31 Best Italian Restaurants near West Cape May

“We’ve been to Viggianos twice and each time the food was excellent! Last time we had the lobster ravioli and the lasagna. This time we had carbonara and the salmon dinner. Wow! We had the stuffed mushroom appetizer and ricotta cheese cake for dessert. Really enjoyed everything we ate and would highly recommend this place!“

“We have eaten many times @ this restaurant & most of the time everything was pretty good, but one of our meals Fettuccine Alfredo was not very creamy & the waiter wrung up the bill with the wrong amount $196.00 & our bill was $74.00. So you might want to shake up the troups.“

“Never dined here before. Picked it out for birthday celebration. Food was very good. The New England clam chowder was the best we've ever had and we've tried plenty through the years!! They even had key lime pie for dessert, which was also very good. Pork chop and Osso Buco were cooked perfectly. Our waitress Barbara was excellent, efficient and professional. I was wished Happy Birthday by the hostess upon arrival. When the table next to us received birthday “fireworks “ with their dessert, we mentioned to Barbara that we were also celebrating, she apologized for not knowing and brought one right out to our table!! Ambiance was nice. Prices are what you would expect to pay for a restaurant of this caliber. All in all, a nice dinner was had with plenty of leftovers. I would highly recommend Tisha's and will return.“

“Our family celebrated my husband's 60th birthday at Venezia last night. There were 16 of us. Milo went out of his way both ahead of time and that night to be sure that my husband's event was special. Milo offered us a semi-private dining area. It was very intimate and quaint and we felt like we were the only party at the venue. The food, which goes without saying, was absolutely delicious. Milo had nine appetizers ready for us, along with our wine, beer, ice, and favors set-up. Our meals were wonderful. My very favorite was the Gnocchi Sorento. The gnocchi are truly little pillows of deliciousness. I highly recommend Venezia for a romantic dinner or a larger party with your favorite people. Thank you to Milo and Venezia for a wonderful night! We will surely be back!“

“We love Santorini and eat there whenever we're in town. My favorite dish is moussaka and it's always delicious. Tonight my husband got a Caesar salad, but it tasted like the dressing had a lot of mayo in it. He also ordered gnocchi with crab, and gave it a 7 out of 10 for taste. I ordered a glass of rose wine and it was delicious! The service was very good.“

“Santorini is a real delight!! The ambience transports you to the Greek Isles while the food and drink delight your taste buds. The staff is friendly and the menu appropriately priced. It's becoming rarer and rarer to find a restaurant on the Cape the offers what it promises- most now over charge and under deliver, Santorini, however does not. Delicious!“

“Stephen’s was a Great Find for my wife and I. Everything was awesome from the friendly service to the gourmet food. My Ribeye was cooked to perfection as was my wife’s broiled seafood combo.Thankyou Steven’s for a Great Evening! We will certainly be back as regulars but next time, with family and friends. …..The Bakers“

“The food was exceptionally good. Or the ingredients of the pizza were. But the crust was like a cracker and I have had gluten free pizza at 5 placesI like that it was "gluten free" . But it was not really. True Gluten free for Celiacs has pizza or whatever in a dedicated oven.It was not. The pizza itself was Gluten free. But it was made with Glutinous pizza. My husband is Celiac and broke out. Because it was not made in a dedicated pizza oven.The parking was not free like they advertised.It was 8.00 and there was no bathroom. You had to go across the parking lot not close. But it was close to the ferry. For some reason I am not able to post pictures.“

“This place is consistently so good. The portions are huge BUT they are also extremely delicious. It is all very reasonably priced for the quality and quantity. I highly recommend Nino’s to anyone in the area. My favorite are the Taste of Italy and the house salad.“

“Great food and service highly recommend“

“Last-minute decision today decided to go sit at the bar and have a few drinks and then decided to eat. We had Clams Casino and Chicken Parm both were absolutely delicious. I’ll definitely be back. Thanks Carl for taking care of us at the bar!!“

