50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Setauket East Setauket

“I’ve done the “One Bite” tour around Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Long Island—I’ve gone to the hole-in-the-wall word-of-mouthers, too. Vincent’s Pizza Truck is undoubtedly up there with the best of them. The plain pie is perfectly dressed; the crust, thoughtfully caramelized with the right hint of char. Expect a crisp bite with great chew and the right balance of sauce to cheese to top a pie as thin as these. Do not skip out on an opportunity to eat here. The staff is always friendly and well-spirited, really rounding out the experience as a whole.“

“Tons of different pizza choices and options, we love coming here for a quick slice. Very friendly service and typical pizza shop atmosphere that's comfortable and inviting. Plenty of options from pizza to pasta, dishes, and salads. Overall great local place we will keep returning to!Vegetarian options: PlentyDietary restrictions: OptionsParking: Free parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Kid-friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Ramp, first floor.“

“If you need to plan a party then look no further. I was looking at several Italian restaurants for a surprise birthday party for my husband. Did not feel comfortable with what the others were offering for the prices they were charging and then I looked into Setauket Pastaria. After all I always ordered my take out food from there and the food is always excellent. So I sat down with Elena. She went over everything with me and decided to book my party of 20 guests there. The pricing was quite fair. I touched base with Elena several times beforehand and she always assured me that everything will be fine. Well, all my guests had an excellent time. I knew the party would be good but I was not expecting EXCEPTIONAL! The food was outstanding as well as the service provided by Elena and Yuresky who were our servers and went above and beyond to cater to all of my guests needs. One of my guests has Celiac Disease and needed her food made Gluten Free. No problem. In fact my guest told me that they definitely prepared her gluten free food correctly because she had no stomach issues the next day. Every one of my guests were given the gold star treatment. Elena went out of her way to accommodate everyone’s needs and preferences. The chefs did an amazing job. My guests were texting and calling me days after telling me how wonderful the party was and specifically mentioned the food and service. In addition I just wanted to add that whenever I come in for my take out order I am always greeted by the friendly faces of Collin and Jhendili (we call him “Jen” for short). They give the gold star treatment on the take out end. Thank you Setauket Pastaria!!!! You are the BEST!!!!“

“Picked up a Too Good To Go order at the end of the night. Honestly one of the best grandma slices I've ever tried. Your sauce is delicious and very flavorful. Thanks for being part of the app and offering such a large variety of pizza.“

“My first wife and I were in the mood for some great “slices” for a casual dinner after we had developed quite an appetite after our latest sweaty “reconciliation” session.Maria’s was highly recommended by some of the locals who know where to get “great” and affordable pizza out in this neck of Long Island.Jackie staffed the counter and Leo was manning the ovens that evening.The food was great! We both ended having a slice of the BBQ pizza as well as a slice of the Buffalo Chicken pizza. Two slices was plenty and super affordable and it only took minutes to reheat from the extensive display of pizza options.For a little sweetness, we also ordered two of the yummy chocolate-covered, home made doughnuts.Although we could have dined there, the place is clearly more of a take out place, rather than a fine dining establishment.Feasting on pizza and donuts from Maria’s was THE perfect way to celebrate our successful reconnection before we both collapsed into a deep, satisfying sleep.Highly recommended!! Although we live far away, we will be back — probably with our newborn twins!.“

“Picked up Three pies two hero’s the price is great. we ordered three different types deep dish. Thin. Crust and regular pie with meatballs five stars the meat balls really made the pie.“

“Mr. Joey, Kim, and Mike are an awesome team putting out some of the best Italian delicacies on the North Shore. Joey goes out of his way to make you and your family welcome and at home.“

“First time at Linda's & was greeted right away. I had margarita slice which was very good. My husband had a square slice which he said was good. The regular slices didnt look appetizing at all but maybe everyone else ordered a specialty slice so they were out there too long? I choose my slice by the look of freshness. Limited inside seating. There are tables/benches across the street with beautiful views but it was pretty windy so we sat inside. There is a variety of food if you dont want pizza. We will come back again and maybe try a panini or a salad? They also have fish & soup if you dont want pizza“

“amazing pizza alot of variety so nice the owners and staff who work there they always remember me and i love their rice balls and now calzone their desserts are amazing too make sure to try them and all their specials you can also get points for reward this is the best pizza place in neighborhood love it“

