20 Best Ice Cream Shops near Henrietta

“A group of 10 of us (6 adults 4children) stopped in for a quick dinner. There was very short line. We were able to order quickly. We ordered 1 pizza for every 2 of us (that's 5 pizzas), along with 2 orders of wings. The pizzas were done very quickly and everyone liked their pizza and the wings. We then had a scoop of hard ice cream each and it too was delicious. The staff were all very feiendly. We all really enjoyed this place and will definitely be back whenever in the area. Highly recommend.“

“Lots of ice cream and custard options! They have an indoor counter as well as ordering window. They have many flavors that can be mixed into the custard. The staff unfortunately wasn't particularly helpful answering questions as a first time guest. The menu prices also were not what was reflected on my receipt (Reg custard listed as $4, charged $4.50 + .75 for sprinkles. Reg HF sundae listed as $5.30, charged $6.80 + .75 for nuts).Otherwise the ice cream was delicious!“

“Great neighborhood cafe, owners & staff are so pleasant. Baked goods, breakfast sandwichs, yogurts & so much more make for a great time. Food trucks on Wednesdays in the summer along with their ice cream, make it a nice place to gather and meet neighbors.“

“Really good ice cream with very unique flavors. They focus on quality over quantity, and it shows. Tip: check new flavors on their instagram because they frequently run unique flavors for a short time, such as collaborations during local festivals.“

“Scoop n' Twist in Brighton is an absolute gem! This family-run establishment goes above and beyond to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. With their delightful flavors and friendly service, Scoop n' Twist is a welcome addition to the community. And let's be real, who can resist indulging in ice cream year-round? It's a win-win situation! If you haven't checked them out yet, you're seriously missing out. Go treat yourself ASAP!Kid-friendliness: Scoop n' Twist in Brighton isn't just about delicious ice cream – it's also incredibly kid-friendly! With a welcoming atmosphere and a variety of flavors to choose from, kids of all ages will have a blast picking out their favorite treats. Plus, the friendly staff are always ready to make their experience extra special. Whether it's a family outing or a birthday celebration, Scoop n' Twist is the perfect place to create sweet memories with your little ones.“

“Lugia's is a great business! I have worked with them twice now booking an Ice Cream Truck. Their employees are kind and reliable and go above in beyond to serve their customers. I would highly recommend booking with Lugia's for an ice cream truck - not only do they have awesome flavors, they have friendly and timely staff! Thank you Lugia's!!“

“Love everything about it. Except that it is kind of difficult to find the price of goods in the refrigerator section ? ?. No price tag on the goods or on side or below the goods. So it's difficult to shop, when you don't know how much your paying for??? I only found out that the English claim chowder soup was $10.49 after purchase and have to ask for the receipts ? ? ?. I got to say that all food is delicious but on higher end prices.“

“The store keeper was really nice and friendly. The vanilla and pumpkin custard was really creamy, rich but not too sweet.Vegetarian options: The frozen custard options are made with egg/dairy so it's good for lacto-ovo vegetarians. There are also vegan options as well.“

“I love that they are open year round. you want ice cream or an ice cream cake, you can go get some. doesn't have to be sunny and warm, pick a day and you can go. I'm a long term customer that has been going since I was very small. Love the variety of ice cream, even other types of frozen desserts. Go check them out“

“The hype is real. Was traveling through the area and decided to stop, we don’t have this back home! Absolutely delicious thick, soft, warm, flavorful cookies! Chocolate chip has always been my favorite- theirs is so good.Prices are high, but it’s worth it for what you get!“

“A great place in an unlikely spot: an old Abbott's in a plaza that has seen better days. Lovely people and good food. We found them because our regular spot for safe gluten-free food was temporarily closed and we just keep going back. They have gluten-free pastries including apple fritters--a must try! Would love to see more vegetarian options show up, but they are very agreeable and understanding if you request light cheese or no cheese. The regular pizzas are also amazing; really good sauce and crust. Highly recommended.“

“I have been to Rita's many times and I love it! The inside has a small amount of seating, but we've always managed to get a seat. The service here is great and super quick even where there's a long line. The Italian Ice is always delicious and I love the rotating menu!“

“Had to wait 10 minutes to get in because the employee was on break. However, I was visiting from Buffalo and I'm a big fan of Perry's ice cream but this place might have them beat. The butterscotch chip ice cream was phenomenal and so was the lemon bar. My significant other loved her red velvet cheesecake and ice cream as well. Definitely will be returning soon ☺️“

“Just had a birthday party there on a Saturday afternoon, and we all had a fun tasty time. Great price to have yogurt cups for all, goodie bags, a fun whip cream game and a special gift for the birthday girl. All enjoyed it and we'll be coming back for sure. The staff were so friendly and accommodating to us. We all had a nice fun time.Dietary restrictions: Had Gluten Free Dole Whip“

“Stopped in on a Sunday evening for a treat with toddler, parents and grandparents. Great variety of ice cream flavors plus sorbet and Italian ice. Clean premises and tables. Inside staff were friendly and seemed to be having fun. First time visiting. We will be back.“

“The flavors are limited but we chose the flavor of the day, peanut butter brownie cheesecake. It was delicious! Very smooth. The waffle cone is huge! Piece of advice: Order the regular size as the portions are generous. The store is clean and bright. The two young women working were pleasant but a bit slow so expect to wait a bit if there is a line. Will definitely return.“

“Abbott's is a western New York classic. The custard is fantastic, there are plenty of creamy options to choose from and they they had prompt customer service in spite of a continuous line of customers. I will be back again (and again and again).“

“Delicious homemade frozen custard. We had large servings for our single scoop cones. Nice variety of flavors to choose from which a couple changing daily. We had prompt friendly service. Samples available to taste first. Pints, cakes and other frozen novelties available. Drive thru window at this location. Milk shakes, sundaes, and a variety of toppings are on the menu too. Restaurant was cleaned. Large parking lot in front, picnic tables outside and a few tables inside for seating. Order at counter.“

“This is the first coffee shop I've visited that actually uses the Japanese tea ceremony green tea whisk to stir up the REAL green tea powder to make matcha latte! Other major coffee businesses use premixed powder with sugar already added. I'm a Japanese and I'm very impressed with the quality of the green tea. The people are very attentive. I also learned that this is a woman- owned business. There is a side room where we can have a small receptions and gatherings. Southbridge definitely I'll be back!Dietary restrictions: Matcha latte with almond milk and oat milk were fantastic!“

“The pizza at this pizzeria is the perfect expression of taste! Each slice of pizza has a crisp golden rim and is covered with fresh, colorful toppings. The cheese is rich, the drawing is long and satisfying, and you can taste the rich milk aroma and rich texture in every bite. The flavor of the sauce is just right, neither too strong nor too light, and it blends perfectly with the ingredients on the bottom and top of the pizza. Not only that, the restaurant's pizza selection is diverse, whether it is the classic Margarita or innovative flavor combinations, to meet the needs of different customers. Sincerely recommend to all pizza lovers!“