18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Skaneateles

“What a great experience! Tony (our waiter) was amazing - he was so kind and accommodating, best waiter I think I’ve ever had. The food was out of this world. Big portions, flavorful, beautiful presentation. I’m not a bread pudding fan but get the bread pudding! It was absolutely amazing.Cozy ambiance in the evening. I wish every dining experience was this good, this place is a true gem. Oh - and really good little coffee menu! Their coffee was so delicious, I just loved the whole experience“

“I wish Gilda's were closer to where I lived! There are always two things I always get when I'm there: the beet salad and the burrata pizza. I always think I'll try something new but I end up going back for the same thing because they're just that good. I love the puree and the creamy burrata that goes with the beets, and the arugula on top of the pizza gives it that fresh finishing. I once ordered take out and Gilda's was wise enough to pack the arugula separately.“

“I ordered their fried dough it was absolutely delicious and I'm glad I only got the one portion a double portion would have been way too much The food is good the service is great I recommend this place for all your pizza and sub needsWheelchair accessibility: Handicap accessible“

“We stopped into this wonderful place during the Dickens Christmas 2023 festival and could not have left any happier. They have a great selection of pizza slices and side dishes ready to go along with plenty of made to order options. The food was delicious and sampled quite a bit of it. The icing on the cake was our group contained 6 adults and 2 small children and the bill for our feast was LESS than $100! Valentine's was a fun part of our day and will definitely be part of our plans when we return to Skaneateles.“

“great meal at a classic joint... their caesar salad with corn, tomato, red onion.. nice twist! braciole with gnocchi, polenta appetizer, super professional friendly service.. nice on the way home after little road trip! always busy always good.. dependable go to when in that area!“

“Very Friendly people real clean place. And the owner is awesome.. The best food in Elbridge ny New York.“

“This place is a little hidden gem in Elbridge, NY. If you are a local, I am sure you have tried it and already know how awesome their food is! If you're traveling, make sure to venture over and check them out; you won't be disappointed. Fast, friendly service,, and they prepare some awesome food! The chicken parm is my "go to". Prices are very reasonable, portions are HUGE, all home- made ingredients. You can't go wrong! Delicious!!“

“A perfect hole in the wall the food is always great the bartenders are always super nice they always make sure that you have what you need and the atmosphere is full of nice people kind of a farmer crowd a hard workers will go there it's a great barParking: Big parking lotWheelchair accessibility: They have a wheelchair ramp“

“I love going to that place in eating pizzathey have the most amazing New York style pizzathat when I'm in the mood for New York style that's where I go again, the food. It's amazing from the people who owns it for a wonderful human being to the people around. God bless you all and thank you again.??‍ ??“

“Picked this place from the good reviews and that it was open Mondays for lunch. Only one guy working but he professionally balanced taking orders, callers, and cooking. Pizza and wings were great. Knots are just perfect as well.Wish they had more seating, or at least not barstool seating, but no biggie.Parking: Free street parking if you can find it. Town is small enough you should have to walk far.“

“It's located in a a shopping plaza. They have ample parking.I've walked in here a few times now before and grabbed a slice. They always have a wide variety available to choose from. Everything always looks and tastes so good. Lots of different kinds of toppings on the slices they have available. They heat it up pretty quickly for you. They always seem to have a steady stream of traffic of people dropping in to get a slice to go.You can also it in.“

“Are waitress was absolutely fantastic.....Steak Sandwich and fries this Sandwich is sliced sirloin or chicken. It's enough for 2 people other sadwich is a BLT with fries very very good..... Hey big pile of fries for both of us.....Parking: A few parking spots on the street ....directly across the street is another parking lot which is very good size......“

“Mark's has consistently great customer service and whenever I get delivery, the food is hot and fresh (and it arrives fast!). Whoever manages this place is doing something right because every employee I encounter is friendly and efficient. Keep up the good work, Mark's!“

“Awesome food, great price, excellent staff . Had everything I favored/craved one of the best experiences I've had at weedsport ninos. Will definitely dine again.“

“Fantastic small town pizza place. Happy, friendly staff. My wife and I pick up from Sissy's a few times a month. They even have a gluten-free, cauliflower crust, which we absolutely love it!Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free, cauliflower crust available. My wife has Celiac disease and has not had a bad response to this, even if they cannot guarantee a totally gluten-free space. She is not super reactive to cross-contamination though.“

“I’m so glad we have this pizza shop in Jordan! If I could give 10/10 stars I would. I have never had a bad experience here, the staff is super friendly and food always shows up sooner than anticipated. Some of the absolute best pizza and subs I have ever had! I don’t understand the 1 star reviews, are you dealing with the same place that I am or do you just like to complain??“

“They are always fast and have your order exactly how you want it. We order from here at least once a week as a family .. even the picky little ones like it so we decided that's what we order for family night ... They even know you by name .it makes for a personal experience. I wish I had a photo to share .they have way more than just pizza ... Great food Pleasant people and local“

“As a truck driver I drive the Thruway a lot and with coffee shops not being open late this is one of my go-to stops. Mainly because they actually have cookies there that they bake .in house. If you're looking for a coffee and a treat fix definitely want to make a stop here. It is inside the pit stop gas station. And they also have food that is made to order. I will say I do wish they had some pizza out late at night but otherwise good service good coffee and good cookies“