“Loved this place, first time trying NY pizza, I was standing in line off to the side and asked one of the customers if they tried this chicken pie with mozzarella cheese, she looks at me and says, Everything is good here! And it was, ordered a few pies, tipped the guy and he brings me garlic bread as a free side! Very nice ppl here.“

“I love this pizzeria the staff is always friendly, place is always clean. The food is delicious and you cannot beat their light and airy garlic knots, and specialty pizza slices. Wish the young owner lots of luck and everyone should definitely give this place a try.“

“We’ve ordered through uber eats twice and have been so happy every time! The margarita pizza and the vodka pie are both great.I was prompted to review with 5 stars because i ordered a ginger ale, and they didnt have any. Not only did they read the order instructions and replace it with a sprite, they also left an apology note on my drink! They not only have stellar food, but they clearly have great people working for them too.“

“Best Pizza I have had since moving back to Long Island from Florida. The reg pizza was baked to perfection and the specialty slice I had was just as good. I found my new Pizza spot, I have to try every variety of slices they stock. Thanks for a great experience“

“Love their food. Just not happy with the pizza“

“I am beyond impressed. I have traveled all over long island to find the best pizza. Sal Anthony’s tops all other pizzeria’s. The sauce, incredible. The cheese incredible. The crust, incredible. Love the pizza as well as the people. Great environment and place overall.“

“Recently visited with friends for lunch. Table service was excellent with server explaining the specials along with recommendations on the basic menu items. Dining area was clean and overall ambiance simple but appealing. Ordered the chicken roll which they specifically cooked for me and a vegetable which were cooked to perfection. Overall service was great. Server checked up on us multiple times and we felt right at home, not rushed at all. Restaurant located on the main road but entrance and parking are behind the strip center off Hawkins.“

“Have been a regular at Branchinelli for years. Food is always great. Service is good. Even when there is a line to wait, you are called within a reasonable time. Would recommend to everyone. If it is just Pizza, full meal or catering, can't go wrong“

“great burgers and super friendly staff“

“Amazing pizzas! The sweet chilli chicken was great, the fries are soooo crispy, and it comes out pretty quick. We were here about a month ago for work in the area and it was so good we wanted to come back to enjoy it again. Both time everything was delicious. Keep it up!“

“We're from Ohio and ended up in the area for a car. The dealership asked us if we'd ever had New York style pizza - nope! So they eagerly gave us a couple slices of cheese pizza they ordered for lunch and it was so good I asked where it came from, they said St. James Pizza. After we got done with the car deal this was the first place we stopped and got 2 larges to eat on the way home. That was on St. Paddy's Day weekend and here I am STILL thinkin about how good the pizza was. Excellent!!“

“I came in there over the summer with my wife and my grandson, Gerald. We were greeted by a young lady by the name of Brooke. Let me tell ya, she was a wonderful waitress to mi familia y yo! She brightened up out dinner experience and made the whole restaurant glow with positivity. I have never experienced such amazing service in my 73 years of life. I especially want to thank her for being nice to my grandson. he has severe autism and she was just a doll! She even sang him happy birthday (he was turnin 7). I tell ya what, if I hadn't lost so much money to these darn taxes, I would've left a $100 tip for this sweet girl. PLEASE give miss Brooke a nice raise. And give her my best wishes. Hugs & Kisses, -Rupert, Gerald and family <3“

“My favorite local pizza place! Pizza is always cooked perfectly and never had an issue here. Their sauce is delicious and it goes great with a calzone or garlic knot. The staff treats you like family and cares about the quality of their food. Will be coming back for years!“

“This place was great! Had a party to attend there, the food came out family style, appetizers were crispy and fresh, Caesar Salad, Fried Calamari, Mozzarella sticks, baked clams, fried Zucchini. Then lunch choices, Shrimp Scampi, Eggplant Rollatini & Chicken Piccata. Everything brought out was so delicious and well done, the pasta was not overcooked, the sauce was savory. I would recommend this place to anyone who was looking for a delicious meal at reasonable price!“

“WOW!! I have not seen a deli or food store this clean in ages! There is a full deli for sandwiches and a large section of hot food. The personnel are friendly and the food is delicious!! We ordered chicken and a side of rice, which is full of vegetables and chicken, and an empanada. The owner even gave us a slice of pizza to try as we were talking about how the Google reviews are great and that is what brought us to this deli. The pizza is delicious-- better than some pizzerias in the area! They have their own delivery services, so get on the web to order or check it out in person! I do not think you will be disappointed.Wheelchair accessibility: there seem to be no accessibility issues“

