Breakfast
Eggs Benedict
Avocado Toast
French Toast
Tater Tots

“Very pleasant experience. High quality food and good service. The atmosphere was very elegant for a diner. We had to wait about 10 minutes for a table since it was a busy weekend time, but they took my number and called me when the table was ready, which was very much appreciated. Would gladly go back.“

4.1 Good114 Reviews
Loading...
map Map