39 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Cape May

“Ordered 6 pizzas to go. One was a pomodoro, one has mushrooms, peppers, and onions, the rest were cheese. The pomodoro was amazing. The crust was thinner than the others, the sauce is delicious, and the cook was perfectly crisp. If the rest of the pies were as thin and perfectly cooked as the pomodoro, they all would have been perfect. The cheese pies could have used more sauce and a little less cheese, but overall, they were very good. The dough is delicious and has actual flavor. I have been to too many places that don’t put salt in their dough. Probably the best pizza in the area.“

“Came from San Diego to see my son graduate from bootcamp found this little gem best fresh pizza great simple ingredients!! Yum we took a box to go! We had the margarita pizza with white sauce it has the best taste and pesto and olive oil great crust. Great service super “

“The pizza and service were amazing I would definitely recommend. Me and my friends had an amazing time here. The staff was very nice. I even went back to add more to this review because every year I have came here and they never disappoint. I’m not a fan of thin crust pizza, but this is the definite exception.“

“Great old 'dive' bar in Cape May. The kind of place that's getting harder to find these days. Really killer food. (Try the wings!!) Good service overall, reasonable prices and a friendly, "neighborhood" type vibe all make for an excellent experience. Recommended.“

“In addition to the amazing food/drinks and atmosphere, the service and staff are exceptional! We came here to celebrate my wife’s birthday and for being cancer free and the staff bought her flowers to congratulate her! Honestly, they are the sweetest people ever! Can’t wait come back!!“

“Great pizza! I have been searching for good pizza for a long time. I found it tonight. Great crust, perfect amount of cheese, pepperoni sliced to perfection!Go over to Memo’s and get a large pepperoni pizza. You will not be disappointed. And I forgot to mention, the price was right!“

“Love love love this pizza! (The top slice). I'd love it all if it was more consistent!! The guys who worked day shift at both locations seemed to do it just a little better! I like that thin crust with the hot grease dripping off much better than the thicker slice with extra sauce. But! In defense of the thicker slice with more sauce, it was a little better when we tested them both cold. I'm not trying to eat it cold, though!!“

“I just ordered my Emergency pizza and it was as good as the pizza I paid for, cause you know how some of the free foods are not as good as the ones you pay for it's like employees hate when you just order the earned food from pointsParking: During the summer months it might be difficult to find a spot but not in the off season“

“The food was exceptionally good. Or the ingredients of the pizza were. But the crust was like a cracker and I have had gluten free pizza at 5 placesI like that it was "gluten free" . But it was not really. True Gluten free for Celiacs has pizza or whatever in a dedicated oven.It was not. The pizza itself was Gluten free. But it was made with Glutinous pizza. My husband is Celiac and broke out. Because it was not made in a dedicated pizza oven.The parking was not free like they advertised.It was 8.00 and there was no bathroom. You had to go across the parking lot not close. But it was close to the ferry. For some reason I am not able to post pictures.“

“Carini's is within walking distance of our condo, so we are there all the time and also recommend it to our renters. It's delicious! There really is something for everyone. My husband got the homemade ravioli which is out of this world. There's nothing like homemade pasta. I got the chicken noodle soup which tasted like mom's. My son got the chicken caesar salad which was a giant portion. We all shared meatballs, sausage, and bruschetta - so good! The clams casino was seasoned perfectly and so tasty. We had a lot of fun. Our waitress was extremely helpful and kind. It was a home run!“

“Customer service is always very friendly.Pizza quality is pretty consistent. My go-to pizza place in the Wildwoods on and off season. Its nice they are open year round.Only ever tried the boneless wings in addition to the pizza but thought the chicken had a weird texture, almost like Burger King chicken tender texture.“

“Had the grilled pork chop- thick and cooked perfectly, not dried out. Came with gnocci that were so light, sweet and savory, little pillows of heaven. Absolutely delicious Parking: Around 20 spots behind buildingWheelchair accessibility: In the back of the building off the parking lot“

“They are very professional, very friendly. And they give you good service with a good food. It's my favorite place.Kid-friendliness: Everybody welcomes the children in there. And it's very peaceful and professional for the whole family.“

“Not a bad pizza the dough was sweet and fluffy. The cheese was just perfect. Some people might say a little on the heavy side but in my eyes was just perfect. I would order from here again. Cash only establishment which shows awesomeness and old school.“

“Been coming to the Villas since I was a kid. We have two family homes here in town. Can't believe we have never eaten here before until this past year. Prices are fair and the food is delicious. Probably the best pizza in all of Lower Twp. We will be ordering from Rino's from now on.“