“So friendly! So nice! Open late and delicious food!!! Something for everyone. Tonight we had everything delivered and I'm so glad!!! We had pizza, knots, the BEST mozzarella sticks, a yummy Greek salad, delicious spanakopita, and baked clams. Everything came nice and hot. Perfect Sunday night dinner for a late night with the family.“

“I stopped in for a few slices after seeing my doctor, who is next door, and I am glad I did! The pizza not only looks delicious, it is insanely delicious! It's some of the best pizza I have had on Long Island! (and I have had a lot, haha). This place is under new ownership, and the owner is so nice you can tell he really cares about the customer experience and delivering amazing food and quality! Also, given what prices for slices lately have been, the fact that you get such large slices at such fair prices for such good pizza is really nice. I highly recommend this place for great slices, and I am sure the rest of the food is great, too. I will try it soon.“

“Love the food. Service and atmosphere.“

“Happened upon this restaurant while visiting Port Jefferson. And glad we did. Got here early enough that we could get a table right away. Steve took great care of us without being overbearing. We started off with the stuffed mushrooms, which were so freaking good. For main course my husband got the Chicken & Sausage Scarpiello, and I had the Veal Scallopini - both were delicious. We finished off sharing the Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake. This exceeded my expectations. Everything was so good that my husband wants to go back tomorrow!“

“The cheese pizza is always good, the knots here are unique bowtie shaped dough, always soft and oily and my overall favorite knots on long Island. I've yet to meet a staff member that I didn't think was excellent and personable. Branchinelli's is my miller place go-to pizzeria.“

“The pizza is just deliciously perfect. I had a regular slice, garlic knots & a slice with mushrooms & onions. The dough is perfectly crispy, no grease dripping off your slice, soooo good, the sauce is delicious, I love that it's not acidic. Cooked right. The garlic knots... soooo good. I could just sit and eat the garlic knots. ? Colosseo only serves pizza and a few other things. It's not a place to sit and have pasta. The menu is small, but if you just want delicious pizza, you won't be disappointed.“

“Every good service and great food“

“I love an old school pizzeria vibe that follows through from owner to slice perfection...and this place has it in spades! From the owner, who knows his pizza, but who also remembers you as a person not just your business and makes you feel like family (hes essentially a bartender but with pizza) to the slices...speaking of which, the grandma slice is amazing, the sauce is my Italian soulmate. If you love garlic the way any sane person should, you need to try it. The grandma Ala vodka is soooo good too. I whole heartedly recommend trying a slice here , but definitely do yourself a favor and try the grandma. That's not to knock the rest, but it's just next level, a thing of absolute beauty to sink your teeth into. He should have named it pizza haven, because there are days and times that a slice here rescues me and calms me down...just saying. Deliciousness.“

“We catered our small home wedding this weekend from Gianna's. Food trays were hot ..great temperature.. and Delicious! The trays were full to capacity. Salad and bread..also great quantity, came with our order. Everyone raved on the food. We will definitly use them again and again. Thanks for helping make our day great!“

“I just have to say this place is amazing,everything so far I've gotten has just been delish and the prices are just amazing, you truly get what you pay for,not like all they other restaurants that make prices higher and the quality of food definitely doesn't match,matches both quality and quantity. This place reminds me of the pizzeria I had as a kid. So good!,and the people that work that are just as nice.“

“Great service, delicious food!“

“We had our food catered by Giorgio’s this past weekend and it was AMAZING! Steve is very nice and worked well with us adjusting some things on the menu to fit our needs very accommodating! Delivery was on time and he helped us set it all up too. Very genuine guy running a great place 10/10 recommend and we can’t wait to work with him again!“

“We moved to the area 1.5 years ago from more Western Suffolk and have been disappointed in the quality of all the pizza places by us until we found this GEM. By far the best pizza and Italian dishes in our area but arguably on the island. We are so grateful to have found this spot and have tried multiple pies now, and different entrees and heros and everything has been phenomenal. On top of that, their prices are extremely reasonable especially for the quality and quantity. We will be ordering here until the end of time!“

