31 Best Italian Restaurants near Cornwall

“I only went into the pizzaria side, not the full restaurant. But, the service was fast, the pizza was delicious and reasonably priced. All in all, a good little Italian eatery. Sometime soon I'd like to try the sit-down restaurant area.“

“We love Rosie's! The owners are just so warm and friendly. The food is always fresh and yummy. My wife loves the fried zucchini sticks and Meatball Sliders. I like everything at Rosie's. Go and enjoy an excellent meal in a classic pizza restaurant setting.“

“Both my husband and I don’t get out much these days with two small children so when we finally had a date night we wanted to try il traverna. It was absolutely beautiful inside the food was wonderful the drinks were okay. I only say that because i definitely ordered the wrong drink. Next date night we would 100% go back and recommend it for anyone to try.“

“I really enjoyed my main course and the sangria. We came here to celebrate my sister's birthday. I will say the Cesar salad was delicious and so was the tortellini Alfredo. The flavor of the Alfredo sauce was quite delicious. We had some appetizers as well which were ok. We had the mozzarella sticks but they were overly cooked; almost burned. I did not like the bruschetta; the flavor of it was not very good. The garlic bread was ok but it did not have enough garlic. My sister ordered the bolognese and it was good as well. My niece had the chicken Parmesan but she did not like it. I thought it was ok but the noodles were a bit overcooked for me. The service was good; our waitress was nice. The food was good but I think there are other place which are better. I am not sure if I would be back. If you are in the area; I do think it would be worth a stop.“

“This is a beautiful restaurant located of the Fishkill/Wapoingers border. You feel like you are in NYC and the service is always terrific, the bread is fantastic and they have one of the best pizzas in the area. For salmon fans they are really great too. Actually everything they make there is delicious. Weeknights are generally not so busy so that's when we prefer to go. They have some nice desserts too, but the entrees are what keeps us coming back. We are excited to try their Sunday brunch too. Definitely give this place a try, it's rare these days to find an affordable, high quality restaurant on Route 9.“

“They're legit good. I'm old school Bronx n I keep it simple- cheese. Their Baskin Robbins 31 flavors all looked good but a plain slice tells you the truth about a place n truth is it's good. Balance of cheese to sauce is right, that light crunch when you bite into it, light char on the bottom. Sauce is maybe a lil garlicky but that's fine by me. So all in all, a solid slice.“

“Traveling on business into Newburgh NY and found this gem on Yelp - had an amazing dinner. Our server - Ali - was knowledgeable and friendly with great service. The ambiance was old school Italy with food to match, ordered my Osso Bucco as a special item not on the menu - it was both perfect and a huge portion. If I ever come back to this area - I'll Cena'colo is a return spot for sure.“

“Classic village pizza shop! Could not ask for anything more. Pizza is great and the service is even better. Perfect place to bring kids. Secret sneaky menu item.. whatever soup they have bubbling that day. Other pizza shops come and go, but there is only one Cold Spring Pizza.“

“I was really hungry and in a rush. The pizza was wonderful and tasty. It wasn’t soft and greasy like other places around. The zapolis was a nice treat afterwards. It was made fresh at that moment nice, soft and warm. It’s a spacious clean establishment this place is a hidden gem in this community. I will certainly return and bring my family.“

“We went to Aroma to celebrate a family member's birthday. We had a large group and we made reservations ahead of time. We were seated right away when we got there in a private like room so it was nice to have the space. Our waitress was very kind and informative on what they had to offer. She was very attentive and helpful with recommendations as well. I ordered the farfalle dish with sundried tomatoes and a cream sauce and I added chicken to it. The flavor was delicious. Everyone at the table ordered different items and enjoyed what they had. I would go again.“

“Only took off 1 star because there's nothing on tap. Pizza is homemade from scratch in a proper pizza oven and DELICIOUS! Service is friendly and feels like home in the best of ways. Karaoke Thursday nights 7-10 PM, kind host and supportive, enthusiastic crowd!Parking: No spots in the small lot? Park next to the fence all along the block!“

“Found this place after some googling and the reviews seemed promising so we decided to give it a try. All of the food and drinks were absolutely delicious and the service was great. All of the staff we interacted with were wonderful.. bartender, waiters, bus boys and possibly an owner/manager were extremely nice. My toddler ended up spilling his water on the floor and even though it was embarrassing for us no one made us feel as if it were a problem or inconvenience. The ambiance was wonderful as it seemed like a place where they have a lot of regulars, so it felt homelike in the best way. We will definitely be back.. (with a spill proof sippy cup!)“

