Custom Cakes near Massapequa Park, NY

Vin’s Bake House Bakery • $
1030 Park Blvd, Massapequa Park

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Cookie House
Wedding Cake
Cakes

“Vins is a great mom and pop bakery owned by the same family that owned the best ever bakery. A few years back, the son vin took over and vamped it up a little.They offer some delicious cakes, pasties, and baked goods. The seven layer and mouse cakes are our favorite.They also have some great coffee at a nice price.They have monthly specials that feature certain cakes, loafs, and coffee.Everyone who works here is super nice and helpful.Overall, it's a nice wholesome bakery to try if you're in the area.“

4.4 Superb29 Reviews
Bread in Oven Bakery •
13 W Marie St, Hicksville - 6.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tower Wedding Cake with Fresh
Fresh Flower Wedding Cake
Customized Birthday Cake
Customized Theme Cake
Gulab Jamun Pastry
Butter Cream Cake
Dried Fruits Cake
Mango Mousse Cup
Rasmalai Pastry
Customized Cake

“I place an order over the phone, last minute only one day before. And I don’t regret anything, is the best eggless cake I ever tasted. It was yummy and perfect portion still have some left. Can’t wait to try other flavors. We got black frost. ?“

4.9 Superb53 Reviews
Old Fashioned Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1025 Straight Path, West Babylon - 5.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Ice Cream Cones
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream
Gourmet Ice Cream
Fudge Sundae
Hot Fudge
Cake

“Great little local ice cream shop! We stopped in on an unseasonably hot October day to get cones. Rainbow sherbet and chocolate chocolate chip both hit the spot.Good value for the cones and the ice cream was good. One thing I wish they had would be tables or benches.Kid-friendliness: A very kid friendly establishment, although there’s no customer bathroom inside or seating.“

4.8 Superb69 Reviews
Pure Sugar, Inc Patisserie/Cake Shop • $$
5 Broadway, Amityville - 2.13 miles

“After he created an awesome cake for my son’s birthday, I went back to Michael at Pure Sugar to order a custom cake for party my Union’s local threw for our members. The cake was gorgeous, all night long people took pictures of the cake. In addition to being beautiful, it was absolutely delicious. Many guests commented that the cake tasted even better than it looked. Pure Sugar exceeded our expectations and we will definitely be back for more!!!“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes) Custom Cakes • $$
12 Grossman St, Melville - 8.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Cupcakes

“I ordered a Barbie themed cake and gluten free cupcakes for my daughter's 5th bday and the flavors were incredible! The Barbie cake was strawberry cake with strawberry buttercream filling with vanilla frosting while the gluten-free cupcakes, which I refuse to share with anyone, were a chocolate cupcake with cannoli filling and almond frosting. My family are so happy there are leftovers. Highly recommend for any special occasion!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
6

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
392-A N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage - 4.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“Carvel ice cream cakes bring out the childhood nostalgia in me!I did not spend much time in store but the older gentleman who attended to me was super helpful. He made suggestions for best results before serving and offered to decorate the cake further for us.The cake was as I remembered and I was transported back to my childhood and savoured each mouthful.Carvel has my heart!“

4.9 Superb12 Reviews
Baked by Emily Rose Bakery •
518 Broadway Suite B, Massapequa - 0.78 miles

“Emily did an outstanding job making cookies in the shape of sailboats for my daughter n laws baby shower. Not only did the cookies resemble the sailboat on the invitations they also tasted delicious. Emily was so helpful and answering all my questions. I would definitely use her again for any bakery needs in the future. Thank you“

5 Superb10 Reviews
The Dot Cakes by OBFC Custom Cakes •
25 B Post Ave, Westbury - 8.4 miles

“These cakes are beautiful!!! The cake is so delicious and moist. The red velvet is the best!!! I've had all the flavors and they are amazing!!! It travels easy and the service I've received is superior! You will not be disappointed!!! It's now a family favorite that everyone asks me for!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free egg free dairy free“

4.9 Superb11 Reviews
Sweet Karma Desserts Custom Cakes • $$
136 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview - 7.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Bakery