“I got delivery food came nice quick have to say the delivery person was so cautious with my food and I was very thankful for that because when I opened the boxes it looked great definitely handled with care.Got a chicken Parmesan pie this was delicious the slices are normal not too big or too small had the right amount of cheese & sauce. I had to try the pepperoni pin wheel one of the best I have tried.The buffalo chicken garlic knots and the cheesy garlic knots where delish.“

“Cute theme inside, very clean, and the staff is friendly and helpful. Their plain slice was really yummy and crisp. I'm impressed by the unique selection of specialty slices. I've never been to place that offers chicken & waffles, hot honey pepperoni, among other unique combinations. I ordered a buffalo chicken slice and there was a perfect ratio of chicken, buffalo sauce & ranch. I look forward to returning to try more slices!“

“I stopped at Lorenzos Pizza for the 1st time today. The pizza is fantastic and gets the full 5 stars.The middleaged gentleman working counter, however should get 1 million stars.Someone in my car got sick as we pulled up to park, and left a little mess infront of the store, and may need urgent care.I went in and told him what was happening, and asked if he had a bucket, so I can clean it.He did not blink an eye, and insisted I take care of my matters, and he would clean it.He offered me towels, napkins, whatever I needed.His only concern, was for me to attend to ourself, and he would do the rest.I travel to St. James 2x per week for the unforseeable future, and I will be stopping in for lunch frequently.SIR, I didnt get your name, but I cant thank you enough.You are a model of what every human should be like.Thank you“

“The food is delicious. It quckly became my go-to for a freshly made meal.Dietary restrictions: They always accommodate my diet needs. The foods I usually order aren't listed but delicious. I've dined in, got deliveries, as well as take out. You will not be disappointed.“

“I’ve frequented Leonardo’s Pizza Cafe and it never disappoints. From the warm greeting by Leonardo himself to the expertly crafted dishes, it’s a gem. While the pizza is top-notch, don’t miss out on the eggplant and baked ziti. Every bite takes me back to my hometown of Campania. Truly a culinary haven.“

“If I ever want some good pizza, garlic knots or hot wings, I am ordering from Goomba Johnny's!! Should be the go to pizza shop in Selden!! Great food and fast delivery...Always good traits to have when you are a restaurant...lol Looking forward to ordering new items off the menu!! ?“

“This is a great pizzeria. This is a family owned business and it's definitely a gem that offers a wide variety of pizza variations and to be honest the food there is great. The service is great there if Luigi is there tell him Frank says hello. The ambiance is cozy.“

“You always get your moneys worth when buying pizza here, the pizza slices are huge!. And the prices are still reasonable, I come all the way from Middle Island just to buy their pizza because I know I will always get my moneys worth.And I live much closer to the other big pizza place in Middle Island that charges more money, and the slices are always smaller. And that’s a fact!“

“I have never ordered from here before. We ordered a plain pie, pepperoni pie and garlic knots. I couldn't be any more happy with what we got. Let's talk about old school knots.... the ones your Grams used to make!!! Delicious. So we're the pizzas!!! We will now be regulars!“

“Had the best Sicilian slice I have ever had today, hands down! Just the right thickness (to much dough is no good) and crispy crustSauce was amazing. Husband had the grandma style and loved it. Definitely worth the trip and we will be back for that chicken cutlet parm hero!“

“Best food Ever!!. Highly recommend“

“Port Jeff Bowl offers a fantastic experience I recently celebrated my child's birthday party there. The staff was exceptionally helpful and accommodating during the party planning process, ensuring that everyone had a blast. The venue effortlessly combines the nostalgic charm of classic bowling alleys with modern creature comforts. It truly captures the essence of old-school aesthetics while providing a delightful experience. I highly recommend Port Jeff Bowl for planning your child's next birthday party or for a memorable night out with the family. Additionally, don't miss the incredible live band performances on Friday nights, adding an extra layer of entertainment to your bowling experience.“

“The guy who worked there last night is a GEM! I ordered online close to closing and he still asked if I wanted cheese in my hero, put it on for me, and stuck it back in the oven. He also told me that if I called directly to the restaurant for a pick up order, it’s a few bucks cheaper. I had a rough day at work and needed comfort food that wasn’t fast food and he just made it that much better. Thank you!Eggplant parm hero also hit the spot! Will be back.“