Paulie's Pizza and Wings

Name: Paulie's Pizza and Wings
Address: 11 Washington St, Tenafly, New Jersey, 07670, US
Telephone: (201) 567-1212
Price range: $
Rating: 2.8

$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings

Hours:
11 Washington St, Tenafly
(201) 567-1212

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

take-out

Customers' Favorites

Cheese Pizza

Paulie's Pizza and Wings Reviews

2.8 (23)

Write a review

February 2024

I've tried the other pizza places in town and haven't been impressed. Let me start by saying I don't like thick dough as my pizza crust. The other locations around town don't have flavor in the pizza sauce itself, they taste like simply crushed tomatoes out of a can. This pizza was five stars all the way around. Beautiful crisp crust and cooked perfectly on the bottom. I'm not sure where these bad reviews came from, but I met a nice lady and gentleman while there, and they were...read full review

February 2024

After trying other pizza spots in town, this is certainly my favorite. The dough was thin, but not too thin. (I hate doughy piza crust, which this town seems to enjoy). The pizza sauce was well seasoned, and it was cooked perfectly crisp. My new go-to for pizza in Tenafly. The young lady and gentlemen working were very kind as well.

December 2023

I was in town visiting dear old mom, driving all the way from The Midwest, 500 miles and 9 hours away. I grew up in Tenafly a long time ago (when the town seemingly had a lot more soul and personality than it does now), and it was a very special place back then, with a Dairy Queen, Friendly's, Charlie Brown, original Tenafly Diner, an actual movie theater, and so many more cool places that are gone now. Anywho, I tried out Paulie's for the first time, fondly remembering the classic...read full review

More Reviews(94)