“I've lived in the area for 23 years. Pizza places have come and gone in that time without leaving an impression. Pizza and Stuff is honestly the best tasting pizza I've had in a while. I am outside their normal delivery range (have to order thru Doordash if I want delivery) but I will 1000% order from them once a week and pick it up on the way home. Their pizza tastes great and their staff are always friendly and welcoming. The storefront might be a bit small, but it's homey and comfortable. You can never go wrong ordering from these guys. I highly recommend them, even over much closer pizza parlors.Dietary restrictions: Able to accommodate gluten free and veganWheelchair accessibility: Door is directly accessible from the street level“

“I’ve been to Cilantro twice. It has mixed reviews, but I’m not one to be scared off by those. The first time I had the enchiladas de mole poblano y pollo. I try mole often because I love chocolate and the idea of it in a sauce intrigues me. Cilantro’s mole is the best I’ve ever tasted with a richness and depth of flavor I haven’t had elsewhere. My husband had the chicken taco salad and was impressed as well. They did not skimp on the chicken and it didn’t taste like Cisco chicken. Last night I had the black bean and mango salad. It was good but I ate some of it with chips as it was sweet and their salsa is sweet too. House margs are $1.50 off during happy hour - bringing them to $8.50 at the time of this review. José was attentive and my meal came quickly last night.“

“The person taking my order on the phone was very calm, polite, and helpful. There are times you can call a place and be rushed and not understand the person clearly.This was not the case.We ordered the veal parmesan eggplant deluxe. Not the first time.My husband who is picky about veal likes their veal. Was very good.The salad with the house dressing was delicious.Broccoli with garlic and olive oil again very good.Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken my husband gave a thumbs up to. ( I shared my veal)Generous portions.The order was ready when we arrived.Again, it's nice to have customer service like this taking our order.Only thing they do not offer is Caesar dressing. But, their house dressing is very good!Also, the wedge of Italian bread that came with the meal was soft and also good! Everything was packed very nicely, too.Their parking lot is constantly full and there is obviously a reason!“

“Brothers is one of our favorites, has been for 24+ years. Food is always excellent, the wait staff and guys in the kitchen are always, always so friendly and greet you with a smile.All dishes are flavorful, the atmosphere is old world charm and it's close to home for us.“

“Hands down, one of my very favorite places to eat. Food is always prepared fresh, attractively plated and plentiful. Their cheese pizza is the best in the area! The staff is welcoming, friendly and attentive; the atmosphere cozy and relaxed. Definitely worth a trip!Wheelchair accessibility: The parking area near the front entrance is small & fills quickly. I believe there is a handicapped parking space but no access isle next to it. There are additional spaces on the side of the building and around back. I've always been able to park my lift equipped van on the side of the building and get out of it without a problem. The entrance has a vestibule and getting through 2 sets of doors using a wheelchair is challenging. Once inside, there is ample space and bathrooms are accessible.“

“My family eats out often and lately have been disappointed. Mario's is a true hidden gem. TRUE Italian food, the food & drinks AMAZING ! Our server Gabby was so attentive & amaxing as well! We found a great place to enjoy food & family!“

“We had such a wonderfulTime! The pizza was amazing. We live in the Village of Montgomery and frequent someOf our local favorites but we drive the extra 3 minutes and had the best pizza! And our twin 5 year old boys we captivated watching the young man make pizza fromScratch. Our 1 boy finished his pizza and his brothers extra slice. So tasty!“

