Ice Cream Shops in Montauk

“I love the small town, beachy, nostalgic feel of John's Drive-In. I stopped here with a friend after climbing the lighthouse, strolling the beach, and shopping the town. The food hit the spot! It was a sunny winter afternoon, so we ate at one of the tables outside as the day began to wind down. It's now my go-to Montauk restaurant for a casual bite to eat. Highly recommend for the food and the feels.“

“I recommend Everything!! They didn’t only have every ice imaginable, they also had Churro Ice cream sandwiches, Mini Donuts, Nutella shots!!! My kids Had the best time in there, they did not want to leave!!! The Girls who worked there were so nice also!!! I’ll Def be back tomorrow!!“