7 Best American Restaurants near Sherman

“Let me paint the picture for you. We walked in and to the left are 5 older gentleman having coffee and chatting away. Soft music playing and the bakery items right straight ahead. You know it’s a local favorite. We went headed over and found a seat. One waitress and she knew the names of the customers. She was quick to get our drinks and take our order. We had the French toast muffins. She answered all our questions and was very personable. You could tell she liked her job. The food was fantastic, the atmosphere was great, the service was excellent. We will definitely be making the trip again to eat here.“

“The fried fish was good and crispy without being greasy, and the potato soup was yummy. The French silk pie was just too heavy and creamy for me, but I tried the coconut cream my friend ordered, and liked that filling much better! Others in my group were not as pleased with some of their meals. I liked the rustic and cozy atmosphere and decor, but the live music made it too loud to have any conversations, so we didn't enjoy that too much! Service was fast and friendly, so no complaints there!“

“Great food, really cool tavern, excellent service! I'm so happy that my friends and I stopped here for dinner while staying at the local Peak N Peak Resort. This tavern has a very "local" feel but we did not feel Unwelcome as tourists. The food was super good, we all left so full and it was very inexpensive!“

“Gluten and soy-free diner here. I was introduced to this quaint lakeside ice cream shop by my new wife and her family. The first time my wife was going to bring me back some ice cream from Krasa's, the staff was not 100% certain which flavors did not contain soy. Thus, she decided to wait until we could speak with the owner. Once we made contact, we were informed that the fruit-flavors were safe for me to consume. I decided to try the strawberry, and it was delicious! The last time we went, just before the shop closed for the season, I tried the peach, and it was chock-full of fruit! I look forward to when they reopen for the 2024 season. Thank you!“

“Had the most awesome fried haddock that I've eaten in a long time! The mashed potatoes were from scratch and the gravey was like my mom's. The portions were enormous! Rosina, our server, was great and really attentive. Her personality is so friendly and outgoing that you feel like your at the home of a friend!“

“Yo me and me white lady went to this joint and send pretty unassuming and inoffensive, but holy jerk, that chicken quesadilla is the best I have ever had. I had these all astound the world, I was in the air force, I have traveled the world and lemme tell you, this chix quesadilla might have saved my first marriage.“

“When visiting Chautauqua County today to see family and the eclipse, my wife and I took a drive to Meeder's to have a lite lunch before watching the eclipse. Meeder's was a favorite of mine in the 1960/70's when I lived in the area. The homemade pies were always a favorite. Well 50 years later I'm so happy to tell you that they are better than ever. If you are within an hour of this place, make time to take a trip back in time and enjoy what homemade food tastes like. From the Beef Vegetable soup to the pie...what a treat!!! Thank you for a wonderful trip down memory lane. Even though I used to get a slice of Banana Cream pie for $.50 and a 16 oz.bottle of Pepsi for a dime, it was almost the highlight of my trip. The eclipse edged out the Banana Cream pie. I guess they had to change their prices?“