“We bought a regular pizza with half pepperoni and a side of sauce. The food was excellent! Might be the best pizza we’ve had since we moved here in 2021. The folks were so nice and service was fast. The prices are the best we’ve seen - we paid about $16. Can’t wait to try their BBQ!“

“There is nothing like a good primo hoagie, when you are hungry. My personal favorite is the mild sharp Italian with the freshly cut cheeses and meats. It brightens up my day and fills my stomach.When I'm there I also get the sharp provolone bites because how can you not. Fresh cut and bite-sized peices of there sharp provolone adds a unique twist to a snack.“

“Had the grilled pork chop- thick and cooked perfectly, not dried out. Came with gnocci that were so light, sweet and savory, little pillows of heaven. Absolutely delicious Parking: Around 20 spots behind buildingWheelchair accessibility: In the back of the building off the parking lot“

“I live in Wildwood and I never tried this place before so me and my son are walking by and said let's grab a slice and try it if you get a slice we both bite into it together we looked at each other face and went oh my God how did we never have this before. Brought my uncle here last week we grabbed the pie first of all it was super fast super clean good service we got a pepperoni pizza it was out of this world when I tell you it's amazing take my advice always tell them make it well done cuz you want that little crush on the bottom so try it you will not regret it forget it trust me this place is where you want to go“

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

“As a pizza maker Dave Portnoy really under scored this place he gave me an 8.3 I would rate Poppi’s pizza a 7.8 I ordered all of their recommendation and was not disappointed in anyway they serve an amazing Neapolitan style pie with a great dough, and amazing sauce and delicious mozzarella“

“The Buffalo chicken pizza was delicious - it came out hot and the crust was nice and thin and crispy - just the way I like it! It's very cute inside, and it was very clean. I also decided to order fries with cheese on the side. Same thing, came out hot and fresh! Delicious! I enjoyed the cheese sauce, just the right amount of cheesiness. Our waitress seemed like a hard worker who was very attentive and helpful. My friend also enjoyed her slice, too! Check them out!“

“Long time customer. Love the service, food, atmosphere, BYOB, large portions, delicious bread!Favorites include Prime Rib, Fried Seafood Combo, Shrimp Fra Diavolo, Shrimp/ Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala, Fried Flounder, Fried Calamari.Parking is a challenge in season.“

“This is one of Cape May’s little hidden gems. There’s not a dish here that I’ve tried and didn’t like. The staff is very attentive and had some awesome recommendations. I enjoyed the unique Caesar salad that comes in a cheese bowl! The fettuccine bolognese is truly the best I’ve ever tried in my life. Of course no meal would be complete without dessert. We settled on sharing the crème brûlée and tiramisu, and it was really the cherry on top to our dinner. This place really does feel like a taste of Italy hidden away in Cape May.“

“This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.“

“Absolutely grab a hoagie from Primo! our hotel mentioned them when we arrived and we called for lunch from the beach the next day. Everything we ordered was great, especially Nonna's veggie, which I got with no cheese to make it vegan. We were a happy family for sure ?Vegetarian options: A few vegetarian options and vegans have the opportunity to have them with no dairy.Parking: easy to find in front of the shop and quick pick up“

“Omg literally the best pizza in the world , and super kind family that make you feel So welcomed !!! Highly recommend!!“

“The food is amazing, we always order too much here because it is so good. Great service and we enjoyed the bar as well. The only negative was the music being played, mostly pop hits (Ariana Grande, Tones and I, Dua Lipa). It really didn't fit the vibe. Other than that, all good.“

