10 Best American Restaurants in Baldwinsville

Angry Garlic Cocktail Bar • $
29 Oswego St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Honey Garlic BBQ Wings
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Smoke and Fire Burger
Long Stem Artichokes
Loaded Garlic Fries
Angry Garlic Bites
Angry Vodka Riggies
AG Steak Sandwich
Chicken Riggies
Grilled Chicken

“Food was good. Service was great. Atmosphere? It was small though not busy when we visited but the seating options were limited. Nothing more than a 4 Top to be seen. Chairs were uncomfortable for the shorter members of our party of 5. We'll go back though.“

4.6 Superb128 Reviews
Olives Eatery and Two Twisted Sisters American • $
25 Syracuse St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Chef's House Made French Onion Gratinee
Soup of the Day
Chicken Caesar
Mediterranean
Cole Slaw
Warm Orzo
Summer
Hummus
Salad

“The food is delicious and the staff is great. They also offer a separate outside room for private parties. You can eat on the outdoor porches under the vines with lights. It’s delightfulDietary restrictions: They offer gluten free. I’ve eaten here several times.Parking: Village street parking availableWheelchair accessibility: They have a wheel chair ramp“

4.9 Superb37 Reviews
Fireside By The River Italian • $$
2347 W Genesee Rd, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Scallops with Pork Belly

“The food was excellent! The service was slow. But all in all it was a great time!Kid-friendliness: They have a kid menu and provide child with crayons ? to color menu. High chair available. Suggest ordering child's meal if you get appetizers. The wait time was extended for adult meals.“

4.6 Superb38 Reviews
Persimmons American • $$
3536 Timber Banks Pkwy, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon and Parmesan Fries
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Shrimp and Crab Egg Roll
Crispy Chicken Milanese
Burger of the Week
Carrot Cake Slice
Sweet Potato Fries
Short Rib Tacos
Bread Pudding
Creme Brulee

“A beautiful building in a quiet remote location just a few minutes from Baldwinsville. My first visit here was for a Mardi Gras show by the Soda Ash Six. They had a special menu of cocktails, apps and mains for the show. I ordered a spicy rum cocktail to start, along with the Oyster Po Boy sandwich with fries. I asked for garlic aioli instead of ketchup for no upcharge. Everything was perfectly done. I finished with a blackberry gin based cocktail for dessert. I would easily come here again.“

4.2 Good116 Reviews
Potter's Pub Bar & Grill • $
8055 Potter Rd, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tender & Fries Basket
Sandwich
Pizza
Wings

“Nice little Pub in Baldwinsville off the beaten path. I think it's part of the golf course and is nestled back in the trees.I had a very good meal with friends. My side salad was very nice size, and fresh and delicious, way nicer than a tiny bowl of just lettuce. My (haddock) fish sandwich was quite large, perfectly fried and bonus was that it was on a brioche roll.One friend had the Reuben which she declared delicious, even though she is not a fan of sauerkraut!The other friend had the 1/2 pound burger which she also enjoyed very much.“

4.6 Superb24 Reviews
Atlantic Seafood Co Seafood • $
69 E Genesee St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Baked Macaroni and Cheese
German Potato Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Seafood Salad
Rice Pudding
Clam Chowder
Onion Rings
Fish Dinner
Scallop

“I have been going to this restaurant for years. The seafood couldn't be better!! Yesterday, I made a special trip and bought salads, five of them! They are all awesome! Better than anywhere else! Service is great, also.I would give this place 10 stars if I could!“

4.4 Superb59 Reviews
Mohegan Manor Restaurant And Banquet Facility American • $$
58 Oswego St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Half Rack Lamb Lollipop with a Chimi Churri Sauce or Naked with Potato and Vegetables
Caesar or Traditional Salad
Petite Filet Surf N Turf
Beef or Chicken Nachos
Manor Burger and Fries
Warm Mushroom Salad
Coppola Pinot Noir
Littleneck Clams
Spicy Tuna Roll
Lobster Roll

“This is a gem in Baldwinville. Sean always gets the cocktails perfectly right at the bar. The food is exceptional. The chicken dish they’re currently serving has a significant wow factor and is well worth ordering.Parking: Behind buildingKid-friendliness: Very accommodatingWheelchair accessibility: Easy from back of building“

4.2 Good56 Reviews
Average Joe's Pizza Chicken Wings • $
2119 Downer Street Rd, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Lettuce Tomato
Grilled Chicken Salad
SM Stk Philly Sub
Grilled Chicken
Homemade Chili
Julienne Salad
Boneless Wings
Sausage Pizza
SD Hot Taki
Fried Oreos

“A friend of mine told me average Joe's offered a very good haddock dinner. This Friday night I checked it out. Not the fanciest of places to dine at (or drink at) but we all know sometimes these unassuming places have darn good food. Yup. The haddock dinner I had was wonderful. It was not greasy. They did not put too much batter on the fish. The portion size was good. They give you plenty of french fries, too many? The coleslaw was a little light on portion, but good tasting. Very friendly servers. A good place to listen to live music. On this night they featured dangerous type.“

4.2 Good32 Reviews
Average Joe's Beernasium Bar • $$
2119 Downer St, Baldwinsville

“A friend of mine told me average Joe's offered a very good haddock dinner. This Friday night I checked it out. Not the fanciest of places to dine at (or drink at) but we all know sometimes these unassuming places have darn good food. Yup. The haddock dinner I had was wonderful. It was not greasy. They did not put too much batter on the fish. The portion size was good. They give you plenty of french fries, too many? The coleslaw was a little light on portion, but good tasting. Very friendly servers. A good place to listen to live music. On this night they featured dangerous type.“

4.2 Good24 Reviews
Pasta's on the Green American • $
1 Village Blvd N, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Supreme Personal Pizza Rolls
Personal Supreme Pizza Roll
Buffalo Wings

“Overall a decent place to have to grab a quick lunch. There is a few different entrances to get into the place so that was a little confusing and there is a bunch of different seating spots and event spaces inside. During our visit we ordered and the bad and that ate at one of the 4 outdoor picnics tables. Food was average, bar tender was friendly. Prices were not bad. They have quick draw at the bar and trivia during the week on I believe Tuesday and they have music during the summary on Thursday nights.“

4.1 Good41 Reviews
Loading...
map Map