“Went here for the 1st time on Monday August 7th 2023, with my family as part of our traditional yearly wildwood/Cape May, NJ Vacation. Maybe because it was a monday, but they only had like 3-5 slices of pizza to choose from, but anyways. I ordered one pepperoni slice, my dad ordered 2 cheese slices, and my mom ordered a white slice, and a slice with riccota cheese on it. Service was fast, and pizza was heated up accordingly. We ate there and sat down in a booth, which they had plenty of seating inside. Like the interesting flavors of soda, such as Fanta's Birch beer (a type of root beer), and i had a cherry coke. pizza crust was a bit crunchy, and the whole pizza was a bit crispy. it wasn't bad i liked it, but could have been better. Reasonably priced also. May be back next year to try it again!“

“I live in Wildwood and I never tried this place before so me and my son are walking by and said let's grab a slice and try it if you get a slice we both bite into it together we looked at each other face and went oh my God how did we never have this before. Brought my uncle here last week we grabbed the pie first of all it was super fast super clean good service we got a pepperoni pizza it was out of this world when I tell you it's amazing take my advice always tell them make it well done cuz you want that little crush on the bottom so try it you will not regret it forget it trust me this place is where you want to go“

“As a pizza maker Dave Portnoy really under scored this place he gave me an 8.3 I would rate Poppi’s pizza a 7.8 I ordered all of their recommendation and was not disappointed in anyway they serve an amazing Neapolitan style pie with a great dough, and amazing sauce and delicious mozzarella“

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

“A+++++!!! Excellent pizza!. I grew up in NJ, bit now live in PA. It is really heard to find great pizza where I live. Whenever I go to NY or NJ, I get pizza and it's usually good to great. Well this weekend we find ourselves in Wildwood. We heard about Mack's and gave it a shot. Wow! It's so good! The sauce, the crust, the cheese...all of it. The flavor pops. It's a NY style pizza and is done to perfection. Don't hesitate, get a slice or two....or three. Disregard any review less than 5 stars.l, this is real deal, awesome pizza.“

“The Buffalo chicken pizza was delicious - it came out hot and the crust was nice and thin and crispy - just the way I like it! It's very cute inside, and it was very clean. I also decided to order fries with cheese on the side. Same thing, came out hot and fresh! Delicious! I enjoyed the cheese sauce, just the right amount of cheesiness. Our waitress seemed like a hard worker who was very attentive and helpful. My friend also enjoyed her slice, too! Check them out!“

“Super busy and crowded. We're lucky we go there early enough to miss waiting in line. By the time we left there was a line down the block.The pizza is great and prices good for boardwalk food. The service was fast. Don't go here if you want a quiet dinner though.Kid-friendliness: There were lots of kids here having a good time.Wheelchair accessibility: You Can get a wheelchair in here. There's no step up or down.“

“My friend and I stopped in for dinner last night. The restaurant is very small. They seemed very busy,but we were on vacation so we decided to wait. Once seated,we had excellent service. The waitress was very nice and attentive. She definitely hustled. My friend ordered the bolognese and I ordered the penne alla Cecelia. Wow! The penne alla Cecelia was the best I'd ever had. Very flavorful and a large portion. The bread was good. We will definitely be back the next time we are in Wildwood!“

“Sandwiches have always been great, but the pizza had fallen off in recent years. Tried again tonight and the cheese steak was as good as ever and happy to report the pizza was very, very good. Hopefully remains consistent. If, they'll be back at the top of our list.“

“This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.“

“I've been going to Alex's for years! The location is perfect at the far end of the boardwalk. The pizza is soooo good and I love that they have a vegetarian option that's delicious! The acai bowl is the perfect option. Service is good and prices are reasonable. Summertime fave!!“

“?.. I Am Not Sure Whom The New Worker You Hired The Young Lady is very new With alot of patience and truly helpful. She indeed in from me to bare with her because she had just fairly started & I Thanked Her For That.. I WIsh That I Could Of Tipped Her For Being So helpful. Shr even gave me few suggestion On Desserts & I Ended Up Talking Me Into Getting The Lava Cakes Which Was Delicious & Filling..I was having a very hard time trying to figure out what I wanted to get For Dinner For My big family. She even smiled the whole time. Not often do you see good kind whole heartly. I'll Keep Bringing My Business Here Long As Shell Be There Or Assiting..Thank you & God Bless You Your Family & Workers“

“The food is mostly good the staff is friendly but no refills on drinks isn't as good as it could be for a place that gets enough business. . When you charge for refills you lack customer service for steady customers. Improvements needed for sure.“

“Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever eaten - and that says a lot about this place since I live in the pizza capital of the world! The sauce was amazing!!!!!! Perfect combination of cheese and sauce!! Can’t wait to come back to the shore and get it again!!“