“Brian designed our dream cake for our October Friday the 13th wedding. We went in with some ideas, bits and pieces from multiple photos and what was created blew our minds. Everyone was speechless when it came out. Aside from the delicious taste of the cake itself the details and time that was poured into it is one that we truly appreciate and love. We been to the shop multiple times before the wedding just to grab some goodies because everything is tasty and above the typical/traditional desserts you’d expect. Highly recommended bakery for sure.“

4.4 Superb52 Reviews
Moscato Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $
546 Stewart Ave, Bethpage - 4.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesecake
Cupcake

“Stopped in today for some dessert after a quick, casual dinner in town. Lots of choices of cookies, pastries and cakes.We ordered a Yellow cake with chocolate frosting that was very good. They also offered to customize a message on the cake.Fresh and the icing was not too sweet.Friendly service, Clean.We would stop by again when craving some fresh baked cake, YUM.“

4.3 Superb42 Reviews
A & G Bakery Bakery • $$
1350 Deer Pk Ave #26, North Babylon - 8.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake
New Cake

“This was my second visit to this adorable shop. The displays are always filled with delightful treats and an amazing variety. Last time, we sampled one of each of their macarons. Perfection. From the feet on the macarons to the light but flavorful fillings, we knew we had to return for more treats. This visit the macaron shelf was filled with small individual cakes. We could not resist. We tried the carrot cake and red velvet cakes and I opted for a black and white cookie as well. Service was fast and the ladies at this shop are very amicable. I appreciate and value good service and this location is top notch. The store is clean and they have a drink station also. We will most definitely be coming back again. I just have to try the spritz cookies. I would like to perhaps get an assortment to try one of each.“

4.2 Good45 Reviews
12

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
301A Bedford Ave, Bellmore - 3.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Serve Ice Cream
Flying Saucers
Birthday Cake

“I had the best experience at Carvel today! My server-extraordinare Jessica gave me world-class service and kindly helped me pick out the perfect Fudgy the Whale cake! Def coming back! Her boss Amanda was stellar as well! Best Carvel in Nassau!“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
Capri Bakery Bakery • $
3434 Merrick Rd, Seaford - 2.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Cookies
Tiramisu Cake
Cakes

“Best bakery I have found in years. A dying breed in the city, and a jewel on the island. Friendly, engaging staff and a wonderful fragrance greet you upon entering. Large variety of delicious cakes, pastries, cookies and rolls. All tied up in a box with that same string. Most delicious black and white cookies I have tasted. Wonderful place.Parking: Parking is not an issueKid-friendliness: Very friendly“

4 Good38 Reviews
Spiga Bakery Bakery • $$
2680 Merrick Rd, Bellmore - 3.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Assortment of Cookies
Maple Bacon Doughnut
Homemade Doughnut
Blueberry Glazed
Cakes and Cakes
Pizza and Pastry
Assorted Donuts
Pepperoni Pizza
Chocolate Cake
Chicken Panini

“Went here with my daughter for a rainy day cappuccino. The original place we wanted to go to had an open yet. Spiga Bakery is cute and stylish. It's a bakery (with loaves made in house) and sells real bakery goods, and even pizza. Would definitely return there. I only wish I had real cups and saucers rather than just to-go cups. The lack of ceramic cups gave the bakery a fast food feel, but would still revisit the location.“

3.9 Good68 Reviews
The Ultimate Bakery Bakery • $$$
North Babylon - 8.15 miles

“Stopped here to get a St. Joseph pastry and ask the young lady behind the counter to give me two pignoli cookies. Unfortunately by the time I got home the pignoli cookies were in 100 pieces don’t know why they gave me such scary looking cookies I did not ask for anything for free the other quality of the pastries that I purchased were fantastic, especially the St. Joseph’s Day cannoli cream filled pastry so far is my favorite But the pignoli cookies were disappointing when I got home to give to my mom and they were all broken apart. I’m sure the owners don’t want people to leave negative feedback, or for the quality of the products that are to be enjoyed or to always be top-notch I’ll be back in the future they’ll take a little more pride in what they’re selling“

3.6 Good18 Reviews