“Verdict: Delicious southern Italian restaurant with generous portions, very professional wait staff in a beautiful atmosphere. Absolutely deserving of 5 star rating. Well worth your time and money. Details below.The food here is delicious. All of us ordered some sort of chicken dish; Picatta, Francais, and Sorrentino. I had the latter. It was in a delicious sauce, tender chicken, delicious eggplant, and prosciutto. The portions are large so we all had meals for two nights.They start you out with, I'm assuming, homemade bread. It's rolled with herbs and spices. I could make a meal out of just that with olive oil! It is served with fresh butter.Next is the salad. This was the 'low part' of the meal. The lettuce was all the same with very light green and crunchy leaves. I prefer more variety among lettuces and vegetables. Their house balsamic dressing was fine, but nothing special.As I said above all the entrees were excellent and all were served with pasta and salad. We also ordered two sides of broccoli rabe and spinach. I'm a huge fan of broccoli rabe and this was perhaps the best I've had anywhere.For dessert we had chocolate lava cake and lemon sorbet. I had the lemon sorbet. I prefer a much more lemony flavor than this sorbet had. The report on the chocolate lava cake was that it was fine but nothing special.The atmosphere is high end, but cozy. Very nice brick walls lined with bottles of wine. White tablecloths. Quiet and comfortable.This wouldn't be complete without a shout out to the wait staff. All very professional, well dressed and polite.“

“Hands down the best pizza in the area. I have been coming here since I was in High School. My family and I eat here or order from here weekly. Not only is the food amazing but they are great members of our community. Both of my daughters have had "Pizza making" field trips and loved learning how pizza is made. The owners took their time to open early, work with the kids and provide them with an awesome experience that they look forward to yearly. I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant. Whether you want a quick slice or a full meal, you can't go wrong.“

“I grew up eating here and I still haven’t found a pizza place to match. The owners and their family run this place and it’s always such a joy to spot them there. This place makes the best Sicilian pies I’ve ever had! They feed the whole family. If you ever have a chance to stop by you should. It’ll be worth it!“

“The pizza is phenomenal and the service is pretty good. They're on time with their estimates and the prices are good too. The atmosphere feels more like a grab and go, I wouldn't stay in the restaurant too long because the kids can be pretty rowdy.Vegetarian options: It's a pizza place with good pizza.“

“Delicious and Intimate. A gem hidden in a cozy building near the bandstand in Cornwall on Hudson. Municipal parking is ample and the food and service are perfection. I had the branzino on risotto, and tasted my companion's grilled salmon with the best capers. I also had a bite of the chicken Marsala made with sweet Marsala wine. All of the food was amazing. And although the restaurant was at capacity, we never felt rushed. Wonderful special occasion night out. The outside dining in the summer is also a treat.“

“Delicious...delicious...delicious. I really enjoy the food here. Everything is freshly made and tastes great, A cool spot to enjoy a meal and the service is top notch! One side is a pizzeria with seating. The other side is a bar with a section with tables at the back of the restaurant. I have been here many times and it never disappoints.“

“Beautiful, rustic, cozy place! Service is ultra warm and professional. Food was excellent. Had the polpette and buratta ravioli. I must say I do not think it was stuffed w burrata as it tasted and appeared to be regular cheese filling but everything was delicious nonetheless! Olive oil w the bread was good! And the creme Brule cheesecake was awesome, not too sweet. Excellent experience all around. I'd give my server 10 stars if I could ✨️“

“Since their opening, Sapore has been a hidden gem of delicious, unfussy Italian inspired fare with excellent, personable service in a handsomely decorated, warm atmosphere.There's no reason to schlep to NY when you're craving dry aged steaks with Sapore in the heart of Fishkill.Kid-friendliness: They're friendly with kids“

“Late ⏰ review but overall the pizza ? was amazing visited here about a month ago. Restaurant was closed but there is a food truck they have outdoors that sells the best chicken and slices. So we had to eat in the car. The atmosphere was great and a nice vibe in the area will surely keep you comfy with scenery to enjoy your food. Thank you ☺️“

“ABC is a great local place that we frequent every once in a while with friends for low-key, informal dinner. The service is always great and the food is well-portioned, made fresh and a good value for the price. The atmosphere is "dated pizza place/diner" but there is a separate dining room and plenty of tables and booths. Comfortable, clean but far from fancy. They serve beer and wine at a reasonable price too...so that's a plus! It doesn't look like much from the outside but you won't be disappointed once you go in!“

“Nice place which seems to have reliable Italian food. For someone just passing through it was a good place to stop. We had 4 main courses and were all fine. The Nona pasta with smashed meatballs listed on the menu just had sliced meatballs which was quite disappointing.Nice modern interior and very good service.“

“We planned my sister's bachelorette brunch here and the staff was amazing. It was easy to book and order ahead and when we were running late, they were very accommodating. They were able to accommodate all our allergies and all 20+ girls all said they loved the food, the atmosphere and the drinks! Thank you again to Michelle for all your help.“