“This place stands out amongst any pizza sandwich shops anywhere in cae may period. The pizza's are hot fresh and the way you want them. I asked for a thin crust Florence pizza that's a white pie with spinach and mozzarella and ricotta cheeses and got such fulfillment in every bite from the crispy crust to the toppingsthe spinach and plenty of ricitta and mozzarella cheeses. ..Where can you get that without saying extra cheese?? Thre service was a very humbled experience. Atmosphere was very good the staff is attentive to what you wanted and without fail ..it was a great experience I will return again soon. They aim to please here open everyday till 10pm you can't beat that anywhere. Blue moon is the best pizza anywhere ..order a hot pie and enjoy it from your first till your last bite my guest and I enjoyed the time spent , and yes they have hot drinks image that??? Yes the ocoffee & tea are hot ? .kiddos Blue moon you made a believer in me as well as my quest. We will be back sooner than you think.Don't take me word just try them out the staff will make you believe there's a better place and it's in Cape May City. 425 Beach ave....Vegetarian options: The menu don't say enough about what you can see or want in PiersonDietary restrictions: Ask them about any dietary restriction they will cater to your needs of at all possible.“

“Ordered food here on Christmas Eve! First thank you for being open and very friendly. Ordered a bunch of stuff White Pizza, asked for no garlic. I can't tell you how many times other places have screwed this up. These guys got it RIGHT!!! And the pizza was delicious. Chicken cutlet sandwich was awesome, my sons chicken fingers were great. Caesar salad was fine, I know the croutons weren't homemade but they were addictive. Overall great experience, and they were very nice. Thank you!“

“Is there anything better than a good pizza? Yes, a great one! Simply put, the thin crust at Tony's is the best! We also had the cheese ravioli, which was to die for, delicious garlic bread, and the salad that came with it was so fresh and crunchy!We were in Cape May for the day, but this was our second visit. Did the same last year. We will be back again! Not sure we want to wait another year!“

“I used to deliver for this place and I was very close with the head chef, who is a very passionate man when it comes to his profession as a Chef and head cook of this restaurant/kitchen side of the "Restaurant and Pizzeria." You see, there's two sets of doors for this fine establishment.Okay, technically, there are 3 sets of doors that are open to the public to enter and exit! The restaurant side doesn't open until later in the day, obviously. However, when you walk into the restaurant, it's like you've entered an entirely different place! The atmosphere is immeasurably different from that of the Pizzeria on the other side with its booths and pizza window!However, I must add that as a full-time resident of this fine town? It's not quite what it used to be. Maybe that might change since spring has picked up, and summer will be in full swing before we know it!The pizzeria is busy during all seasons! The restaurant does have an amazing N.Y. Strip Steak and a brilliant rib-eye if I'm not mistaken! Then their seafood is apparently delicious! I'm biased since I'm not big on seafood. But it does look good! All-in-all, I'd recommend trying the pizza at least once!Their specialty pizzas are good. They have a very good white cheesesteak pizza, too. Oh! Their white pizza, in general, is amazing. I used to take some home after my shift. I'm weird, though, so I'd throw some pepperoni and pineapple on it before heating the slices.This is a place you need to try for yourself to have a decent opinion. The pizza is great. They even do parties and cater to parties. I'm quite certain to an extent. Okay, I'll end here since I left a mino-novella! ?“

“Very friendly owner! He was so happy to great us and get us exactly what we wanted and made it to perfection! The pizza is amazing and the onion rings, shrimp and curly fries were super good! Highly recommend!Kid-friendliness: The owner was very nice to our kids loved talking to them and letting them order for themselves!“

“We find that this is the best pizza in CMCH, tasty, not oily or greasy, and they deliver pretty much on-time. Our only caveat is sometimes the specialty pizza doesn't have sauce if it doesn't explicitly say that in the description, so make sure you ask for the red sauce when you order it if that is what your expect. We assumed all pizza other than white pizza has red sauce but I guess they come from a different part of Italy.“

“The staff was very friendly and chilled. Only had time for a quick drink but the food looked awesome coming out of the kitchen. Will definitely order something to eat next time I am there. The price of the beer was very affordable. Looking forward to next visit.“

“We decided to try this hot spot for the first time this year. We have dined in the other hot spot next door for years. I found the atmosphere, service and food to be much better. The service was on point. Everything came out just the way we ordered it. The staff was very friendly and the restaurant was very clean. We will not only be returning everytime we are at the shore, but I will be recommending this hot spot to my friends who also vacation there.“

“Very welcoming staff and good food at a good price. They keep to the express too and I have been known to drop in for a gab. Open kitchen so really good value.I run from cape may to here (they have some locations) and its a nice jaunt. Not gonna call it the best spot in town if you are a fueler but it might be the best option and hands down not even close. If you are lucky enough you might even get gone with a six pack - of cannoli! The staff mix it on the spot and the environment including their friendliness built me toward a 60 VO max, hoping for a bit higher but the canolies are tempteous to say the least as much as the folks and staff. Worst comes to worst just breeze or head on by the boardwalk location for a hopeful sighting or wiff of the sauce if you are a strict typer. of runner or athlete.“

“I like this place for a long time. They make really good pizza and have specials everyday. I like the cheeseburger hoagie and french fries thats pretty good. They also deliver food which is fast and efficient! They are open all winter and fully stocked with groceries.“