“I used to deliver for this place and I was very close with the head chef, who is a very passionate man when it comes to his profession as a Chef and head cook of this restaurant/kitchen side of the "Restaurant and Pizzeria." You see, there's two sets of doors for this fine establishment.Okay, technically, there are 3 sets of doors that are open to the public to enter and exit! The restaurant side doesn't open until later in the day, obviously. However, when you walk into the restaurant, it's like you've entered an entirely different place! The atmosphere is immeasurably different from that of the Pizzeria on the other side with its booths and pizza window!However, I must add that as a full-time resident of this fine town? It's not quite what it used to be. Maybe that might change since spring has picked up, and summer will be in full swing before we know it!The pizzeria is busy during all seasons! The restaurant does have an amazing N.Y. Strip Steak and a brilliant rib-eye if I'm not mistaken! Then their seafood is apparently delicious! I'm biased since I'm not big on seafood. But it does look good! All-in-all, I'd recommend trying the pizza at least once!Their specialty pizzas are good. They have a very good white cheesesteak pizza, too. Oh! Their white pizza, in general, is amazing. I used to take some home after my shift. I'm weird, though, so I'd throw some pepperoni and pineapple on it before heating the slices.This is a place you need to try for yourself to have a decent opinion. The pizza is great. They even do parties and cater to parties. I'm quite certain to an extent. Okay, I'll end here since I left a mino-novella! ?“

“Ordered food here on Christmas Eve! First thank you for being open and very friendly. Ordered a bunch of stuff White Pizza, asked for no garlic. I can't tell you how many times other places have screwed this up. These guys got it RIGHT!!! And the pizza was delicious. Chicken cutlet sandwich was awesome, my sons chicken fingers were great. Caesar salad was fine, I know the croutons weren't homemade but they were addictive. Overall great experience, and they were very nice. Thank you!“

“This place stands out amongst any pizza sandwich shops anywhere in cae may period. The pizza's are hot fresh and the way you want them. I asked for a thin crust Florence pizza that's a white pie with spinach and mozzarella and ricotta cheeses and got such fulfillment in every bite from the crispy crust to the toppingsthe spinach and plenty of ricitta and mozzarella cheeses. ..Where can you get that without saying extra cheese?? Thre service was a very humbled experience. Atmosphere was very good the staff is attentive to what you wanted and without fail ..it was a great experience I will return again soon. They aim to please here open everyday till 10pm you can't beat that anywhere. Blue moon is the best pizza anywhere ..order a hot pie and enjoy it from your first till your last bite my guest and I enjoyed the time spent , and yes they have hot drinks image that??? Yes the ocoffee & tea are hot ? .kiddos Blue moon you made a believer in me as well as my quest. We will be back sooner than you think.Don't take me word just try them out the staff will make you believe there's a better place and it's in Cape May City. 425 Beach ave....Vegetarian options: The menu don't say enough about what you can see or want in PiersonDietary restrictions: Ask them about any dietary restriction they will cater to your needs of at all possible.“

“The food was delicious.I will make a point to come back next year!“

“Did a family style dinner on 2.29.2024. It was a great time, food was delicious and the portions were very generous! The staff was friendly and accommodating too. They don't have a full bar of their own but, otherwise I'd have given them a 5 star review. However BYOB is just fine and they are able to order beer and mixed drinks from the bar next door without any issues. Recommend!“

“Very welcoming staff and good food at a good price. They keep to the express too and I have been known to drop in for a gab. Open kitchen so really good value.I run from cape may to here (they have some locations) and its a nice jaunt. Not gonna call it the best spot in town if you are a fueler but it might be the best option and hands down not even close. If you are lucky enough you might even get gone with a six pack - of cannoli! The staff mix it on the spot and the environment including their friendliness built me toward a 60 VO max, hoping for a bit higher but the canolies are tempteous to say the least as much as the folks and staff. Worst comes to worst just breeze or head on by the boardwalk location for a hopeful sighting or wiff of the sauce if you are a strict typer. of runner or athlete.“

“I love this place …. The seafood is always fresh, and anything you can add the (Jackie) sauce to I would highly recommend .Favorite appetizer there is the spicy calamariFavorite dinner is the blackened Seabass over linguine with the (Jackie) sauceAnd if you like garlic, the family style house salad is to die for“